From DARK SOULS 3 to ELDEN RING: Was the Tree Spirit cut content?

SpoilerDiscussion & Info

Posted Mar 29, 2022, 3:13 PM UTC

1015
scrumsclut•

Well yeah and red wolf was supposed to be part of the Abyss Watchers but they scraped it. Here we are

6
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

Yeah! I love that. It's so cool to find the shared DNA in each game.

2
BBQMasterDad•

Considering ER uses the same engine as DS3 it’s not surprising they share assets.

1
Inconmon•

Or the same people like to evolve their ideas in the next iteration.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

That's... also basically what I'm saying here? It's not mutually exclusive or at all a bad thing.

1
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

I don't know about y'all, but this is the enemy of Elden Ring that most immediately made me think of Dark Souls 3. It's sort of a hiding-in-plain-sight thing. It just seems so likely based on their designs, animations, and basically everything about them that the Tree Spirits are some sort of cut or incomplete content originally intended for Dark Souls 3. I remember the Dark Souls 3 community often speculating about the Pus of Man and that leaked screenshot, and possible cut content regarding these creatures, so this felt like something worth putting into an image.

I actually think the connection is obvious, and I'm sure a lot of you have - on some level - recognized this already yourselves, so I'm not making any claim of being the first to notice this. I just wanted to share.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Kishin2•

no it wasn't cut from ds3 they just reused an enemy concept. same how the erdtree avatars are basically asylum demons. or how omenkillers are capra demons.

1
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•
1
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

I guess we'll have to wait and see! It probably wasn't "cut", i.e, finished but didn't make it to release, but I bet it was at least in development originally for Dark Souls 3. I think it's a bit more than conceptual similarity.

1
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

Glorious validation. https://youtu.be/uBzelJ70lCM

1
Misfit597:restored:•
1
Inconmon•

I think you're connecting dots trying to find a connection that doesn't exist.

0
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•
2
ProtoRedditOP:hollowed:•

I disagree!

I think there's enough readily apparent shared DNA in the design of the Tree Spirit to quite reasonably assume that it was in some way originally intended for use in Dark Souls 3, similar to the Red Wolf of Radagon.

2
Misfit597:restored:•

He was right.

1