r/DMAcademy•
addygil

How to make a music battle interesting?

Need Advice: Encounters & Adventures

My bard player is about to come face to face with his rival bard turned lich (long story), who is going to challenge the bard to a music off when the party finds him. This will be a big character moment, so I don't want it to just be a single performance check, as I want to build some tension.

Posted Mar 31, 2022, 11:44 PM UTC

15
TheWoodsman42•

Do a full-on battle of the bands, similar to how it was done in the Scott Pilgrim movie. Also, let the rest of the party help the hard in some form or fashion. They can try to hype the crowd up, mess with the opposing bard’s equipment, etc. Spells are disallowed, but only if you get caught.

5
Left_Ahead•

Coming here to recommend you watch Scott Pilgrim as well, particularly the Katanayagi Twins battle.

4
Lazerbeams2•

Musical combat should be charisma based. Maybe give both combatants double their charisma modifier in "health" and have performance checks deal damage to that number. The whole party can participate, they can use spells and skill checks to spice up the show by giving advantage or "healing". The bard would be able to do these things too, but as the "damage" dealer of the group, he'll need to be a little tactical in that. Attacks would probably be opposed charisma checks or charisma vs wisdom. A fast fight would have combatants dealing 2d6 "damage" on a good charisma check, for a slower one you can adjust the "damage" to 1d6 or even 1d4, or better yet base the "damage" on how much they succeeded by

3
CaduceusClaymation•

You could make it some sort of skill check contest. Three or more rounds of contested performance checks as they duel each other with their respective instruments. There could be opportunities for the bard's party members to offer some support with magic or cheering for the bard or heckling the lich. Meanwhile, the lich could have some legendary/lair actions and have its own bonuses to some of the checks to keep things interesting.

Another option might be the bard and the lich each have a special pool of hit points that they each do damage to with their performance checks. So your bard's 23 performance check now does 23 musical damage to the lich. Whoever hits 0 first gets blown away by the other's musical prowess.

2
ewok_360•

I'd throw my lot in with the first option here.

Make it audience based in a town, they get to canvass east of blank to hype the competition at sunset while the other gets to canvass west of blank.

For each of these below it can be a single roll or a separate skill challenge or whatever combo you feel in between.

First challenge is who can gather the most audience to the event, fist impressions and all,

Second challenge is to play and perform the best,

Third is to win over the audience (i'd have the bad guy spend some magic for effects in a last solo or something).

Also i'd have the bad guy bet on something to further the plot (his designs) if he wins, and be a total douche about it.

Sounds fun!

2