Does anyone else feel slightly underwhelmed by the Apple Extended Keyboard II?

I recently acquired a Macintosh SE off eBay, and while I will spare the long story for getting the machine working for now, I ended up getting an AEK II for it, for a hair over $70.

I've used mechanical keyboards in the past (Cherry MX Blue switches on both of them), and I was expecting the AEK II to have a similar feel, with a very tactile click, and at least a somewhat audible sound. When I got the keyboard, however, it feels fairly similar, although possibly a little better, to most membrane keyboards I have used, including the Apple Design Keyboard. It honestly does feel like the modern style of Apple keyboards (such as the 2009 Bluetooth keyboard I use on my desk, and the one built into my M1 MacBook Pro) have more tactile feedback.

I want to make it clear that I don't think the AEK II feels bad to type on, it feels perfectly fine, just that I am slightly underwhelmed by what it feels like to use.

Did I just have the wrong set of expectations? I know both of my mechanical keyboards were advertised as "gaming" keyboards, but I do prefer the tactile response they give compared to the mostly linear motion of the AEK II.

Posted Mar 27, 2022, 3:22 AM UTC

44
cadenya_•

Some Alps keyboards have been used a lot throughout their lives so the switches might be worn out, but in my experience I always prefer Cherry style switches compared to them.

2
Johnnya101•

You're right, it has a bit of a mushy feeling. The AEK is a bit better, but still quiet. Personally, I like my IBM Model F XT the best with it's maximum click/pop sound.

2
drosse1meyer•

There were a few variations. Which one is yours? I'm guessing they're damped 'cream switches' by your description

https://deskthority.net/wiki/Apple\_Extended\_Keyboard\_II

2
cy384•

Cream damped Alps switches have a mild tactile bump and no click, and they've also got rubber dampers, which makes them quieter and bottoming out is softer. It's a matter of personal preference (I love them).

2