My friend and I (mostly my friend) are trying to make an open source Rekordbox alternative - call for information!

Software

As the title. It would quantize, bpm detect, perhaps key detect, sort into desired playlists and then move all that information onto a usb stick, CDJ ready. It would also contain a couple of extra features, like a 'usb stick combination' button, which would combine 2+ USB sticks onto 1 stick with each old stick's contents becoming a folder with playlists on the new stick. We think this would be particularly useful for doing somewhat impromptu b2b sets with not enough USB slots on the CDJs/XDJ, situation we find ourselves in often.

For all the people who want to use Rekordbox to DJ or require it (for e.g. a DDJ controller), this isn't gonna help you I'm afraid, that would be much more complex.

The thing is we fucking hate Rekordbox. We hate the experience of using the software. We hate paying for it. But I like the end result, at least for use with CDJs!

We found various bits of info online from people's past efforts found with google search. But here to ask if any of you has tried to do anything like this before and if so whether you'd be willing to share what you learnt. You would be credited but it'll open source so no money to be made here. We're particularly looking for any previous attempts or insights into rendering the database file (export.pdb) and the track data (the ANLZ files). The info we found so far has some useful parsing info, but rendering is a bit harder than parsing as we really need to know everything the CDJ needs to work.

Thanks so much for anyone who can help or point us in the right direction!


Stuff we found before:

https://djl-analysis.deepsymmetry.org/rekordbox-export-analysis/exports.html

https://github.com/henrybetts/Rekordbox-Decoding

https://github.com/Deep-Symmetry/crate-digger

Posted Mar 27, 2022, 10:07 AM UTC

4024
MixMasterG•

I would suggest to join the MiXXX open source initiative instead of trying to invent the wheel yourself. It is a very kind and knowledgeable group of DJ enthusiasts who can use all the help they can get.

https://mixxx.org

51
EmergencyCreditOP•

Thanks for this, it definitely looks interesting but it seems to mostly do everything we're not looking to do and not the key thing we want it for. We don't want any DJing software, but rather just something to prep USB sticks for DJing with CDJs, XDJs (and with rekordbox if you are so inclined)

8
EOwl_24•

Why not just implement it into MIXXX? it would be better to just export your already prepared tracks.

9
EmergencyCreditOP•

Will definitely look into that, think it makes sense to integrate the two esp as we don't particularly want to redo work done on quantizing, bpm detection etc.

1
loquacious•

A Rekordbox type feature is something that's missing from MIXXX.

I use MIXXX a lot. Fucking love that program compared to all the DRM'd, locked down and paid crap out there.

You'd also get a built in audience if you worked with MIXXX instead of reinventing the wheel all alone. They'd probably love your help.

4
vhexsTraktor S4 MK3 | D&B, Bassline, Prog. House•

I agree, MIXXX is awesome and it's what originally got me started with DJing.

2
EmergencyCreditOP•

I've honestly never used it, and obviously it's not very useful as is for my use case which is sometimes with laptop but mostly without.

But it does look cool and I think integrating this feature into Mixxx makes sense. Maybe we will try go from Mixxx format to CDJ format so that it can be easily integrated into Mixxx if we get it working.

1
toast_training•

Who pays for Rekordbox?

23
vhexsTraktor S4 MK3 | D&B, Bassline, Prog. House•

That's a good point. Isn't the free version perfectly able to prep USBs for CDJs?

5
EmergencyCreditOP•

honestly this might be my mistake, but I swear this wasn't the case pre version 6, but does seem to be the case now. Anyhow, I still find it very inflexible and honestly pretty fucking shit, with rekordbox frequently corrupting drives etc.

1
IanFoxOfficial•

You don't need to pay for Rekordbox to export USB's?

But one feature that I would improve on would be the beatgridding experience.

Make it easier to edit flexible grids in the beginning without messing up the rest of the track.

So let's say I just beatgridded a live drummed track. Then I go back I notice I've messed up somewhere in the beginning. Let me edit that part without changing points after that. And show the points where I've placed a new beatgrid marker.

Maybe also improve the automatic beatgridding and analysis so Rekordbox users could use your tool to import back into Rekordbox.

8
twaxana•

Hey, I just wanted to say good luck. Ignore everyone saying "don't do this, do that"

8
EE1323•

The people working on mixxx already figured out how to read rekordbox usbs, I would take a look on their github page and forum

5
EmergencyCreditOP•

Yeah like i said in the post, we found stuff on how to read and are currently developing off of that. But how to create and what the cdj actually reads and requires is a bit more complex and just putting a message out in case someone has (partially) done this before

1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
busycalibrating•

Another feature that blows my mind that Pioneer thinks it's appropriate to charge you a subscription for is the ability to synchronise your libraries using your own Dropbox that I already pay for... I understand the tier where they provide you the storage, but charging me just for the privilege of using my own cloud storage? Absolutely ridiculous.

4
davr•

You can synchronize it without paying for rekordbox, it just takes more effort to set up manually

1
ghostz33•

While this sounds very intriguing, what is the max size usb the cdj can read. Reason being is ssd is becoming relatively cheap and with large space. Unless it can't read external hard drives.

4
EmergencyCreditOP•

hm, I'm pretty sure 256GB sticks formatted to FAT32 (using mac or non-native windows applications) work just fine and top range 256GB ones don't cost more than 50 euro or so

1
_scorp_•

There is a load of software that will do what you want to for free rekordbox for one engine dj

The main issue is that pioneer don't want you doint this and has broken the formatting with firmware a number of times

So unless you're using latest rb to prep your drives then no guarantee they'll work at the club

3
EmergencyCreditOP•

Yeah I see, I'm sure that is a concern, would have to be a battle to out update them. But Engine DJ doesn't say anything about supporting CDJs (supports Denon players which honestly I would like to switch to from CDJs but it's no good when Pioneer still have the market monopolised in bars, clubs and amongst all your DJ friends lol)

1
renegadellf•

I support this effort and look forward to any developments

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Typical_Curve_5672•

DDJ-400 Vibes

1
EmergencyCreditOP•

Thanks all for the encouragement, discouragement and words of advice. Will take it all on board and get in touch with the guys at Mixxx

1