Just a random thought. But let's say that a season would have the first ever two-time finalist. While I wouldn't want that to happen since I'd want other competitors to have a chance at being a finalist, I'm still curious about who might deserve being a finalist for a second time.
Posted Apr 6, 2022, 11:45 PM UTC
Definitely Gwen. She was easily one of the franchise's most deserving winners, and yet she was one of the few who never got to keep her well-earned money.
For sure
I would say Mike because I think he deserves a better win that what happened in TDAS, but from this list I go Gwen.
Lightning Sha-Duh 🙄
I would be totally opposed to seeing anyone be a finalist twice unless in an All Winners season, in which case Gwen Vs. Heather all the way.
As much as I wanna pick Gwen, I gotta say put some respect on my man sha-Lightning
Lindsay obviously but off the list Alejandro to prove that he is truly the greatest villain in TD
And because I think Alejandro would not like the fact that he only won because Heather threw a wrong dummy. IMO he he would even find it disrespectful.
It's a toss-up between Gwen, Duncan and Alejandro.
Gwen's ending is the only one that's repeatedly confirmed to not be canon, so to give her a win that sticks would at least even the playing field for her.
Meanwhile, Duncan and Alejandro are both fantastic competitors with rather mediocre season victories, and they each deserve a chance to have a win that better reflects the kind of players they are.
I would say Sky because she's very athletic and has got skill.
Gwen, Heather, Lightning, or Mike.
I still don’t get why so many people pick Heather. Her arc is already over.
Probably 'cause even in her ending, she didn't get to keep the money.
Probably, but that’s a pretty weak reason just to see a character go through the same arc again.
At least Heather could stay good for real.
Owen Gwen or Heather but mainly Owen since he didn’t really get his money i know the same goes for Gwen and Heather but i would want Owen to win again in a slightly different way.
Mike or Gwen.
Beth because people forgot she was a finalist anyway.
Beth, she needs a finale run that's actually written well enough for people to appreciate her. She's got the same problem as Lightning where they saved all her big moments for the very end.
Gwen or Heather
Lightning!
Duncan because I think it would be better and more-in-line with Total Drama's theme if he won by defeating Beth in a fair competition instead of relying on a swing vote (and because I think it was unfair that all Beth had to do was correctly answer the trivia while Duncan had to redo every TDA challenge in one day).
Gwen considering she never actually got her money.