Is it okay to auto start and shutdown nightly for a few hours to do backups. Or is it better to leave it on all the time?

There are several considerations. I have a DS216j. I don't need to backup much, just a few hundred mb of photos a day via script. On summer days the drives can get kinda hot. 110°c +. I've had drives that fail within 3-4 years range which seems short for WD Reds so I'm thinking it's heat related. Finally, startup seems to trigger indexing so may be unnecessary wear on drives.

Posted Mar 26, 2022, 4:44 PM UTC

15
arkTanlis•

A true NAS drive is designed to run continuously. Starting it up introduces unneeded wear on it.

If your drive is getting that warm, you need to move it or provide some air circulation. That is way too hot. Mine are currently sitting at 29C / 84F and that is sitting on a desk wide open.

6
forceclosedOP•

Circulation could be the issue. I do have other networking equipment next to it. I'll try rearranging or a new location. Thank you!

2
fakemanhk•

Are you talking about 110F? 110C I believe your NAS case should start to melt?

If it’s 110F nothing much to worry about, most HDD have a limit about 60C which is 140F, my drives has been running at 50C for 6 years without problem.

2
forceclosedOP•

Ha! Yes, I meant F. So, if heat isn't the problem and I don't put much load daily. Now I'm curious what other factors could reduce the life of my drive.

1
fakemanhk•

My previous experience of working in a data center, drives keep running tends to be less problematic, somehow after maybe 1 or 2 years when there is a power maintenance and some of them wouldn't come back again.

My previous 160G SATA drive running in a mail server for 11 years, there were only less than 40 reboots in total.

2