Wondering about thirst posts

NSFW

Hey all!

Lately I've been wondering - all those thirst posts and "step on me"s and suchlike: they don't do anything for me. Like, I'm reasonably sure I'm not ace; I am a sexual being, I enjoy sex, I feel sexual attraction - but not to celebrities, or even just images. I wouldn't use a simple picture to masturbate, for example; doesn't do anything for me, again. I need to either read some smut, or envision sexy actions, to get going. When I meet someone and find them attractive (as in, I vibe with them to the point when I can envision doing sexual things with them), then I can get super horny and all - but not over a zero context picture of someone I don't know personally, no matter how beautiful or how much naked skin. I don't think demisexual fits the bill either; I can and have felt sexual attraction to someone I just met. But I have to have exchanged a few words with them at least; I've never wanted to jump someone who sat opposite me on a train, much less a celebrity I never even were physically near to.

Now, I'm not yucking this at all; go do your things, you funky little lesbians! I'm just wondering if there are others who feel like me, or if someone who does get excited by, like, pin-ups etc. might explain how it feels for them?

Posted Mar 26, 2022, 8:47 AM UTC

4419
Ness303•

You're fine. There's no one way to get aroused. Don't overthink it. Most women in particular need more than visual stimuli.

Being sexual interested in someone you just met based on physical features but needing to know more than their name is one of the most common ways to experience attraction. It's really rare to find someone who would be okay to have sex with someone with no knowledge of the other person, that's not safe.

Jumping someone you just met? That's a movie fantasy for bored heterosexual housewives. Even casual hookups happen after conversations occur.

A lot of the "step on me mummy" cringe posting is just that..cringe posting from younger people who might not have enough experience in a real world sexual setting.

32
purlturtleOP•

Thanks for the reassurance - the people I see reblogging this stuff are firmly middle aged, like me, thirty upwards (I'm 42, don't know if I said in my original post). The vibe I get from their other posts is that, again like me (though I might be projecting; who knows other people on Tumblr, really), they're relatively settled in their identities.

7
Ness303•

The internet gives a level of anonymity. They're most likely being "horny on main" because it's the only time they can. It's a bit cringe, especially since it's something I associate with younger people, but it doesn't mean there is anything wrong with you.

Sometimes it's an online version of talking a big flirting game. Typically, the sorts of people who do this really wouldn't know what to do if someone actually responded.

8
purlturtleOP•

Please take this with a lot of kindness: I don't need reassurance that there isn't anything wrong with me. I know that :) and I'm not worried about the people who post that stuff, either. I just wanted to hear if other people feel like I do, and hear from people for whom these thirst posts actually do something.

Thank you for your reassurances - I know they come from a good place, and I appreciate that. They go slightly to the left of what I'm looking for, is all.

5
Ness303•

I don't know what it is you're looking for, but clearly you're searching for something. You're worries can be summed up as: You're fine. You have an average person's experience with how your sexuality functions.

3
wishIwere•

Demisexual isn't monolithic. I am definitely demisexual in that I have no real desire to have sex with someone without some kind of emotional connection (absent alcohol or a few other rare exceptions) but I still feel primary physical attraction to people or pictures of people. Like I wouldn't actually want to have sex with them without an emotional connection but that doesn't mean the idea of sex isn't still appealing.

14
BulbasaurBoo123•

Yeah I've struggled to know whether to identify as demisexual, because I can look at a picture and think the person is sexually attractive - and maybe enjoy the idea of fantasising about them if I'm in the right mood. But I find if I meet someone in person and they want casual sex, even if my libido is relatively high at the time, my desire tends to evaporate. It seems like my actual desire for real life sexual activity is tied more to building a mental connection with someone.

5
wishIwere•

Yeah I am the same it can take me quite some time building emotional and mental connection before I have a real desire to have sex even if I find myself very physically attracted to that person. Every time I have had sex without that first I have not enjoyed it at all.

3
purlturtleOP•

And see, that's where it's different for me. I can have and enjoy sex at basically the drop of a hat.

The thing is, and maybe I didn't word that right: I don't think I'm ace or demi, since I know I experience sexual attraction - but not for or over pictures, or someone I don't know at all.

5
wishIwere•

Ah. Ok now I understand. Even so, everyone's attraction works differently. I would wager that people who enjoy thirst trap posts aren't actually even the majority they just happen to be more visible because they comment and such.

2
i_sing_anyway•

I'm demisexual and I enjoy sex at the drop of a hat, and I'm not at all into pictures. For most demi people that's because they need to have an emotional connection, and it sort of is for me too? But I think most people define that emotional condition as love, or at least a crush/infatuation/like/respect/trust. For me it's a LOT more ambiguous than that. It can be mannerisms that really grab me, it can be learning something about their character like they support the same charity as me. It can be little, like the way they smell, or the way their body moves. And usually NONE of those things come across in a picture, or with someone who's a complete stranger.

One of the most mind blowing experiences of my life was re-evaluating my laminated celebrity list with a partner once I came out as demi. You know those lists- 5 celebrities that if you actually had the opportunity to sleep with you could, and your partner wouldn't care. I think it's from a 90s show and ours weren't serious, but basically a way to celebrity gossip. Anyway, I had a totally mind blown moment realizing that he ACTUALLY would want to fuck any of the celebrities on this list. The ones on my list were aesthetically attractive to me, but not arousing, unless I knew specific quirky things about them. Even then, how do I know if they're mean to animals or have terrible coffee breath all the time?

Demi is a lil different for everyone, but I think "conditional attraction" is a fair summary. So for me the thirst traps are off putting if they're low effort or seem desperate, completely neutral if the person is aesthetically attractive and that's all, and actually attractive/arousing if the person says something that clicks for me like making a bad pun, or "who wants to go on a picnic date?"

1

Yeeeah I'm kind of the same. Random images/thirst traps do almost nothing for me, and when someone asks if we can exchange pics I usually tell them they're welcome to look at my Instagram but I'm not going to exchange pics over DM because it does nothing for me. And taking sexy pics when I'm not in the mood is a chore.

Attraction is a very complex and individualized reaction. Other factors like smells, voice, eye contact, mannerisms, lifestyle, and many many other things come into play. It's hard or impossible to gage any of that from a photo or short video.

13
purlturtleOP•

Thank you, that sounds really very close to what I experience! Thanks for sharing, this means a lot to me!

3
DykeHime•

Yeah, I don't really get those posts either. Just don't do anything for me, beside sounding a bit cringy sometimes. 🤷‍♀️ And I also feel like needing some kind of personal connection before really wanting to be intimate with someone. Now, this doesn't have to be a super deep, emotional thing, and it might happen quickly... But it still needs to happen first.

4

I mean I can look at a pic and think 'oh she's hot, would smash' but that doesnt mean I want to smash

3
raisaroq•

I feel similarly, though I am occasionally interested in visuals, it's mostly artwork that might accompany a story or text. It's kind of like sprinkles or something on cake, I don't *need* or necessarily seek them out, but if they're there and the kind I find cheery, they add to the experience.

For me, my ability to be attracted to someone is mostly emotional? It's all wrapped up in like, warm fuzzy feelings of friendship-romantic affection.

While I can appreciate the aesthetics of other people, I don't actively seek out pics or videos unless I'm drawing and want a reference / model. I think there's also like, the term is eluding me, but there's the way people experience things? Some people really love visuals, some prefer written words, and others like audio without visual accompaniment. Nothing weird, I think, people are just built different and it's fascinating.

And then the more I thought about this while writing it, the more I can relate to not really feeling thirst for a celebrity or stranger. I mostly feel awkward when I see someone else's pictures. :x I guess that's why I prefer artwork and stories, it feels less... I don't know? Invasive? I'm honestly having a hard time finding the right word to fit how I feel, but it's definitely somewhere along the lines of "uncomfortable".

2
TheNewt181•

I'm a <20 young person, and I definitely understand how you feel.

For me, in the way you described, a picture, (even if they are showing skin or even nude) doesn't get me going at all.

Attraction as well is very similar for me. My dad was always pointing out ladies that most people would consider very attractive, and was always asking, "do you think she's pretty?". I hated it, but for me, I have to know a person. I'm attracted to who they are primarily, and less what they look like. So sexual thoughts or fantasies definitely rely on some knowledge or connection to the person for me. Suffice it to say, you're not alone in how you feel.

2
purlturtleOP•

Thank you! That's very reassuring to hear!

1
legaladult•

I don't feel for thirst posts, but mostly due to personal issues with feeling like I'm allowed to desire anybody or assume that I deserve that kind of attention. Sort of similar situation with blanket validation posts -- I'm glad they work for others, but because you don't know me personally, and are not saying this directly to me, for me, I am not feeling the intended reaction. It bounces off me.

1