What is the exact rule around switching jobs with 30% ruling

Question

Among the history of 30% questions I couldn't find an answer to this one on the subreddit, apologies if I missed it.

I am aware that one is able to take the 30% ruling between employments with some rules. However, searching for specifics of this rule has lead to some confusion for me. Consider these following sources:

Belastingdienst [1]:

Hasn’t the employment contract been signed within 3 months? Please send us supporting documents that the employment contract has been effectuated within this period.

iamexpat [2]:

The gap between your previous job and the new one cannot be more than three months.

30percentruling [3]:

the 30% ruling will remain applicable for the remaining duration, provided that the period between the end of the employment at the previous Dutch employer and the formation of the employment contract with the new Dutch employer is no longer than three months.

Blueumbrella [4]:

The application should be submitted within three months of the end of employment with the previous employer.

As you can see, the advice seems to range from "have a contract signed within 3 months" through "start the job within 3 months" and even "submit application within 3 months".

I'm inclined to say that the truth is "start the job within 3 months", particularly when I look at this court case summary on expatnl [5]:

Change of employer with 30% ruling: If you have already obtained the 30% ruling and you would like to change employer, then you can still re-apply through the new employer as long as you were not unemployed for more than 3 months between jobs.

However, since the first link was the belastingdienst form which just mentions signing a contract, I wasn't sure.

Any advice would be much appreciated, thank you!

1: https://download.belastingdienst.nl/belastingdienst/docs/applic_2021_Inc_tax_nat_insur_lh5981z21foleng.pdf

2: https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/dutch-tax-frequently-asked-questions-about-30-percent-ruling

3: https://www.30percentruling.com/new-employer/

4: https://www.blueumbrella.nl/faq/30-ruling/change-of-employer-with-the-30-ruling

5: https://expatax.nl/knowledge-base/continuation-of-the-30-ruling-conflicts-with-the-three-months-requirement/

Posted Mar 24, 2022, 1:37 PM UTC

07
Typical_Investment65Knows the Wiki•

The terms from the belastingdienst are correct from my recent experience; the contract just needs to be signed within 3 months. The entire period in between contracts is deducted from your 5 year period though

4
HuggernautOPKnows the Wiki•

Can you say more about your experience here, since the other posts seem to disagree. Thanks!

0
Typical_Investment65Knows the Wiki•

This is what the advisory firm that did my application said. Technically I was just more than 3 mos between roles (ended on 31st of month, 3 months break, started on 1st) and I got my ruling transferred. If in doubt just reach out to an advisory firm, it’s the safest

2
HuggernautOPKnows the Wiki•

Thanks. I am in touch with a tax advisor, but would you mind sharing the company that helped you so that maybe I can reach out to them as well?

1
DeathKnightWhoSaysNiKnows the Wiki•

I’ve successfully transferred my ruling to new employers - my take has always been you have to start the job within 3 months.

Mostly because contracts can be reneged prior to start dates, which would then impact the window of time.

3
Duochan_MaxwellKnows the Wiki•

The original Dutch text from the belastingdienst says:

"Vraag samen met uw nieuwe werkgever toestemming of uw beschikking voor de 30%-regeling geldig kan blijven. Dat kan als u binnen 3 maanden na afloop van uw oude baan gaat werken voor uw nieuwe werkgever.

Doe uw aanvraag binnen 4 maanden nadat u bent begonnen bij uw nieuwe werkgever. Dan mag u vanaf de 1e werkdag bij uw nieuwe werkgever gebruikmaken van de 30%-regeling."

Which is

"Make a joint request with your new employer for your 30%-ruling to be kept valid. That is possible if you go work for a new employer within 3 months of ending your contract with the new one.

Place your request within 4 months of beginning with your new employer. Then it is possible that you use your 30%-ruling from the 1st day of employment with your new employer"

The exact rule is

  1. You have 3 months from leaving your job to start a new job (contract end and contract start dates)
  2. You have 4 months from starting your new job to make a 30% ruling request

What you're quoting is what you should do in case you don't have the contract to prove item 1

2
HuggernautOPKnows the Wiki•

What you're quoting is what you should do in case you don't have the contract to prove item 1

Right, I was mainly pointing at the "contract signed" bit, which is different from "job started".

I think "job started" is the most obvious conclusion, it just seemed like strange wording.

Thank you for your translation!

1