What type of therapy do you need and how do you find out? AKA "What the heck is existential therapy?"

Help / Advice

Big post, sorry. A bit of a rant, but I really want input if you got it.
TL:DR I am incredibly lost with therapy, "the System" doesn't help me much, but I don't want to spend more time doing nothing. How do I even start to navigate this space?

I recently attended therapy with a therapist who adhered to Jungian Analysis I think. I still don't know if it was the right thing for me. As I gathered my mental energy to have that "meta-discussion", she declared she would be retiring, but recommended three other "Jungian" therapists.
And I am equal parts tempted to stay with what I know or try something very different.
Unfortunately I have no idea how to find out what is right for me.

I boot up the list of unionized therapists in my city (a somewhat reliable ward against quacks here), and within the first two dozen, I am met with many approaches from CBT, EFT, ACT, EMDR, hypnotherapy, existential therapy, psychoanalysis, and even more who use non-descript combinations or some holistic (while evidence-based) approach. Let alone whether I would benefit from coaching, or group/individual therapy.
Each of them holding a hammer, and insisting I got a nail. Who am I to ask if it's not actually a screw? I start researching, but I get nowhere before I am exhausted and realize I don't have the background to go beyond a layman's understanding.

Frankly, I struggle to even be consistent with whether or not I think I need (and deserve) therapy, so these repeated research sessions are both difficult and get me nowhere.
I am very cautious in researching "stuff I might suffer from" and stay clear of self-diagnosing, but I think my issues are generally in line with low self esteem, an avoidant attachment style and/or a depression that started out as stress-induced. If anyone have experience with certain types of help in situations like this, I'm all ears.

I'm becoming increasingly aware that in my head I keep a list of failures: Failed jobs, relationships, really any and all opportunity that didn't go as intended. And while on some days I have to wrestle that myself, I fear that if anyone is actually gonna get to know me, they are gonna have to face that list and accept me regardless.

Now, I'm deadly afraid of adding more to it in the very pursuit of better mental health. There is of course the point of picking something wrong, maybe even idiotic in hindsight. To beat myself up for time, that I could have spent with another therapist. Add a few "failed therapies" to the list.
But there is also the question of resources. That insurance funds are gonna run out while I fuck about with a therapist or a whole style of therapy I cant use. And though a kind relative offered to help me, in both cases I hate spending money I don't have on me, maybe even in ways that wont help.

Many people here are kind enough to tell people to get help, or to change therapist when things don't work out. It sounds so easy. But it betrays the sheer number of (often overwhelming) options.
While "just doing something" or trying whatever might be better than doing nothing, it fills me with dread, and I am so very lost.

Posted Mar 26, 2022, 8:48 PM UTC

78
amulshah7•

I'm familiar with a few of those therapies and looked up the ones I didn't know--I was initially going to suggest CBT, and after looking up some of the ones I didn't know, I would still suggest starting with CBT to see if that helps. CBT is one of the more evidence-based therapies out there and is used often to help treat some of the conditions that you have. I would put EMDR pretty low on the list of therapies to try, as I think that one would be least useful to you (unless the following applies to you)--EMDR is usually for people who have PTSD and/or who have been through traumatic experiences.

3
GrindoffOP•

Thanks for the input. I also came across the things like what you said about EMDR, but still one or two of the therapists I checked out said they dealt with things like depression and listed EMDR as (one of) their major methods.
Frankly that was one of the more frustrating part. Of course everyone is gonna say that what they practice is right, but you just end up with a long list of people insisting they got the answer.
I will definitely keep CBT as a high priority going forward.

Also just thanks for responding, it did a lot to make it feel less lonely.

1
Slamturtle_•

Hey, I hear that you're feeling super lost trying to find the right kind of therapy for you. That really, really sucks.

You said that you have low self-esteem, avoidant attatchment (burying your own needs/struggles for the sake of keeping people around you? If my understanding of that is correct?), depression that started out as stress-induced, very aware of your past failures which you are afraid will make others less likely to accept you.

The issues that you've identified for yourself describe me to a tee also, so I just felt like sharing what has been/is helpful for me.

The therapist that I see practices Pyschodynamic Therapy. Here's what I've experienced:

  • I feel very much heard, understood and accepted, unlike with anyone else. This is helps me feel like all of my feelings and thoughts matter (helps build self-esteem).
  • I'm not offered solutions or fixes to my problems (unlike CBT for example). The only thing we do is explore how I'm feeling, why I feel that way, and where those feelings come from. As I learn more about my feelings and where they come from, I feel more empowered, like I have more agency. The things I feel start to make more sense, which allows me to feel less ashamed about how I feel.

I guess it's like: less shame -> less weight on my shoulders -> can do more stuff

3
GrindoffOP•

That is some much appreciated input. It can sometimes feel like therapists just rep themselves in public, so its nice to hear from the perspective of a therapy-goer.
I do not recall seeing Psychodynamic Therapy among those I checked so far, but I will look into it further to see if its maybe called something else here, or if perhaps its labelled under broader or more narrow terms.

I have no experience with that or with CBT, but you seem to imply that its less about applying ideas directly than e.g. CBT. Do you personally feel as if it has borne fruit yet, or is it too early or perhaps intangible to tell?

I wish you the best going forward.

2
Slamturtle_•

Psychoanalysis and Psychodynamic seem to get lumped together from what I saw on Google. My guess is that any therapist that describes themselves as a psychotherapist would be similar to what I described?

The main "idea" I was given, and applied was self-compassion. And I think the reason for that was because every single thing that I struggle with would link back to me feeling worthless, and that I don't matter.

And yeah, I feel like I've made huge strides over the last year and a bit of therapy.

  1. I can recognize what needs I have, and can stand up for them/myself
  2. I've become much more comfortable with conversations, since I've learned that there is alot of value in just listening and understanding others.
  3. I've been able to do alot of stuff that I would never have done before (reaching out to old acquaintances, using meetup.com, attempting to work jobs).
2
[deleted]•

Sorry things are so rough. It makes sense that you feel so frustrated.

CBT is the style with the most research backing it up. And it works for an incredibly broad range of problems. It may not be the best treatment for everyone, but it's at least the third best treatment for everyone. If you're struggling, you'll never not be making progress with CBT. (Unless your therapist is a bad fit, which can still happen.)

In general, older styles are less effective.

3
GrindoffOP•

It seems people have good experiences with CBT, so I will keep that in mind.
Have you tried it? And if its not too much to ask, what for? Did you get something out of it?

1
isurollin•

Have you tried a gym therapy yet

1