str8aura*fluffle puff noises*•

Hilbert's Paradox of the Email Inbox

193
misplacederudite•

Gotta say, I read that as Hitler at first. The little computer in my brain that processes Tumblr posts did a spit-take.

63
Dr_Nue•

It malfunctions when it sees reddit instead.

25

Guess who made the same mistake? That's right, me. In all fairness, I finished a paper about my (German) city between 1933-1939 this week so the topic is still very present in my head.

11
misplacederudite•

I feel like you actually have a valid excuse whereas I just had a brainfart.

11
Quetzalbroatlus•

Hey. I don't like your Jinx/Heimer hybrid

2
CueDramaticMusic🏳️‍🌈 Least Horny Baiken Main 🖤🤍💜 125•

I don’t know enough high-brow mathematics lingo to describe what happens when someone says “there’s nothing worse than getting N email(s) (where N is equal to a countably infinite natural number) and then stubbing my toe.”

87
JayFromTheGreyZone•

I think.you just disappear down the rabbit hole of infinite ordinals at that point. (Also known as "what if there was a way to add 1 to infinity and have it actually be bigger?")

57
reedless•

Wouldn't the two sets be the same size though (ie countable infinity)? Since one is the set of all natural numbers and the other is the set of all natural numbers + k where k is a constant

19
TJSomething•

The thing is that we can have multiple concepts of "greater than" depending on how we define "numbers" and "equality".

By cardinality, we say that a number is a way of counting things in an unordered set. Then we can assign each element of a set to exactly one of the elements of another set, then we can say that the property they share is the number of elements.

Alternately, we use the ordinal definition, where the number is position in a ordered sequence of all the numbers.

For finite numbers, these are pretty much the same. 🍎🍎 + 🍎🍎 = 🍎🍎🍎🍎 works just like (the number that's after the first number) + (the number that's after the first number) = (the number that's after the number that's after the number that's after the first number). But at infinity, these differ in interesting ways.

We can say that there's a number after all of the numbers that can be constructed by adding "that's after the number" repeatedly to the first number, and then suppose the number after that. The shorthand for this number after the naturals is ω (pronounced "omega") and we call its successor ω + 1.

The cardinality of both ω and ω + 1 are the same: the countable infinity, ℵ₀ (pronounced "aleph zero"). So, in size, they're the same number. But because of how they are defined, we can talk about them separately in interesting ways. And that's really all you need in math.

Edit: Man am I a slow writer.

25
YouFoundShift•

you need to STOP THIS

3
JayFromTheGreyZone•

Once you get into infinite numbers, stuff gets weird. The two sets have the same cardinality (both countably infinite), and therefore the same size by one definition. But say you listed all the natural numbers (or any countably infinite set) and gave each element a label starting with 0, 1, 2, etc. You'd clearly use up all the natural numbers in your labeling, right? Then if you wanted to add another thing to the list, you've run out of labels to use. So you have to invent a new label, and we call that ω. Numbers used to label stuff like this are called ordinals, and the number ω is "the smallest ordinal that's bigger than any finite ordinal". And then you can do weird things with it, like: 1 + ω = ω, because you just shift all your labels over by 1 to accommodate the new element, but ω + 1 > ω, because by the time you get to the new element you've already run out of labels and had to use ω.

13
Tomer_Duer•

Since "worse then" has an order it would probably be "there are ω things worse then getting an email".

Or not. I don't actually understand it.

But what if you stub two, different toes?

3
CueDramaticMusic🏳️‍🌈 Least Horny Baiken Main 🖤🤍💜 125•

Oh yeah, toe stubbing is allowed to go on forever too, assuming a countable infinity of toes.

5
That_Mad_Scientist•

I have good news about human anatomy

3
jacw212•

“I’ve got bad news about the cardinality of natural numbers” is still one of my favorites sentences to come out of tumblr

58
Crescent_M0ON•

Image Transcription: Tumblr


yorickish-deactivated20220112

there's nothing worse than getting an email


official-kircheis

getting two emails


yorickish

there's one thing worse than getting an email


nightpool

i've got bad news about the cardinality of natural numbers


notajerusalemcricket

There's a countably infinite number of things worse than getting an email


^^I'm a human volunteer content transcriber and you could be too! If you'd like more information on what we do and why we do it, click here!

44
casperdewith•

Very nice, human.

2
SilverOverture•

Me, sweating with a red 1,540 icon on my mail app (・_・;

28
exceptionaluser•

Technically you cannot get infinite emails.

An email is a physical object that occupies a portion of space, so only a finite number can exist at once, and new ones can only be created so quickly.

Therefore, there's only an arbitrarily high number of things worse than getting an email.

20
BitUnWize•

While it may not be possible, getting one more than the max number of emails would still be worse. We also don't know for sure the universe is spatially and temporally finite.

7
GeophysicalYear57Ginger ale is good•

Counterpoint: if you reach the limit for the number of emails that can be displayed, then the number will wrap back around to a negative value and you’ll be happy

19
NomaTyx•

Actually that isn’t true. There’ll reach a point where the storage system of whatever email provider you use runs out and can’t receive any more emails.

8
That_Mad_Scientist•

I think at this point you have an entirely new problem on your hands, so I’m not sure it’s actually better

10
joshak•

There would be some point where you would reach the maximum number of emails possible to be read in a lifetime. After this point any additional emails would have no impact and therefore not be worse.

3
Dragonist777•

I am actually looking forward to one email that is gonna come soon

1
SirensToGoyou (derogatory)•

At least emails is on the naturals and so you don't have an uncountably infinite number of them

1
EmuEmperor•

Getting a phone call is worse than any number of emails

1
z0rbakpantsNemesor•

I'd say it's a converging sequence of badness though, you'll hit a point where the best way to solve the issue is Ctrl-A, Delete and if it's really important they'll send another email

1
Broad-Sound9208•

There’s only one thing worse than an email.

A child.

1
IdLikeToGoNowSparkelbruderärger•

Past a certain point it can be assumed the emails are no longer important and marked as spam

1
YouFoundShift•

so this is where the nerds hide out. i have found my people

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8
Aetol•

It's been six fucking years... Y'all are the ones who need to be told "get over it, she lost"

9