OTNMD-RadOnc•

Tackling diabetes will be easy! Let's see what the article says...

"Experts say addressing the nation’s diabetes crisis will require more than expanding the number of community health workers: Well-funded public education campaigns are needed to drive home the importance of exercise and healthy eating, as are seismic changes to a food system geared to cheap, processed food"

123
Voc1Vic2•

A USDA food support program delivers monthly boxes to a high rise near my home, intended to help disabled and elderly residents. The quality of food is truly deplorable:

Peanut butter made with sugar, salt and hydrogenated oil.

Cereal made with refined grain, often corn, and sugar as the second listed ingredient.

Canned potatoes.

Apple juice.

The residents sort through their boxes and often set out what they know they won’t use on the sidewalk. A lot of the food is so unappealing that it never gets taken.

Given its quality—high fat, high saturated fat, high sugar, high salt, low fiber—think that’s just as well.

118
Sense_Opposite•

A USDA food box brought to you by big agra. Those ingredients sound about right.

72
devilbunnyMD - Anesthesiologist•

I'm entirely on board with the sugar and hydrogenated oil hate, but if you've ever eaten peanut butter that was made entirely without salt, you know why it's in there.

49
Paula92Vaccine enthusiast, aspiring lab student•

IMO a little molasses doesn’t hurt either

7

We get low/no additive peanut butter in Australia that’s pretty good.

America can do better.

4
Whites11783DO Family Med•

Oh you can get it here, they just want $$$$ for the "real stuff".

7
mudskippieMD, Hollywood Upstairs Medical•

Diabetes-in-a-box!

33
pizzainoven•

What about the dreaded peaches or mandarin oranges in light syrup or juice? Man, people hate those. No one likes those little preserved fruit cups.

Yeah, and of the canned veggies, the canned white potatoes are definitely the least liked.

20
Paula92Vaccine enthusiast, aspiring lab student•

Whose idea was it even to can potatoes? It’s so much more palatable to dry them. And IME, instant mashed potatoes is an awesome thickener for vegetable soup.

21
pizzainoven•

Food bank recipients also wonder why they get endless cans of green beans... Although I think those are more interesting and useful than canned potatoes.

Well, on the good side, here is some uses of canned potatoes. Looks like soup could be a decent option.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HereForTheFreeShastaMD•

What the heck even are canned potatoes?? Horrible.

8
betweentourns•

They're just potatoes in a can. They're not terrible. Not sure why they're on the list here. The one good thing i see!

10
Kelley-James•

There’s no reason to can potatoes. Fresh potatoes have a lengthy shelf life and no added sodium. Canning destroys nutrient values of fresh vegetables.

2
pizzainoven•

The canned potatoes have low value to food bank recipients. Since potatoes are inexpensive and store well, food banks often distribute fresh potatoes as a source of fresh potatoes. Getting canned potatoes and a bag of potatoes as your produce source is just disappointing.

2
EuphoriantCrottle•

sodium

Edit: for people downvoting me know that a can of Walmart’s canned potatoes has 720 mg of sodium in it. Unless you source no added sodium canned foods, they are super saturated.

1†
bomgd3•

I really doubt anything substantial can be done for our obesity and diabetes epidemic without changing how our actual cities are designed. Look at the healthy populations around the world. They do not spend their lives in their cars like we do. And the vast majority do not consciously go out to exercise. It’s just built into their day because they don’t move from climate controlled home to climate controlled car to climate controlled work to drive through and then back home. Chinese people are super skinny for example and most would be confused by the idea of regimented exercise, but the cities are designed such that cars are not necessary. You can walk or take transit to most places you need to go. In America it’s often unpleasant to even walk a few hundred meters due to lack of pedestrian infrastructure, and if you ride your bike you might get mowed down by a giant pickup truck. Our car dependence also makes us poorer, which makes it a lot more difficult to buy fresh healthy foods

43
Paula92Vaccine enthusiast, aspiring lab student•

Regarding the Chinese, I’m pretty sure it’s common for schoolchildren to start their day with simple light exercise. So from an early age they have a habit instilled in them of starting the day with some movement.

23
mudskippieMD, Hollywood Upstairs Medical•

IKR? NotJustBikes is so inspiring. Even if the ideas aren't practical everywhere, a bit more human-sized infrastructure would help a lot of people.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
olanzapine_dreamsMD - Psych/Palliative•

Fix your diabetes with these 67,563 weird tricks!

23
boredcertifieddoctorMD - FM•

On an individual basis with no structural change!

22
PokeTheVeilMD - Psychiatry•

Well look at fancy you, using more than 16 bits. I never recommend more than 65,535 tricks to avoid overflow errors.

14
Damn_Dog_InappropesInpatient Uber driver•

65,535

I understood that reference!

2
HereForTheFreeShastaMD•

8F

2
dr_exerciseABD (covid casualty)- physiology•

What a novel proposition! /s

0
macreadyrjcommunity EM•

News flash: diabetes alone is a public health train wreck.

Diabetes + anything else is even worse.

51
Nitnonoggin•

But we need to Raise Awareness!

/s

5
macreadyrjcommunity EM•

In all seriousness, when I read Covid threads in layperson forums and subreddits, I was astonished by the general reaction to this news. No one seems to know that diabetes is really bad. I think it is like smoking; everyone has it, it can be that bad.

4
biggreencat•

https://www.npr.org/transcripts/131167638

Evidently Nixon granted universal health care for dialysis.

1
UTChemOPIM PA-C•

What I find more interesting is the article's mention of a lancet study published last month that describes a patient's increased likehood of T2DM post recovery, when compared to a patient with no known COVID exposure

https://www.thelancet.com/journals/landia/article/PIIS2213-8587(22)00044-4/fulltext

26
rocketlac•

Screening for diabetes, HTN and kidney disease is so easy. It should be required for annually for all insurance coverage, routine visits and at PCP office visits. I hope diet becomes more of a major topic instead of meds.

26
chickaboom_MD•

Your last point is interesting to me - diet is emphasized in every diabetic patient encounter I have. But in residency, when I had the time, I would often spend 20-30 minutes discussing diet and exercise with patients , carefully laying out small changes they could make in lifestyle and scheduling frequent follow ups. It would make a difference in like 10% of people, and usually those people would go out and educate themselves. For the rest, my words fell on deaf ears - “oh, I can take a pill for this and change nothing? Thanks doc”. I am tired of the world acting like we don’t try to pitch lifestyle changes and just push pills.

42
lianaliMPH/research•

This is 200% why I got into behavioral economics. People know what the rational choice is (eat more fruits and vegetables, eat less meat, save for retirement, exercise more), the issue is not one of knowledge but of lack of intentional design, ease of access, and support systems for individuals. If we made it as easy to eat fruits as it is to eat french fries, as safe to walk as it is to drive everywhere, and supported cultural changes like shorter work days, more flex time scheduling that allowed people to cook fresh meals on a more regular basis, we could make a difference. What kills me is that Americans seem to be sold on the idea that Europe pays a crapton in more taxes to get things like walkable cities and fresh foods when that really isn't the case for the majority of people who earn less than $100K/year. There's a freaking railroad crossing in my city where pedestrians regularly die by train accident because we can't get funding for a safe pedestrian crossing. The worst part is that just tackling one of the issues won't solve the diabetes/obesity problem, we have to address all of them or the needle will not move.

I'm one of your 10% who absolutely managed to keep my cholesterol, A1c, and BGL numbers down because CVD runs in my family. I just have to look at a stick of butter to get my LDL levels to rise (thanks genetics!). Holy crap, did it it take a helluvalot of restructuring in my life to get there though! Asking every individual to defy social and cultural norms is basically asking all individuals to suddenly become disciplined, highly self-aware, highly-educated with the ability to work flexible jobs. I have 3 college degrees. I am not the norm and it's not fair to magically expect all people to perform at that level to solve problems that are so much bigger than individual choices.

29
kazooparade•

Absolutely, this is somewhere where we need bigger changes to the food industry and work culture to see improvements. It’s not a lack of education for most people. I have seen more than my share of hospitalized patients with a CHF flare have their families sneak in burger/ fries/pizza etc. because they don’t want to eat “gross hospital food”. I thought one of our hospitalists was going to stroke out one day arguing with a patient who he found happily eating fries while needing hefty doses of lasix.

We can educate people all day, but the reality is unless they REALLY want to make changes its not going to happen. Processed and fast foods are cheap, convenient, and tasty. They need to be made more expensive and less available. A better work culture, as you mentioned, would help a lot too.

14
-cheesencrackers-ED RPh•

In other words, accessibility is not the problem. The problem is patient choices.

1
-cheesencrackers-ED RPh•

How tf do you die by train accident? Just literally use your eyes and look to see if a train is coming

3
lianaliMPH/research•

Older people, those hard of hearing, people wearing headphones, people playing on their phones.... Yes, there are no less than 4 pokemon go stops RIGHT NEXT TO THE DAMNED TRACKS. Like, I love the idea of gamefying walking, but for the love of god, why do we always have to write safety regulations in blood?

1
Main_Orchid•

You should run the world.

It’s almost like structural systems have unseen, unintended consequences in our lives. C. Wright Mills would like to introduce to you a little thing called the sociological imagination.

3
lianaliMPH/research•

You should run the world.

I mean, I joke that I would make an excellent benevolent dictator because I hate public recognition and intentionally design things to try and default people to the beneficial option (like making 401K matching contributions and organ donation default to opt in, so you have to consciously opt out of them. I can't take credit for this idea, go read Nudge by Richard Thaler.)

I've been mulling over the choice of "systems" because system implies that there was a deliberate level of design to funnel people into one area or another, and sometimes, there really just a stacking series of independent systems that don't talk to each other that happen to intersect in just the worst ways. Case in point, the 4+ pokemon go stops right next to some train tracks that have NO pedestrian crossing. Like, I'm 100% sure Ninantic didn't plan to put the stops next to the trains, it's just what happens when local urban areas keep building up on top of the infrastructure that's in place.

Same goes for fast food - restaurants didn't plan on people developing type 2 diabetes, it's what happens when you put together successful marketing campaigns and agriculture/meat production subsidies. Neither one intended to to create long term health effects like increased CVD, it's an unintended consequence.

3
rocketlac•

Sorry, I didn’t post my complete thought. I planned on editing later, so thanks for your comment! As an RD I feel your pain, trust me! I think your diet tips are an exception to most providers I encounter. We see T2 patients that say their PCP only mentions diet and to “stay away from sugar”. I spend almost all of my day educating and re-educating adults about using their diet to help treat their diabetes, HTN and kidney failure. I definitely think if diet instruction; including an individualized meal plan that takes into account socioeconomic factors and limitations was essential to all newly diagnosed and poorly controlled diabetics there would be better outcomes. Nutrition education, meal prep and cooking classes need to be as important as medication for treatment and prevention of disease., especially diabetes. The cost of these prevention programs are minuscule compared to what wound care, ophthalmology or dialysis treatments cost and they are needed to treat complications of diabetes. I am sorry that COVID has caused more people to be diagnosed with diabetes. Maybe that coupled with the increasing cost of diabetes meds will create a sea change-going back to basics with the foods we eat and learning how to use our whole foods to treat/prevent disease. I’m sorry you feel like the world thinks you don’t talk about lifestyle changes and just push pills, please don’t stop educating about diet! It’s so important! Thank you!

7
DocPsychosisPsychiatry/Forensic psychiatry - USA•

We see T2 patients that say their PCP only mentions diet and to “stay away from sugar”.

Well, you probably know this, but there is often a difference between what is said, what is heard then, and what is recalled weeks or months later. Asking the patient what they were told is a good way of gauging their understanding but not a good way of knowing what actually happened at the appointment.

11
rocketlac•

Honestly most people (especially folks pictured in the article) need more than one education session before they grasp a concept, especially diet changes by that impact their whole family. In my practice I meet my patients where they are at, so if all they retained from their provider when they were diagnosed with diabetes is to stay away from sugar, then I know where to start. If the docs did more at their appointment, that’s great but it’s also a moot point because patient did not retain the info. Keep talking about diet and stressing it’s importance and then keep referring to your RDs and CDEs!!

6
Nitnonoggin•

I'm old enough to remember a shortlived campaign to tell the public "No, diabetes isn't caused by eating too much candy! It's complicated!"

Not sure what that was supposed to accomplish. Seemed like the go-ahead to eat more candy.

3
soninicole33•

If you're a doctor, can you for freaking sake say Type 2 when you're referring to the above?? Type 1 and Type 2 are not the same and I'm fed up with how even medical people don't differentiate?

5
chickaboom_MD•

We’re discussing lifestyle, therefore type 2 is implied. Type 1 diabetes cannot be managed without insulin.

5
nag204IM Attending•

Its already is. You can't change people unless they want to change themselves. Every doc has done the let's try diet and exercise and see in a few months and low and behold it's time to start meds.

3
rocketlac•

Annual screens are not done everywhere and are not standardized in US, but should be. No disrespect, but Haha “let’s try diet and exercise” without any education, education follow up or accountability is super ineffective, no wonder patients don’t do well. What if you start them on meds as well as nutrition education and present them as equally important treatment approaches? At least they have all they need to treat their disease. My patients do so much better (I am an RD) when their provider is just as interested and engaged in dietary changes as they are the meds.

3
nag204IM Attending•

The annual physical? It's quite common. Even so a visit one time a year isn't going to do a lot to change people. The education is there and frankly at this point people know exercise is good and eating fast food and crap is bad. It's not hard to Google the Mediterranean diet or dash diet either and I give printouts at times as well.

The whole point of trying lifestyle changes first is to avoid starting meds. But the lifestyle changes are usually middling. People are motivated for the first few weeks and then slip back to their old habits. Education needs to start in childhood. Healthy habits need to start then as well. Adults in bad habits usually need a big event before they Implement real change and the sad reality is most won't until they've already done significant damage to themselves.

1
KetosisMDMD•

COVID19 hard on the body, as seen as worsening glycemic control

Would the same be true for any severe viral infection ?

or do people feel it's SARS-CoV2 specific ?

to me, the mechanism is:

oxidative stress -> worsening insulin sensitivity -> inactivity -> worsening insulin sensitivity -> hyperglycemia

Is the oxidative stress of COVID19 worse than an equivalently bad influenza ?

23
dr_exerciseABD (covid casualty)- physiology•

Not that I disagree with your proposition, but I have Just a few thoughts about the mechanism laid out:

Oxidative stress is rather nebulous. What free radicals are being produced? From what sources? I ask because, in a hypothetical sense, antioxidant(s) should have a rescue effect on insulin sensitivity then. However, Other non-oxidative signals originating from cellular activation can result in reduced insulin sensitivity (eg TNF-a) within endothelial and skeletal muscle cells.

How does reduced insulin sensitivity lead to inactivity in this model?

9
KetosisMDMD•

I meant more that both oxidative stress and inactivity from being ill worsen insulin sensitivity / glycemic control.

TNF alpha

Great point 👊

2
Yeti_MDEmergency Medicine Physician•

Yeah, there's nothing magic about COVID-19 much as people want to blame it for all our problems.

6†
steve20202020•

Actually it is different, there’s evidence covid directly infiltrates pancreatic beta cells

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34081912/

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-23886-3

34
CouldveBeenPoofsVirology Research•

I mean that’s not particularly unique. For example, mumps, rubella, and influenza all do the same. Taking it a step further, in the last link they could induce diabetes in birds via influenza infection.

2
MEANINGLESS_NUMBERSMD - Peds/Neo•

And does what? Reduces peripheral insulin sensitivity? That doesn’t even make sense.

It does seem to (very rarely) trigger an autoimmune cascade that ends in type 1 diabetes, but that’s not what we are talking about here.

-6†
steve20202020•

Well yes it does make complete sense, if I have a patient with a degree of peripheral insulin resistance, and I then directly disrupt their pancreatic beta cell function with the mechanisms in those papers (if you bothered to look at them) what do you think will then happen as a result of that?? 😂 Clue : it’s not that their blood sugar control/ islet function and metabolic regulation will improve. This is not the auto immune phenomenon that you’re talking about

19
evan_is•

I feel like this is extremely old news

15
educateyourself1•

I think increased mental health options might help people take better care of their bodies and therefore decrease the prevalence of diabetes.

14
CarolinaReaperHeaperMD•

Talking about structural issues in diabetic care...

https://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/11/nyregion/nyregionspecial5/in-the-treatment-of-diabetes-success-often-does.html

tl;dr Several hospitals in NYC setup diabetes clinics that were so successful in reducing long-term diabetic complications like amputations and dialysis that they had to close them because they were losing too much money. Hospitals weren't dumb. They actually knew that diabetic care would lose money, but expected to make up the difference with the surgeries they would get from all these new diabetics they would be attracting. IOW, if they were only a little bit successful, it would have been fine, but they were *too* successful in their diabetic care and lost money.

tl;dr #2. Insurance companies aren't stupid either. Why fund chronic care today to prevent a foot amputation done on some other insurance company's dime 20 years later? They deliberately underfund chronic diabetic care because otherwise, they would attract too many diabetic patients. The name of the game in insurance is to attract healthy patients, and dump sick patients. If you paid well for chronic diabetic care, you'd attract diabetic patients in droves, on which you'd spend tons to bend the curve of their complications, only for them to switch insurances and some company 20 years in the future to benefit from not needing to start dialysis.

IOW, the structural moral hazards and perverse incentives built into our system due to our fragmented private insurance system go far deeper than simply that diabetes is difficult to manage or that our nutrition system is driven by the needs of Big Ag. Only a payment system that knows it will cover you from cradle to grave, and can't escape consequences by dumping you before you get sick, has the proper incentive to prevent future catastrophic complications by spending money today.

11
mudskippieMD, Hollywood Upstairs Medical•

Let's put a diabetes tax on every beverage sweetened naturally or artificially by a sugar impacting blood glucose. Liquid sugar is such a curse.

10

I think we need an ad campaign, like the "tips from former smokers". You could have tips from diabetics:

The amputee talking about the importance of foot care. Someone at dialysis explaining how taking up a hobby like knitting or crocheting helps pass the time at dialysis. The diabetic getting an injection into their eyeball. The poorly-controlled type II showing all their medications and the monthly cost.

That sort of thing.

14
Activity_Inside•

How about the amputee talking about the importance of having feet and the impact of not having them anymore because he wanted sweet treaties instead of low blood sugar?

5
v29130Non-traditional pre-med & current admin•

I thought this was established two years ago...seems like the NYT is doing lazy "reporting" and rehashing old stories. And I only put reporting in quotes because when you report on something established two years ago, its really not "reporting".

4
Gracie1994•

Tackle obesity,...that might be helpful.

2
GoodLt•

Well, we would but DONT YOU TELL ME I CAN’T EAT 57 CHEESEBURGERS AND 12 COKES A SITTING! THIS IS MURICA!! FREEDUMB!! 😁

0†
AlyciaDCRDN•

Dietitians…………………………….

2