Source
r/Eldenring•
GetReadyToJob

D and his twin brother[Spoilers]

SpoilerSpeculation

D and his twin brother, D, are two people who share one mind. They are never in the same place at one time but can communicate telepathically.

Fia says to give the weathered dagger to its original owner, who you would think would be alecto, but it is actually D. The weathered dagger seems to be the dagger that killed godwyn.

Ranni couldnt have cut that knife mark into her back on her own.

My theory is that D and his twin brother were a part of the ritual and were the actual murderers of both godwyn and ranni. They could kill both at the EXACT same time by communicating telepathically. The only reason they like the Greater Will is because they are accepted there, probably because they are similar to radagon/marika

Posted Mar 27, 2022, 12:43 AM UTC

38
yucker02:restored:•

If you find ds brother before fia kills d, he's stuck in a deathless sleep, only one of the twins can be conscious at any given time, they share one soul but have different minds, the Japanese concept of a soul is life energy and the mind and body are separate from a soul.

5
GetReadyToJobOP•

Oh i see. I must have missed parts of the quest. These games always have odd quest timings.

Thats interesting to know.

1
CommanderCianide•

The weathered blade that you give to D doesn't really look anything like the dagger that you see in the cutscene killing Godwyn. The Black Knife you can find in game looks exactly like it. The weathered dagger looks like the hilt of a fairly standard looking gold dagger.

Also it never specifies that the two of them can communicate telepathically. The armor specifically says that they are of two minds, but one soul. Whatever that means.

3
GetReadyToJobOP•

Dagger received from Fia, the Deathbed Companion.

She wishes for it to be returned to its rightful owner.

It was once a special weapon of gold and silver intertwined, but is now worn down and marred by a black gash.

Couldve sworn she mentioned it was part of a ritual.

0
Wise_Mongoose8243•

Black Knife’s description all but outright says that it was used to kill Godwyn, but I do wonder what’s up with the Weathered Dagger

3
Hollow_Hinterclaw:restored:•

sorry pal, but it was I who slayed Ranni's empyrean flesh...

1
GetReadyToJobOP•

How could you

2
Hollow_Hinterclaw:restored:•

she asked me, actually i made her beg. it was cute

0