r/eu4•
cavalierfool

Expel Minorities rehash . . .

Question

Hey all y'all!

Although I've played colonizer before as Castile/Spain and France several times, I've just started exploring Portugal. As Portugal is clearly a colony and trade co. heavy nation, I was trying to understand a mechanic that failed me in previous games, but wasn't significant enough to delve into at the time.

​

After reading several posts (here, wiki, para forum, etc.) about Expel minorities, spread across several years, I am now more confused then when I first *thought* I didn't understand.

​

Previously, in one of my first Castile games, I had tried relentlessly to expel the moors from Andalusia with 0 success. Think there's a mission that had difficulty completing because of this, even though I ran out of new world provinces to colonize. I think I ended up spending on culture conversion to get rid of them for some negligible dip reward. I dismissed as my not understanding something, and ever since I've just ignored Expel. With France, I didn't bother sorting it out, as I was more of conquering colonizer.

​

For today, I am early in my Portugal game, have just completed Cape Verde and am looking at my first new world colony. I have conquered most of Morocco - all their coastline and through to the Tafilate gold mine. 24% of my dev is Moroccan. I already kind of screwed up by stating North Morocco instead of putting it into a trade company (forgot it would affect all Iberia).

​

The option for Expel Minorities comes up, allowing me to send Moroccans or Sunni out of Ceuta. It is currently the only non separatist colony with a minority.

​

I *feel* that I understand:

  • The tool tip re: Expel is wrong and should be ignored.
  • Expelling does NOT change the culture or religion of the origin Province
  • Expelling does reduce the development of the origin Province
  • Expelling does NOT send culture or religion of the origin Province to Colony (at least as Castile all I ever got were Castilian Catholics, never once a Andalusian or Sunni colony occurred)
  • Expelling does increase the development of the Colony equivalent to the loss in the origin Province

​

I *know* that I don't understand:

  • what the percentage and number represent in the expel minorities dialogue, where it appears to indicate 1 development and 0.70% chance of something. However, in observations during Castile game, the # of dev didn't seem to have any affect, and I have no idea that the less than 1% chance is?
  • Does Expelling an "Accepted" minority do anything different? Is it a minority because it's not accepted or because it's not my True Blood original culture? I'd really like to accept that 24% of my dev that is Morocco - will I have to wait until I've established colonies from Morocco to accept, or can I spread Moroccan in say Brazil and Portuguese in La Plata?
  • How about Religion? I want to force a Sunni conversion of Portugal. I've never done a rebel conversion and Portugal seems small enough to make it functional, and that would get me out of the Treaty of Turtlesighs, allowing a more diverse colonial experience with my "?friend?" Castile and/or Aragon. Will Expelling Sunni to the colony help lay the ground work for that?
  • Am I really just stripping Morocco to have a less than 1% chance to maybe expel a minority? maybe increase the dev? maybe get the new religion spread without a missionary? Maybe . . . ?I don't know what?
  • If it does send the origin religion or culture to the colony . . . how would that be helpful in more normal situations, with no Sunni overhaul planned?

Am I wasting time, is this just a dead mechanic that I'm overthinking and should ignore?

​

No particular screen shot seemed useful, they say a picture is worth a thousand words, so I tried to make an even trade.

Any clarity than can be provided would be much appreciated, if you took the time to read this much, you are appreciated even if you don't have good advice or two cents :)

(for reference, I'm up to date, all DLCs)

Posted Mar 25, 2022, 10:35 PM UTC

45
Shitpost_Deus_Vult•

I'm not the most familiar with expel minorities myself, but I think your struggles with the tooltip may be due to how it originally worked, when it basically functioned as a way to convert religion and culture in the original province, while settling with the minority.

2
cavalierfoolOP•

I definitely confirmed tool tip is wrong lol I'm carefully experimenting, trying to send sunni to Brazil, got several settler buffs in a row so growing fast. Will see soon, cuz the first colony will happen before I have no expel cost. Then I can compare second

1
gdo01•

Sorry for the late reply but I just found this thread while searching. Did you get your answer? As far as I can tell, it creates dev in a colony by lowering dev in a chosen province. The minority part no longer matters or is relevant since you can expel any culture. I haven’t looked at the actual numbers but in theory it could still be used to eventually culture convert a province but only because it would lower its dev making it easier to convert.

2
cavalierfoolOP•

Ehh, I never found an explanation of the percent numbers.

No combination of things ever seemed to effect the outcome, except the dev transfer.

When a colony is complete (new world, Africa, islands, or Siberia) I either get my main culture, or the culture the province originally had, and I get either my state religion or the local religion.

In recent match I ended up with colonies that were Aragon Fetishists and Mali Protestants lol.

I think that has to do with how long you leave a colonist at the colony. I usually move them on to the next one once the trade good is set and usually have between 2x and 3x colonies per colonist.

I feel when I've pulled the colonist early is when I get the oddball culture-religion cross like Aragon Fetishist

1
gdo01•

I’m pretty sure the actual mechanism has been stripped to just be basically the opposite of transferring dev to the capital. The culture seems to always be the dominant accepted culture for me. The “role play” of it I guess is that small numbers of people of a certain culture are being transferred overseas to the colony but not enough to change the dominant culture. Before I really knew what I was doing, as Spain I had stripped Gibraltar down to 1,1,1 dev from exporting so many Andalusians.

I don’t think it’s really useful unless you are choosing to give your colonies a better chance at surviving on their own. That is for colonial subject nations. For old world colonies and trade companies, I think it’s a complete waste of dev. In either case, the dev is usually in better hands concentrated within the parent nation rather than spread out all over the world. But that’s the roleplay imperialism talking.

1