Unpopular Opinion On Racial Training

Probably gonna get downvoted but oh well...

I feel like some of the videos are actually promoting racism. Especially module 3. I guess they technically taught what they said they would... Racism Training aka Training to be Racist.

Also all I’ve learned so far is confirmation that I’ve been discriminated against and that racism only exists for a select few groups (not my belief) 😞

Edit: Glad to know I wasn’t crazy in thinking this.

Posted Mar 25, 2022, 1:52 AM UTC · edited

23940
Deep-Gur-573•

The one that was like what would you do in the scenario that a white woman receptionist gets frustrated that a black mother was late because she couldn’t find child care and the receptionist asked why couldn’t the father take care of the kid. Like we are asked how we would intervene without knowing any information about if the father is in the picture. This scenario is just teaching us to assume that black fathers aren’t there which is so fucked up and racist and this scenario is teaching us to act upon that.

245
MarineroDelMar•

Talking with POC who have taken the discrimination "training," it seemed like they also were very uneasy by Northeasterns approach to this question. Kinda felt like they were teaching us to be shallow, stereotyping Social-Justice Warriors. SJW shouldn't mean inserting yourself into situations you are uninformed or ill-equiped to call out. Kinda pathetic how backwards this institution targets discrimination and title 9

17
KingOfCubesCOE CE/CS - (Ex) Elections Chair•

Robin D'Angelo was one of the academics they quoted in the early modules, and she has a...controversial view on race, to say the least. most academics are skeptical of her arguments but she's been able to capitalize on the greater DEI push of a lot of companies recently, and has made a ton of money by grifting off of it

it's pretty sad they couldn't do proper background research for this stuff. this sort of training is really important, but it unsurprisingly ended up being virtue signally garbage

Edit: I wouldn't go so far as to say this promoted racism, I think. I think it's just pretty useless without any penalty for not doing it. Honestly think it would've been better to read a couple of passages out of some books and write a short response. At least you can't mindlessly click through - - you gotta think at least a little bit

115
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

I'd imagine it's logistically difficult to mandate an assignment for the whole student body and not have it be mindlessly easy especially when it's not part of a class. We all had to go through a few other modules during our first years that were similarly mindless about drugs and alcohol and sexual assault and other larger schools seem to all do this the same way. I think the latter especially should not be so mindless but I'd imagine there are a lot of tradeoffs involved when you have to do it on that scale and have everyone pass.

18
I_am_so_lost_hello•

Can't pass module 3 because it won't let me choose bisexuals as priviledged

they have twice the dating options

73
vtdadbod007•

Hook, line, sinker, you caught some fish with this one😂

I, a bisexual, laughed and found this very funny on record lmao

24
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

yeah i think i got jebaited

1
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

Please be bait please be bait please be bait

16
Auzaro•

Relax

3

Wait, I know this is a joke, but does it seriously not let you pass if you have the “wrong opinions” about which groups are privileged or not? Bruh this is a university not an indoctrination

13
war6795CCIS•

i am more confused on how you got from being taught “lgbt people are less privileged” to “we are being indoctrinated into liberal groupthink”

all learning can be seen as “indoctrination” if you want to look at it that way, ie as a cs major i program a certain way because of school. it’s up to you to decide if you think it’s right but i feel like it’s hard to argue that lgbt people aren’t socially disadvantaged

15

I understand that, but like, it’s a subjective opinion. From someone’s perspective one group might be more disadvantaged, from someone else’s perspective they might come to a different conclusion. These are subjective judgements, they aren’t scientific facts. I’m not talking about that example specifically, but it’s kind of bullshit that they’re prescribing for us which groups are more disadvantaged than others instead of letting us use critical thinking and coming to our own conclusions.

3
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

Ok at the risk of taking the bait I really should explain why this is dumb because this is a disturbingly common take.

The biggest problem I see with this is that bi people still face many of the same problems that people who are only attracted to the same gender do. They are often ostracized by their families, friends, partners, and coworkers for being attracted to the same gender all the same even if they are not in relationships of any kind. This can also result in losing your job, housing or other forms of financial security. There are also plenty of other dimensions to it but I figure this on its own should at least outweigh any privileges that allegedly being able to date more people sometimes should bring.

4†
Despicable-Llama•

But… twice the dating options.

17
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

I see no possible way that someone could read all that and then sincerely say "but more options" so on off chance that you're actually serious

That's a big generalization. If you live in an area where the majority of people are homophobic your dating options are way lower than normal even if you are attracted to other genders. You also obviously cannot date straight people of the same gender (which is most of them) so its nowhere near twice even in the most mathematically ideal conditions. Further, I see no way in which being attracted to more people grants you any sort of meaningful privilege. If someone can show me a study saying that people who are attracted to people of all hair colors for example are more privileged somehow than people who are only attracted to people with dark hair I'll believe otherwise.

2†
Kitchen_Somewhere207echo 'ccis'•

but you can date literally twice as many people... 2x >= x... simple mathematics

7
Pyrobot110•

Also at risk of taking the bait: This is disgustingly wrong and beyond ignorant.

First off, this neglects to consider bisexuality as a spectrum. I am bisexual, I am attracted to multiple genders, but I strongly prefer guys. This far from doubles the dating pool and is already a gaping hole in this poorly thought out logic. Some people will fall more towards the middle, other towards the extremes, and some in between, it's not at all a shared experience.

Second, 'twice the dating options' fails to consider that people of the same gender they identify as also have to be attracted to the same sex in some way. As a guy, if I have a crush on 30 guys and only 1 or 2 of them are attracted to other guys, then my possibilities for dating are not 30, but instead 1 or 2.

Third, people who are bisexual are very, very often invalidated by everyone. Both people who are straight, gay, etc. often tell us that we just haven't made up our mind/are indecisive right now. If we're in a hetero relationship, we're labeled as straight and to say anything else would be seen as wrong. If we're in a homo relationship, we're labeled as gay and to say anything else would be wrong.

Additionally, many people are paranoid over bisexual people not being 'fulfilled' by 1 partner and requiring multiple partners of multiple genders to 'satisfy bisexual urges'. This is blatantly false, yet further reduces the dating pool as people wrongly assume that we're unable to stay committed to a monogamous relationship based on our orientation and nothing else.

0†
PopcornFuelCOE: BIOE•

Maybe not as unpopular as you think... I noticed it too.

67
Elonmustycuck•

Can someone summarize module 3?

35
whatizzwrongwithme•

Its just talking about white privilege. Its basically says that white people/heterosexuals (the majority) are seen as the standard in our society, which is true because white people made and formed the laws and society (of the US). As a result of that, white people usually never have to think about their race and how it plays a part in their identity like POC do. The video brings up an example of how being in a predominately white high school makes you ill-equipped to interact with people outside of your race due to never being around them (which is true in the same way that many people at NEU don't know how to interact with international students and vise versa.) They talk about how white privilege gives white people advantages over the minority, like inclusion in media and bias. There is nothing racist about it at all. Like not even a little bit. I thought it was gonna be something like "you can't be racist against white people" that people get so mad over but it literally isn't. It's a fact of life and of society that people are given privilege for being of a certain race/income/etc. Literal baby brain post

64

Counterpoints:

As a result of that, white people usually never have to think about their race and how it plays a part in their identity like POC do.

No one “has to” think about their race.

The video brings up an example of how being in a predominately white high school makes you ill-equipped to interact with people outside of your race due to never being around them

This just sounds like straight-up stereotyping white kids from low-minority areas. I went to a predominantly white high school that had a few East Asians, a few black kids, a few South Asian kids, etc. I don’t feel “ill-equipped” to interact with them at all. In fact it’s a little insulting to be told that I’m ill-equipped to interact with perfectly normal people who just happen to have a different skin color simply because I’m from a majority-white area.

They talk about how white privilege gives white people advantages over the minority, like inclusion in media and bias.

This isn’t necessarily true. There are some areas where being white gives an advantage, but also other areas where being a minority is an advantage. Minorities (not just racial minorities) are consistently over-represented in the media compared to their population proportion, with the possible exception of the Latino population. Furthermore, sometimes opportunities are afforded to minorities that aren’t afforded to the majority. As we’re at a private university, I’m sure you’ve heard of Affirmative Action? These sorts of “diversity” programs explicitly give an advantage to minority applicants. So I thoroughly reject the idea that white people (and other majority populations) are consistently advantaged; advantage does exist in some situations, but disadvantage exists in others. I just wish everyone would just stop giving such a crap about what color people’s skin was at all, it’s ridiculous.

-37
whatizzwrongwithme•

Congrats bro

the dumbest fucking reply on Reddit of all time. Astounding. Tone deaf and ignorant in every way possible yet so bold and proud of it at the same time

44
[deleted]•

[deleted]

27
PinKro•

Imagine not having to think about why XYZ happens to you, only to realize that it was because you're black/latino/asian/any other minority.

"Thinking about your race" is not something we are taught, is something we realize on our own, because people DO treat you differently depending on how you look like.

Congrats on having an easier life I guess?

26

That’s not always true though.

Especially with the prevalence of “diversity outreach” programs, there are plenty of times when white people are explicitly turned away or given a lower chance due to their race. Affirmative Action, for example. So yes, white peoples can absolutely have those questions too.

You know what would make all those problems go away? If everyone just stopped giving a crap about race.

1
EmpiricalMonarch•

As somebody who sees the arguments from both sides in this thread, I disagree with your first and second counterpoints.

Subconscious biases are everywhere (in fact, from what I’m seeing in this thread, they may be present in this training). Minorities (it doesn’t matter what race) suffer from subconscious biases. They then have to think about how they are perceived as a result of that and try to correct for and avoid such beliefs and behaviors. So, yes, some people have to think about their race.

Your second counterpoint is an analogy; it’s your personal experience. People who did not grow up with others who look different than them are more likely to exhibit these beliefs and behaviors than people who did grow up in diverse racial and ethnic areas.

I agree with you that the goal shouldn’t be to target white students when it comes to these lessons because these principles happen all over the world with different racial and ethnic makeups… But where we live, white is the majority.

I know this module set may be just another example of an ill-equipped way to address racism, but the critical need is very much there and as a white guy myself, we need to be able to have these discussions without immediate ‘on the defense’ arguments.

13

It’s a little hard not to be on the defensive when the premise I’m confronted with essentially boils down to “whether you mean it or not, you are racist and need to change that, especially if you’re white.”

-28
vtdadbod007•

There was a post on here a while back about RA’s getting handed a pamphlet on race and protected categories that was more or less labeled as “here’s what gives you privilege and here’s what you should feel like people discriminate against you because of.” I genuinely love this university, but for Pete’s sake they just plain SUCK at trying to promote diversity and understanding. They’re easily more racist than any issues they’re trying to combat.

19
I_Hate_Chevy_AdsCOE•

Do you have a more specific example of what was said that promotes racism? That's a pretty bold claim

18
del564COS•

Also they refer to Latino people as 'Latinx' as if Latino people like using that word to describe themselves. One of my friends showed me a poll where something like 40% of Latino people found the term 'Latinx' offensive (and also the friend who showed me the poll is Latina and she hates Latinx). And yet Northeastern is using it in their training on how to be more considerate and less racist towards poc lol

14
lillobby6•

What’s even more annoying is that Latinx is an Anglicization. In Spanish Latinx makes absolutely no sense - Latine would be better, but it’s still not great.

Spanish is a romance language in which words are gendered and typically the male form is used for a mixed-gender group (i.e. using Latino to refer (collectively) to a group of both Latino men and Latina women).

Latinx is a way for white people to feel better about themselves without considering how latinos feel.

5
flammable8•

Agreed. Northeastern shouldn’t waste our money on this crap.

5
husky_neu_229•

No chance I'm doing this bullshit thanks for speaking on this

5
neu_mikelitteris•

Being racially woke is rooted in subconscious racism more-times than not

4†
freekoffhoe•

wait there’s no penalty for not doing it? they don’t put a hold on your account or something?

2
CEO__of_Antifa•

No one knows, it says mandatory but last semester it said the same thing and they just pushed back the due date

3