Any safe way to share the gw.dat file to make it easier for new/returning players?

So, as many of you know, a bunch of people were banned because they downloaded a gw.dat file that was originally shared here by myself and a few others. I removed the links to avoid these things from happening again.

However, after having had to reinstall Guild Wars myself, I have come to truly loathe the slow download process. Perhaps I'm spoilt by Steam's 60-70 MB/s download speeds, but I think that being able to get the game up and running on a spur of the moment would be very much appreciated.

The problem, however, is that the .dat file serves as a unique fingerprint. If two people use the gw.dat file, they are linked by that unique fingerprint. I tested this by checking the MD5 hash of two freshly installed copies. The hashes, and even file sizes, were different. I suppose this might have been done intentionally as a way to detect if the same person is simply using different accounts.

Back in the day, when we had actual GMs banning RMT sellers and botters, this might have been a very useful tool indeed. But today, I find myself wondering why we are forced to hold back an important QOL feature simply to avoid the occasional false positive ban.

So idk, any insights, anyone?

Side note: I know that AWS loves charging through the nose for outbound data. If people download the gw.dat file from another source, Anet potentially gets to save on that juicy 4GB per download. More savings = more GW forever?

Posted Mar 31, 2022, 2:48 PM UTC · edited

125
brumalis•

There is not.

You can force gw to download all files if you want to overnight

As for gw forever

Gw runs on gw2 servers and doesnt cost a thing

So long as guild wars 2 runs gw will be running

3
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

Why not? I'm asking from a technical perspective.

As for forcing GW to download all files overnight, yes I'm aware of the -image flag, but that doesn't solve the issue of slow download speeds.

As for the myth about gw2 servers, it actually doesn't run on gw2 servers. This was recently confirmed by DrStephenCW himself.

Also, there's no such thing as not costing a thing. It clearly does cost something, which is why the server is probably on the cheapest and shittiest ec2 instance and cannot handle peak loads very well. (or I might be wrong, idk)

1
brumalis•

Its not myth.

It really does run on gw2 servers

As confirmed by Anet themself

-8
[deleted]•

I downloaded the client yesterday, and it had a guildwars2 url. I'm pretty sure it's safe to say the two games share infrastructure.

5
Z442•

The infrastructure belongs to Cloudflare and they have tens of thousands of servers because they are a content delivery network.

2
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

The setup file is just an executable file. You can host the file anywhere, it really doesn't matter.

The setup file triggers a download of the client and the gw.dat file from another server.

1
Z442•

It really doesn't.

As confirmed by Anet themself.

2
Baunzie•
-1
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

From DrStephenCW: "Why do people keep saying this? GW1 has it's own servers in AWS. (I mean, I know why people keep saying it.) Thanks to the other people that set the record straight."

https://www.reddit.com/r/GuildWars/comments/tmdann/comment/i23mwxg/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

And also: "(GW1 game servers are not shared with GW2. They are on completely different instances at Amazon. Maybe this rumor started because they do share the same login servers.)"

https://www.reddit.com/r/GuildWars/comments/rs0njj/comment/hqlthgo/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web2x&context=3

5
brumalis•

https://www.eurogamer.net/articles/2013-07-16-arenanet-guild-wars-1-could-last-forever

I stand corrected and its also the reason why it surfaced that it runs on gw 2

1
Lutzol•

How long is your actual download time? The game is only about 4gb.

3
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

Around 3 to 4 hours if I recall correctly.

Yes it's a small file but the download is slow.

1
phlyingisphun•

Seems to me like there isn’t much of a solution to the slow download speeds if each installation needs its own download and the GW servers are the bottleneck (I don’t know if that’s actually the case, just an assumption).

But as a workaround, what about just keeping a copy of Gw.exe somewhere, running it with -image to do the full download, then holding on to the corresponding .dat file until you find a use for it. Once you copy it somewhere else, wipe the original and run w/ -image again so you have another .dat primed and ready to go for later.

It’s not elegant, but at least you won’t have to wait for a download (assuming you don’t need too many copies of the .dat at once).

1
ChthonVII•

So, as many of you know, a bunch of people were banned because they downloaded a gw.dat file that was originally shared here by myself and a few others.

Umm... can you document that? I've copied .dat files around with no consequence multiple times in the past.

​

The problem, however, is that the .dat file serves as a unique fingerprint. If two people use the gw.dat file, they are linked by that unique fingerprint. I tested this by checking the MD5 hash of two freshly installed copies. The hashes, and even file sizes, were different. I suppose this might have been done intentionally as a way to detect if the same person is simply using different accounts.

I don't believe there's any deliberate fingerprinting going on. So far as I am aware, the differences between .dat files boil down to (1) settings such as default username, UI size, volume, etc. being saved within the .dat and (2) the internal structuring of the file placing newly downloaded stuff wherever there is space instead of in a predetermined order.

1
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

Here's the thread on that: https://www.reddit.com/r/GuildWars/comments/epqvrx/reason_for_recent_bans/

I'm not sure myself either. But two freshly downloaded -image gw.dat files should be identical. However, they are not.

1
ChthonVII•

two freshly downloaded -image gw.dat files should be identical. However, they are not.

They will not be because there's no guarantee the resource files will be served to you in the same order, and GW tosses them into the dat in the order received, into the first big enough free space or at the end if there is none.

That's a two-year-old thread with one guy who seems pretty earnest plus one post by a deleted account. I'm curious about the provenance of the particular dat file that guy had -- maybe it really was doctored -- or if it contained saved local settings.

1
renebulousOPRenebulous Me•

I see. Well I assumed that the files are always downloaded sequentially since ping has an effect on download speed. But I could be wrong about that.

Yeah but two years in Guild Wars is like yesterday.

It's also possible that they are just making up an excuse for why they were banned.

But without a way to be sure, I'm not sure if we should share the gw.dat file

1