Weekly Entering & Transitioning Thread | 03 Apr 2022 - 10 Apr 2022

Discussion

Welcome to this week's entering & transitioning thread! This thread is for any questions about getting started, studying, or transitioning into the data science field. Topics include:

  • Learning resources (e.g. books, tutorials, videos)
  • Traditional education (e.g. schools, degrees, electives)
  • Alternative education (e.g. online courses, bootcamps)
  • Job search questions (e.g. resumes, applying, career prospects)
  • Elementary questions (e.g. where to start, what next)

While you wait for answers from the community, check out the FAQ and Resources pages on our wiki. You can also search for answers in past weekly threads.

Posted Apr 3, 2022, 12:00 PM UTC

17228
Implement-Worried•

If we have anyone who is looking for work as a new college hire, check out companies in the Midwest. You might not get paid top of the market, but from what I have seen in recent interviews my company is lowering the bar quite a bit to get workers. A lot of companies provide tuition reimbursement but even if not offered you can do the Georgia Tech or Texas for less than $10k. Work on a masters if you do not have one and then leave with 2-3 years of experience for your big pay raise. We are hemorrhaging junior talent, but upper management doesn't seem to care. Guess we are moving to a churn model.

6
wsen•

Are you in person, or is remote possible?

1
Implement-Worried•

Midwest so in person. All our new college hires must be in person for six months because that entire period is for training followed by live small projects before being assigned to a team. Then you are at the mercy of your manager.

2
MarcoTalin•

Copied from the previous post as recommended by the Bot Mod.

​

Hi r/datascience. Apologies for the long comment, but I have a lot on my mind.

I've got two questions: one specific and one broad. I'm open to answers to either one.

​

First, I'm looking for a good Post-Graduate Data Science Program in Japan. Would anyone have any recommendations? I've been looking around, and I've found a few options.

  1. Tohoku University's AIQDS (AI, Quantum Computing, and Data Science) Program was the first major one to catch my eye, but it's a hefty one. It's a Master's + Doctorate program all in one over 5 years, which is a heck of a time investment.
  2. Shiga University has a fairly well-outlined master's program. I have no frame of reference as to whether or not it's good, but I'm just doing preliminary research at this point anyway.
  3. A few others have more loosely defined programs (Osaka University, Hiroshima University, Nara Institute of Technology). I can't find a proper outline of the programs on their websites, but I'll be looking to dig into them as I go further into this process.

Please let me know if you have any other recommendations.

​

Second, the bigger and more general one. This comes with a bit (read: a lot) of context.

I'm ~30 years old. I currently work as an information analyst, mainly doing data-oriented Business Intelligence work for a big FMCG company. The work I do is some of the more technical kind of work I can think of without being IT proper: data management and processing, report production, management, and optimization, etc.

A career path in data science is something that I've been thinking about for quite some time now. Higher education was always in the back of my mind, but it wasn't something I wanted to jump into unless it was something I was certain I could invest myself in. That's when I stumbled across data science. It just covered a lot of the things I'm either good at or interested in.

  • I've always been good at math. Best in the subject in my high school, and I did well at it in College (College Algebra, Calculus, Linear Algebra, etc.).
  • I'm an Excel nut. Even before working, I did a lot of stuff with it, but on the job I've been able to hone my understanding with the extended features like Power Query and DAX in PowerPivot, as well as the related application Power BI.
  • I like problem solving. I'm the kind of nut that won't let go of a problem unless I've found an answer.
  • I have an affinity for programming. Didn't get to it until later in my school life, but I've since taught myself a bit of C++, Javascript, and Python along the way. I've probably forgotten a lot about them, but I picked them up pretty easily anyway.
  • I love messing around with databases. I do it for work, and I also do it in my spare time, mainly for supplementary calculations to optimize decisions in video games, which have been a great source of large-scale information combined with calculations of higher-than-normal complexity. I could probably put together a decent portfolio of Excel files I've made over the years. I've also done a bit of amateur data scraping to put together the databases I need.

I find that a lot of these things apply quite well to certain aspects of Data Science, which is why the field appeals to me. I know "Data Science", "Big Data", and "Machine Learning" have been big buzzwords tossed around for a while, so I didn't want to get into it without good reason, and I think I have a few pretty good reasons.

I'm also a lot more interested in the more technical and hands-on side of data analysis. Of the specializations I've seen, Data Engineering is probably the one that appealed to me the most. I'm not 100% sure what that means for the direction I should take, though.I also want to pursue it as an educational path for a few reasons:

  1. I feel like there's so much to learn, and I'm not sure how far "really good at Excel" will take me. I've never had a proper formal IT-oriented background either, though it's something I've been open to.
  2. When I want to learn a practical skill, I need either proper direction to help guide my learning or a concrete application to help learn as I go. I can't just learn for the sake of learning, and concepts with no application just don't stick in my head. I need a big meaty project I can sync my teeth into.

Most of all, though, I'm looking for something that I can throw myself into. I've always been the type that wants to keep myself busy, but I also find negative motivation in doing something I'm not interested in. I want to build things and solve problems and puzzles, and I want to help people by doing something that I know I'm pretty good at, and that I know a lot of people have trouble understanding. I love taking complex concepts and turning them into something people can understand.

However, I also have trouble with long-term vision. I've never been interested in "upward mobility", and when I work, my #1 concern is that I'm doing something I'm interested in. That's made it hard for me to break out of the little corner I've carved for myself at work, and it's put a self-imposed ceiling over my head, because I'm so attached to the hands-on and busy aspects of my job.

I'm hoping that immersing myself in a field that demands a lot of skills and interests that I have will open up opportunities to be able to utilize them better and to make a living. That probably sounds a bit idealistic, but I think I've got the ability to make it happen.

​

With all that being said, I guess the question I have is am I going about this in a good way? Is this broad and general idea I have a good one? I don't have a lot of people I can talk to about this because my interests are so niche, and the questions I have can be pretty specific.

3
CKiame•

You sound like a great candidate for data science! I just completed a post-grad program out of UT Austin’s McCombs School of Business via Great Learning and it has been tough but a great seven-month introduction to data science and analytics. I highly recommend it.

2
Vigilance1213•

ou sound like a great candidate for data science! I just completed a post-grad program out of UT Austin’s McCombs School of Business via Great Learning and it has been tough but a great seven-month introduction to data science and analytics. I highly recommend it.

I'd love to go down to Austin and study but my parents say that's to far and prefer me to stay in the North East

1
CKiame•

It is an online course, but run as an executive post-grad program that does not carry academic credit (not a grad program) so perhaps you’d want to do an in-person program in Japan.

2
MarcoTalin•

I appreciate the encouragement. What do you think about the programs I shared? Do you think a 5-year program is worth it?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
datascience-botOPMODv0.5.1•

Hi u/-jaylew-, I created a new Entering & Transitioning thread. Since you haven't received any replies yet, please feel free to resubmit your comment in the new thread.

1
HIPAAlicious•

Is it better to apply for a data analysis role first and then try and transition to data science? Everything I’ve read seems like DS is really hard to break into and that a lot of jobs seem to want experience first. For reference, I’m about to finish my masters in a sub field of Mech E I have a few courses in AI, neural networks, and the like. But I have no direct job experience.

3
monkeyunited•

Yes, that's a good strategy but you should also apply to any job that you're interested in.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
takeaway_272•

graduating cornell w/ a degree in stats and cs minor, no industry internships but 1.5 years experience of applied ML research. I don’t think I have it in me to do a masters straight away but also don’t think I have enough experience to secure a relevant first job. so I was thinking about trying to find an internship or co-op in the fall before trying to get a first job? not sure if this is reasonable or stupid.

3
diffidencecause•

Why don't you think you can find a job? Cornell is a reasonably well-known school. Your degrees are relevant. Sure, if you're only open to becoming DS at Google, that might be tricky because that's pretty competitive.

3
takeaway_272•

IDK lack of industry internships, comparing myself to other kids here and frequenting this sub a lot. It seems to secure any junior data position out of undergrad (not just FAANG) you have to be pretty extraordinary.

1
diffidencecause•

Is this backed up by personal experience? e.g. have you sent out a bunch of applications and heard nothing back? (And, even if that were true, it could be a resume writing problem rather than an experience problem).

There are a lot of industries that are looking for data-related roles. Lots of classical ones (data analysis/stats roles under various titles at banks, insurance, bio research, etc.). Business/finance analysts at pretty much any company.

There are also data roles with different titles at tech companies (business intelligence, [something] analyst).

I suppose you could try to get an internship (tricky, since most good ones expect you to still be a student), but it's very obviously not the case that having an internship is necessary to find a job -- many folks didn't do an "internship" by the time they graduated for a variety of reasons -- what do you think they are doing?

2
izzyrose2•

Hello everyone,

I am looking for insight on a career orientation decision.

I am currently finishing a Ph.D. in computational psychiatry and looking to make a transition toward the data science field with the end goal to become a freelance data scientist, or working in a tech-oriented firm. At the moment, I live and work in Belgium and have to stay here for a few years, I would really want to work in other European/American countries later.

I currently face two very different career opportunities. The first one would be to take a classic entry-level data scientist position in an advisory firm (I have opportunities in a big four and in several mid-size agencies).

The second one would be to become the only data analyst in a government agency that takes care of mental health in my country. It makes the connection between the hospitals and the government for 'lobbying' purposes. At the moment, the data work mainly revolved around epidemiologic reports for the government in order to assess the hospital needs. The strong point is that I would have a lot of data at my disposal, and a lot of time to develop whatever I want, as long as I report the epidemiologic data once a year. The weak point is that I would not have any supervision and that I will evolve in a niche field as compared to an advisory firm. Besides, I would not really gain experience with specific tools such as cloud tools, BI tools, etc...

My main question is, would that kind of experience be considered beneficial for a recruiter if I applied for a 'non-entry' level data scientist position later? I guess it would mainly depend on what I develop at the firm but I am not so sure. What scares me most is that I would not be able to develop anything really meaningful at that agency, or that the field would be considered too specific and translates badly in the private sector later.

(considering salary, it is a bit better at the governmental agency and with fewer obligations).

Thank you very much for your insight !

Cheers!

3
datascience-botOPMODv0.5.1•

Hi u/izzyrose2, I created a new Entering & Transitioning thread. Since you haven't received any replies yet, please feel free to resubmit your comment in the new thread.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
datascience-botOPMODv0.5.1•

Hi u/RoadToReality00, I created a new Entering & Transitioning thread. Since you haven't received any replies yet, please feel free to resubmit your comment in the new thread.

1
transitgeek10•

What criteria should someone meet before they can call themselves a data scientist? This term gets tossed around so much these days. When is the title appropriate to the work and when is it inflated? Since people come from all different fields and there's no official certification, it seems rather subjective so I am curious for opinions.

3
diffidencecause•

As you say, it's very subjective. Personally, I don't think it matters. You can call yourself a data scientist if you'd like, as a way to market yourself. What really matters would be whether you had the actual skills to be hired and to do the job.

Sure, it used to be that data scientist titles were given more to folks with reasonably heavy statistics or modeling technical knowledge, but that has changed with the times -- now companies give many folks data scientist titles, and some companies move the more technical roles into "research scientist" titles (at least, in tech). So is it still fair to say that these are inflated? I mean, if that's what the market consensus is, then I guess it's not really inflated?

Personally, what I find more important is, when looking at a role -- what is the work content (analytics/product vs. statistics/modeling/ML vs. other dimensions), and what is the corresponding compensation. Likewise, when looking at people/candidates/myself, I consider ability along different dimensions that are relevant to data science as a whole, but I don't think about questions like "are they actually a data scientist".

3
readitallday1•

I graduated from a top 30 University in Computer Science last year in May and realized Data Science (Analytics focused, not engineering) is what I wanted to do instead of SDE. I had an internship at a quantitative hedge fund outside of the US (not a big name like Citadel or anything you guys/girls would know) and mainly used pandas to clean, and manipulate data, nothing super complex.
My skills right now:
-Python, Pandas,

-minimal SQL exposure,
-basic statistics (Z-Score, Correlation, Linear/Multiple/Logistics Reg, basic stuff).

-Calc 2,

-Matrices.

-I have good finance/economic knowledge/intuition, no credentials besides a few classes in college and the internship though.

Right now I am considering a few paths and was wondering if anyone who was in a similar situation could provide some insight:
Paths currently considering:
Self-learning/Project
Kaggle, then own a project with uncleaned data (something like a finance predictive analytics project)
Data Science Bootcamp
Data Analyst Roles while self-learning
Masters (really don't think this one is necessary, let me know otherwise)
I do not have an extensive data science network and intend to just cold message LinkedIn professionals from my university or companies I'm interested in.
I am not interested in data engineering roles as many people would probably say that's the easiest role to enter with a CS background.

Really really appreciate any insight. Thanks!

2
monkeyunited•

Masters (really don't think this one is necessary, let me know otherwise)

Of all that you listed, this one is the fastest track. Sure, it's not absolutely necessary, but it's the fastest and with the greatest probability of success.

1
miel_tigre•

I sort of disagree about the masters degree unless while doing the masters degree you are also heavily involved in internships, collaborative projects with real world traction, etc. Then make sure that is heavily featured on a resume. But I could be wrong.

I run a data science company right now and I also come from the scrappy start up world so my advice would be to start looking at job postings for your ideal job(s). Make a list of the requirements: both inferred and explicit and figure out ways to meet those requirements. It takes some imagination but for instance you do a couple mini projects showing different skill sets and creative analytical thinking. Document your process and add them/link to them from GitHub to a portfolio website (super quick to spin up a wix site.) I think that the process of making these projects and putting it all together will be a substantial learning experience that will increase your knowledge, skill set, and shows your seriousness and passion to people that see it. Plus you will learn a ton about yourself in the meantime. Get a Boot Camp credential for extra measure if you want. …Then actually apply for the job you want.

1
monkeyunited•

heavily involved in internships, collaborative projects with real world traction, etc.

That is certainly the key here. I agree if it's a no name, cash grabbing degree then it's not better.

I also agree that personal projects should be done first before committing to grad school.

1
readitallday1•

Thanks for the input!

1
readitallday1•

Thanks for the input! I would also like your perspective on the hiring process. Would you weigh drive/passion more than technical prowess? Would you rather choose a fresh graduate that is super passionate but knows little to nothing but shows great potential versus a 26-year-old, 4 years of experience with above-average technical skills but will not above and beyond?

1
miel_tigre•

I don’t have TLDR… it’s just a novel.

Late reply here but that totally depends. Ideally, I’d hire neither. But here are two cases I’d hire one or the other:

  • new grad with passion but little know-how: So first they would need to demonstrate skills that would translate to their role and show that they are in fact a dependable, passionate candidate to be considered. I would hire this person if and only if we had a mentor for them. When hiring people who have a steel learning curve in front of them, there is a huge management workload involved. Introducing them to workflows, industry stuff, assigning projects, reviewing, working through improvements together, extra QA…That means hiring a new resource like this will be a net loss for a while (if you think of people like resources and output.) It’s an investment. So the goal would be to only hire someone that is going to be a good return on investment and hopefully that return comes sooner than 3 months. (I dislike talking about people as assets and resources but…capitalism is the game we are playing.)

  • Person at any age with great tech skills but unwilling to go above and beyond: this sounds like a person who has set strict boundaries on what they want to do and what they want to provide. This person is probably more geared toward freelance work rather than a collaborative work environment where they are required to be flexible. I would hire this person for a project. The contract process would be a lot easier. It would be a low risk exchange where we give them money for their time and materials and we could reasonably assume we will get exactly what we need from the circumstance.

The new grad with little know how would be a hard sell because it’s high risk. This is where as a candidate, you would need to show rather than tell me how your passion manifests.

So for an example: my company works with geospatial analysis. So if you want to apply for a job or merely reach out to make sure you are on someone’s radar (always a good idea) - reach out with a cover letter, resume, and links to your projects. Your cover letter should acknowledge any lack of professional experience and should insinuate why you aren’t a high risk hire. If you are “passionate and driven” you should give me examples. “I’m passionate and driven, for instance when I researched your company I was interested in the way xyz data set could be used in your product. I created this GIS visualization (linked)….”

Always show with your tell. And be creative with it. You don’t always need to create new projects. Think about how things could translate.

1
IAMHideoKojimaAMA•

Took my first real data job and start in two weeks. The job applying grind was real though

2
Implement-Worried•

Congrats! What field did you end up in?

3
IAMHideoKojimaAMA•

Thanks! Analyst with flight data. Choose them over a startup because I've had bad expirences with startups lol. The tech interview was dead easy. If I could pass it anyone can.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2

Any advice on pursuing a statistics and data science minor while majoring in environmental science? I was planning on adding that as my minor but was wondering what kind of jobs would I be able to consider doing in the future.

2
miel_tigre•

I think this is a wise decision. No matter what you end up doing in environmental science, being able to work with, transform, and model data such a geospatial data will be majorly accretive to you. Not to mention it gives your mind a unique toolset for working with information and systems. It also makes you a valuable hire. I am an executive at data science company and we work with geospatial data so for instance your major and minor would make you a great candidate if I wanted to build out our environmental risk analytics. There is so much data out there and barely anyone is analyzing it. So in a more traditional environmental science role you would still be able to transform a department with incorporating data science practices.

1
gambrinous_sloth•

Which career path should I choose starting out in data science?

First job after grad school (PhD cs). Considering DS roles at FAANGS or at consulting firms eg QuantumBlack or Bain Advanced analytics.

Looking for anyone that's done both and can tell what it's really like at one or the other. What is the best choice for a fresh grad? Is it easy to switch between the two?

Thanks

2
datascience-botOPMODv0.5.1•

Hi u/gambrinous_sloth, I created a new Entering & Transitioning thread. Since you haven't received any replies yet, please feel free to resubmit your comment in the new thread.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
datascience-botOPMODv0.5.1•

Hi u/vampirdus, I created a new Entering & Transitioning thread. Since you haven't received any replies yet, please feel free to resubmit your comment in the new thread.

1
WiscoSippi•

I know what I want to do but I don’t know what it is called. Will you folks help me?

I want to use data to answer business questions and solve business problems, e.g. What are the drivers of productivity of our labor force? How can we increase productivity?

I have a MS in DS and 7 years of DA/BI work. I also have a background in finance with a CPA.

I think this role is a Data Scientist.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
WiscoSippi•

I want to do the development to some degree but acknowledge I’m not an expert in everything. I’ll look into solution architect.

And yeah productivity is the product of efficiency and utilization. More hours on DL but also turn the wrenches faster.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
WiscoSippi•

More time on DL, direct labor, not more actual hours. Cut down on non-production related activities

1
WiscoSippi•

Solution architect sounds interesting but the definition I read seemed more focused on the technology than on the business problem.

2

Industrial engineering student wanting to enter data science

Hey guys I’m an IE student and hate the idea of working in manufacturing/supply chain. I like math and programming though so I figured I could be interested in data science. So a few months ago I bought an udemy course in data science in python and have really enjoyed it. I’m about half way through and have built a few basic reports in jupyter. The rest of the course goes into theory I think so about clustering and machine learning, trends, etc.

Anyways, so I’m positive I want to try out data science through an internship/job. I’m set to graduate in a year and have never had an internship so I’m trying to get one in the summer/fall. If I can’t get one however, would it be difficult to get a data science job coming from an IE background? I take a lot of math and statistics and know basic python and SQL. Should I look into a masters or Boot Camp? What should my next move be, once I finish this course?

2
thedatarat•

I’m new to DS but I’ve been in tech for 7 years - I’d say not to sell yourself short if you feel confident in the skills you’ve listed. I’d look for Junior Data Scientist Roles, and/or keep your options open for semi related roles that can help you eventually transition, I.e. Data Analyst.

In terms of boot camps, most are ~$12-15k. I make six figures and even I am not willing to pay that much. I know you’re fresh out of college and I remember money being confusing to me at that time, but that is a LOT (unless you’re fortunate enough to have parents pay or a scholarship). I’d stick with cheaper online options (Udemy, LinkedIn Learning, Coursera, EdX, Pluralsight, YouTube) and work on projects that you can talk about in interviews.

And some semi-related advice - start getting into the habit of putting away money into a retirement fund as early as you can (like, now). Your future self will thank you!

2

Thanks for responding. You’re right I should just keep pushing through online classes. Money is kind of an issue and I also don’t like structured classroom learning. Luckily I’ve been contributing to a Roth IRA since high school but thanks so much for the advice!

2
thedatarat•

Nice!! Wish I knew to do that at that age. Good luck, and I’d also add to focus on creating projects once you’ve gone through a couple online classes. Then check out Kaggle competitions https://www.kaggle.com/competitions

Edit: whoops already mentioned projects in my first comment!

2
mayofield22•

Hello, I am a student in my first year of my Data Science degree. My school just notified me that they will be offering a course in Cloud Computing using Amazon Web Services to teach it. I’m interested in it, but I’m curious how useful it would be to a Data Scientist. Even if it’s not useful I might still take it since it would broaden my horizons, but any input from professionals would be a help. Thanks!

2
monkeyunited•

It'll be very useful actually. Cloud computing is industry standard.

The reason being if you look up the specs of your laptop, you have fairly limited RAM and perhaps not even a GPU. Cloud computing is essentially connecting to powerful computers (on AWS) and run jobs on them so you're not limited by the hardware of your laptop.

2
mayofield22•

Interesting, thanks for the response!

1

Hello everyone,
I'm currently a first year student choosing computer science as a major. I have little experience besides basic programming classes and some coding exercises. Constantly recommend to do a project. However, I don't really know how to "do a project."
First of all, how to choose a project? Do I start from "scratch"? Also, I am a little overwhelmed with learning about data science through online courses by myself because there are some many so I will be grateful for any advice.
P/s: I'm struggling with peer pressure because everyone around me started doing something since they were in high school and here I am learning to code several lines. It is really hard for me to express this. Anyway, that's why I am here and I am thankful for any advice.

2

In my experience, following book examples for projects has helped me learn way more than working on a specific project (usually by following a youtube tutorial). Figure out what language you want to learn, then find a good book with some example problems in it, and work through it. This is probably what you'll be doing in class anyways, so it'll be good to get used to that format. If you do want to make a project in your free time for practice, I recommend thinking about what you would want to make, find out what language and software people in industry usually use to make that thing, and then try to make it. (tutorials might be helpful too).
Hope I helped!

1
SwammyG•

Do you need a masters to enter the data science field? I feel like I have a relatively strong resume via coursework, major, school, and have an internship in data science for the summer, but it seems that the field is dominated by graduate degrees. Would not having a masters lower my chance of a return offer or give me reduced compensation? Any advice welcome!

2
diffidencecause•

Do you need a masters to enter the data science field?

Not necessarily, but it's helpful if you're looking for more competitive roles. e.g. if you want to work at Google/Facebook/etc., it's unlikely to be considered as a new grad without at least a masters.

Would not having a masters lower my chance of a return offer

unlikely -- that is more determined by your internship performance + any company/team constraints at that time.

give me reduced compensation?

Some companies will pay masters students a bit more. However, pay for someone with 2 years of experience vs. a new grad masters is likely pretty comparable.

1
ActualHumanFemale•

You don’t need a masters, but to be honest “data scientist” roles are all over the place. Some focus mostly on analytics reporting and insights and a/b testing. Others build machine learning models. The roles requiring masters degrees are going to be more advanced and the ones that don’t might be more Data Analyst roles.

Also a candidate with experience will always be favored over someone with an advanced degree and zero experience. Even if their title isn’t Data Scientist or Data Analyst. If they can demonstrate solving problems with data, that’s going to be valuable.

However if it’s between two candidates with zero experience, a masters degree will stand out more than just a bachelors. Especially if your goal is to work for a big tech company that gets flooded with resumes. Also at some companies, a new hire with just a bachelors will be a DS I whereas with a masters you might be hired as a DS II. So your salary might be higher. But the first candidate will likely be promoted to DS II within a year to two.

1
Aman8099•

Hey everyone!

I'm currently graduating in the summer with a MS in Data Science and I am noticing when I am applying to jobs a couple of things:

  1. A lot of companies want A/B testing. Is A/B testing simply a randomized trial with hypothesis testing? I'm curious because I understand randomized trials and hypothesis testing along with how bias affects the trials. I want to put this down on my resume if that's the case but I also don't want to put down something I don't know.

  2. Does anyone have any good advice for picking up Tableau? I have the public version and want to learn it, but a lot of the lessons I'm seeing online require the paid version. Any tips or thoughts?

2
diffidencecause•
  1. Yeah, more or less.

  2. It should be pretty easy to learn it on the job, and I imagine most new grad roles will expect you to learn it on the job, as long as you have skills with some comparable tools. Only some companies use Tableau so you might not even need it.

4
fropenius•

Hi all!

I’m trying to decide between two Data Analyst job offers. Both are with established, late stage startups who get stellar reviews (top places to work list on Glassdoor, etc). I’m a non-traditional student finishing my BS in Math with a Minor in CS after working in barely technical roles in nonprofits for several years.

Company A is smaller/younger, and I would be only the third person on their budding data team. I asked what they’re doing in the scope of “data science” and it sounds like it’s purely analytics, but they say want to move more toward machine learning. This could mean that with aggressive study, I could get in on the ground floor of a quickly growing data team and end up high up. Or it could mean that they never move past basic analytics and I won’t have the opportunity to learn much. Feels high risk/high reward.

Company B is more established and I would joining 30ish analysts on their data science team. I could work on projects with engineers, likely learn a lot, and would have a pretty guaranteed slow and steady progression.

I’m not sure where my heart lies (ML, data engineering, visualization, BI, etc) and a big thing I’m hoping to get out of this role is seeing the day-to-day of different areas to figure out where I should orient myself. Of the two, which do you think would be the better way to go to open doors toward a data science career?

2
monkeyunited•

Company B

3
diffidencecause•

I would suggest the larger company. Having a more mature data science team means that you will get exposure to a lot more teammates that you can learn from, with a wide range of skillsets and knowledge. A lot of the basic stuff will be done so you will have examples to follow if you're working in a new area, and won't need to invent as much from scratch.

Sure, there's potential for more career growth if you're early at a place, but that's not guaranteed. Especially since you're early career, you are not going to know how to scale things up when needed -- they will possibly bring more experienced folks in to lead later. You will have a lot of domain knowledge so you could be valuable to any leaders that are brought in though. As you noted, since you don't know what you don't know, so it's possible that your technical growth stagnates because you don't have the incentives (nor time) to go beyond what's immediately necessary (and there's no one there to serve as good examples).

Of the two, which do you think would be the better way to go to open doors toward a data science career?

The randomness between companies and outcomes is very high, so I think predicting that is pretty futile. However, you'll build a bigger network at the more established company, and the company brand (currently, anyway) is more valuable.

2
fropenius•

Thank you for the thoughtful response! This is sort of where my intuition was pointing, and it’s helpful to have that confirmed/articulated by someone else. It does seem to be the safer bet overall, so I think that’s what I’ll do.

2
fropenius•

Also I should clarify that I’m planning to study independently as well, whether that’s through MOOCs or grad school. Just trying to determine which of these two will work best in conjunction with self study.

1