Astraea_M•

So we have a story about a heroic climber who risks his own life to help another, and the comments are all about how it's expected, and that mentioning that he is Israeli is lame? Seriously? You folks have issues. Volumes even.

73
[deleted]•

rescuing other climbers is actually against the norm because it's often too dangerous. The outcome is often that both climbers end up perishing

30
Ex-Sgt_Wintergreen•

Also, people die there all the time and it's very expensive to climb it. You'd be rescuing just one of many morons for the price of tens of thousands of dollars, significant mortal risk to yourself, and months of preparation.

14
[deleted]•

costs are easily recouped and there's plenty of time. I'm sure they'd have a rescue helicopter on standby at all times if that was feasible. However, due to winds and other environmental factors it's not. The reasons rescues aren't attempted isn't because of the capital involved, it's because of the risk of becoming the second victim

3
Heidegger•

Tens of thousands for a mere life!? And a potential idiot's life at that! What a hero!

3
[deleted]•

The only reason this is a story is because of their nationality.

Israelis hate Turks so it's unusual that one would help a Turk.

If these two were of any other nationality we would not be talking about it.

-11
WelshDwarf•

Does make you think of the good samaritan though :)

5
[deleted]•

For all we know it's a propaganda piece.

-12
WelshDwarf•

To be honest, this deosn't change Jack about what I think of Isreali policy (they should get their head on straight for once and stop pandering), and it doesn't change Jack about what I think of Isrealis (never met them, so no opinion).

If this was a propaganda piece, then I declare it an epic fail.

0
[deleted]•

We are all humans, and we shouldn't let politics, religion, or anything else trump that.

43
wq678•

If only you actually adhered to that.

From one of your other comments:

Go figure, the arabs are racist as fuck.

Yes, it's clearly the Arabs who are racist...

32
[deleted]•

[deleted]

31
wq678•

From Wiki:

The Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) published reports documenting racism in Israel, and the 2007 report suggested that anti-Arab racism in the country was increasing. One analysis of the report summarized it thus: "Over two-thirds Israeli teens believe Arabs to be less intelligent, uncultured and violent. Over a third of Israeli teens fear Arabs all together....The report becomes even grimmer, citing the ACRI's racism poll, taken in March 2007, in which 50% of Israelis taking part said they would not live in the same building as Arabs, will not befriend, or let their children befriend Arabs and would not let Arabs into their homes."[11]

A March 2010 poll by Tel Aviv University found that 49.5% of Israeli Jewish high school students believe Israeli Arabs should not be entitled to the same rights as Jews in Israel. 56% believe Arabs should not be eligible to the Knesset, the Israeli parliament.[16]

An October 2010 poll by the Dahaf polling agency found that 36% of Israeli Jews favor eliminating voting rights for non-Jews.[17]

Now what would your reaction be if the top comment here was made by someone who said "Go figure, the Israeli Jews are racist as fuck"?

Edit: Just to clarify: I would never make the above comment, but I would like to know if Ijustlostmyjengajam would react the same way if Israeli Jews were targeted by such a comment, instead of Arab people.

13
cojack22•

uhh that happens all the time. It would probably have 100+ up votes.

Edit: Looks like wq678 got his SRS friends for a down vote fest in this thread.

22
cojack22•

Just found out you're an SRS goon. Please go back to your fantasy land subreddit.

14
7daniel7•

Oh yes, yes they are

-2
tunapepper•

Most of those surveyed are not even Arab. You appear to be one of those that literally does not know the difference between 'Arab' and 'Muslim'.

1
Rusty-Shackleford•

well that just goes to show that the more diversity, the more tolerant people are. I mean, how much tolerance can one expect from countries run by Monarchs?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
lolrsk8s•

Arab culture, on the whole, is pretty racist.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_the_Arab_world#Affected_victims

Edit: looks like Islamophiles have discovered 'tu quoque'

7
theamplifiedorganic•

Ahem.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_Israel

We could even start talking about America, the UK, Australia, India, etc. But at a certain point, when discussing other nationalities/religions/races, you get arguably close to making racist remarks/generalities yourself.

So let's not stoop.

8
lolrsk8s•

tu quoque

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-10
MUSTKILLNOOBS•

You know not all Jews are bad and not all of them support Israel right?

-1
[deleted]•

Fuck you Jewish holier-than-though asswipes! Hoep you like it when you get the shit bombed out of you and get forcefully sent away from the land you stole from us.

you have a lot of nerve to call us racist when the Israeli Jews have treated the palestinians and arabs worse than they have been treated in their entire history. Don't act like a bunch of fuckin-do-gooders, we know what you're really like.

-29
Vslacha•

How the fuck did you just get three upvotes for this bullshit. r/worldnews is even worse than I thought.

13
aroogu•

...treated the palestinians and arabs worse than they have been treated in their entire history.

Except, of course, that the treatment is much gentler than how Palestinians & Arabs treat themselves & each other.

8
edisekeed•

Wasn't it the arabs that have attacked Israel multiple times Mr. Intifada??? Dont kid yourself?

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
timeandspace11•

There is know doubt the Palestinians have been treated horribly. They deserve their own state and a better livelihood. But calling for violence wont get you anywhere. The radical element of hamas has done more harm than good, and if some sort of war did break out the region would be harmed a great deal.

1
[deleted]•

You need to change your additude. Your doing an amazing job at convincing people to support Israel over Palestine in this issue.

If your in the right, you should not need to act like a fustrated teenager.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
meh1234•

Of course, you Arabs celebrate the Religion of Peace!

-5
[deleted]•

I don't think it's fair to be judging the peacefulness of either of these countries right now considering they're at war.

1
Mel___Gibson•

The Jew is just waiting for you to lower your guard.

-8
[deleted]•

Either your nieve or an apologist for Arab's problems, anyways, since when are Arabs a race?

-12
PaperInFireOP•

Agreed. In a better world, where such things didn't matter, that headline might read "Climber gives up summit to help another climber." But in this one, it's so remarkable these two were from different countries that both nationalities made it into the lead.

9
[deleted]•

Nah i think its important, it shows the veracity of my thought that humanity lives beyond sensationalist borders of religion or country.

-2
WTS_BRIDGE•

As admirable as it is, I can't help but seeing it in context as an Israeli agit-prop piece, intended to highlight for domestic and foreign English-speaking audiences, exactly how much Israel has sacrificed to help its neighbors in the Middle East, particularly vis a vi Turkey. This would be in keeping with the recent push in US media to idolize the Six-Days War.

-17
[deleted]•

Yes, and I hate it how every time there's a natural disaster (Haiti etc.) Israeli rescue teams show up and start saving lives.

Damned agit-prop idiots.

And you're a troll.

19
[deleted]•

so... American rescue teams.

-2
meh1234•

Israel kicked so much ass in 1948 Arab-Israeli war, the Six Day war and the Yom Kippur war!

I know it doesn't live up to your idologies; however, when natural disasters happen Israel has a history of humanitarian missions.

9
WTS_BRIDGE•

I'm not saying Israel doesn't do any good; I'm suggesting it does more harm than anything else.

-4
achtungman•

You mean paid by american taxpayers?

-7
[deleted]•

Especially not on an extremely-dangerous mountain climb where keeping your partners alive increases the chances of your own survival.

3
redgator•

Wow. You just got your ass handed to you Rosiee.

3
KeavesSharpi•

True, but this wouldn't be news if a Japanese helped a Turk, or a Frenchman. "Look at how great Israelis are!"

0
emasua•

The phony who claims to have visited Israeli has become a humanitarian?

-3
[deleted]•

In that case let the title be: "Israeli helps Turk" or "Human helps Another". We don't need to have the Israeli 'sacrifice' be pushed at the reader.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-16
[deleted]•

Calm. Down.

0
ex_israeli•

Look who's talking... Rosiee... the user who regularly demonizes Palestinians and one of r/israel's strongest Apartheid supporters...

These fucking racist jewish supremacist assholes from r/israel know that their Apartheid State is being exposed so they submit feel-good Hasbara stories to try to mend their image. Guess what? There were also good and normal people in Nazi Germany. That doesn't change the essence of that state.

-18
cojack22•

oh please you're basically a troll.

7
batmanmilktruck•

-4100 comment karma

basically? no that is one very committed troll.

8
slackmaster•

a better life achievement, imho.

42
thatonedeadguy•

I concur with this. I know it is nothing spectacular, but I have about 38 of the 53, 14,000 foot peaks (known as 14ers) in Colorado under my belt as a 22yo climber. I know firsthand that the serious climbers that I encounter would abandon their climb if they encountered an injured climber. The climb can be accomplished at a later date. We will always put aside differences to make sure that some one else has a later date...

14
deadrabbitt•

Good on this human being to help out another human being.

34
envstat•

Brian Blessed did this in 1991. He was very close to the summit, around 29,000 ft up, but stopped just short to rescue a guy. He also wore only the clothes that Mallory wore in 1924 and did it with no oxygen bottles.

18
gunner_b•

He is also part fucking gorilla so I doubt he strained much to do it.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
theamplifiedorganic•

One of the guys my dad did it with a couple years back (dad didn't summit) refused to use O2.

He died.

I understand the passion and drive behind doing things the way he did, but when the guide of lifetime experience tells you to use the damn canisters, I don't care how big your balls are - you either use it, or at least don't be surprised when you feel the curtains closing.

8
heathengray•

To be fair though, Blessed could have flown up to the top, shouting something about Gordon being alive.

2
envstat•

Ah, well; who wants to live forever? DIVE!

Might not have gone down too well on the summit.

2
rnrl•

so? Chuck Norris rescued 2 in a thong. twice.

1
Sarahmint•

A lot better then other stories I hear where climbers on that VERY SAME SUMMIT have nightmares about injured climbers they abandoned to the death. :'(

16
PaperInFireOP•

True, it does has have a happier ending. But...as we've discussing in another thread about Everest, the problem with trying to help or rescue anyone on Everest is that the most likely outcome is that you'll BOTH die. And one of the first rules of rescue is "never be the second victim" -- it's noble and self-sacrificing and heroic, but it just means two bodies instead of one.

That's what I find most remarkable about this story: not only did the rescuer make the decision to incur the tremendous risk to his own life -- and he must have known he was doing so, not only did he manage not to die in the process, but he also managed to get the victim off the mountain alive. When we finally find out exactly what happened up there, my guess is that the story will be amazing.

23

All knowing that nobody would do the same thing for him had he been in that spot.

10
outerspacemann•

Amazing how sometimes people really step up to the plate, regardless of the consequences? Here's one of those guys. They're rare.

3
timeandspace11•

Agreed. I saw this documentary once when people were discussing how some may have had priority issues. Meaning some climbers felt a greater emphasis needed to placed on helping on injured climbers then reaching the summit. Of course there are times when people do not have the ability for others. It is a dangerous activity but from what Ive heard it can be extremely rewarding.

3
tamirmal•

he also fears losing his fingers, as he gave up his gloves to carry the man...good guy

16
Rusty-Shackleford•

Something something Zionist oppression. Karma Please!

13
bigfig•

I'm cynical about a lot, but you gotta do these things.

10
71Comet•

I love how "worldnews" is just an anti-Israeli circlejerk.

9
Bear_Sheba•

Human climber gives up on Everest summit attempt to help Human climber. Both men said to have nationalities.

6
BadluckBro•

And saved two climbers in the process

0
[deleted]•

What does the fact that he is Israeli have to do with anything. the title should be "Man gives up on Everest summit to help fellow climber"

You shouldn't congratulate him for not being an asshole, you should congratulate him on saving another man's life.

5
quatso•

i agree, but the thing is turkey and israel are in a tense relationship right now and this might help a bit (although it's just being human). btw this guy might also lose some limbs to the frost.

6
Rusty-Shackleford•

But they're not congratulating him for not being an asshole.

1
orthecreedence•

"Person gives up on Everest summit to help another person" FTFY

4
Java_Beans•

Palestinian here, I applaud that guy for what he did there. As a Muslim I believe that "who ever saves man life - it is as he saved mankind entirely" Quran 5:32.

He was 300 meters away from the peak and if succeed he would've become the youngest Israeli to do so. You need to have high love to humanity to something like that at those conditions.

4
AmericanGoyBlog•

An israeli is a human being, with empathy and shit - news at 11!

3
aaegler•

Everest is an anti-Semite!

3
aldonley•

What is with the labels, what is the importance of saying Israeli and Turkish? I don't even think this is worth a news story there must be some greater motivation for this article to be written.

3
WrongAssumption•

Yet if they mentioned a Swedish climber everyone would think it totally relevant and go on to mention how awesome Swedes are and how only a Swede would do this.

2
[deleted]•

Yes sir you are correct. Propaganda much?

There has been a couple of incidents on the news that make israel look bad, so they come up with this

1
Throw_a_HAAAY•

They come up with this because they know that a bunch of people on the internet who think that Israel is 'the devil' will click on it, and they will get ad revenue. My god, there are plenty of reasons to be pro-Palestine but the people on Reddit who denounce Israel just come off sounding paranoid and ignorant.

5
[deleted]•

It's a propaganda piece.

-4
timeandspace11•

Glad to see this, hopefully the Israeli will still have time to break the record.

I think it is vital for the region for Israel and Turkey to be allies. If this alliance were to happen Turkey could be a strong mediator in the quest for a two state solution.

Israel and Turkey I have heard also have two of the coolest cities in the Middle East: Istanbul and Tel Aviv

2
thats_not_what_I_do•

The picture of the guy is a hilarious choice for such an article

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
annoymind•

I don't get why people are so crazy about Mt. Everest. I haven't been myself but I only heard really bad stories. And it's fucking expensive. The main problem is that it's just too damn crowded. Sometimes there even is gridlock to the summit. The base camps are more like small messy towns. Some vendors sell broken supplies/equipment for high prices. Expeditions are stealing supplies/equipment of other expeditions because everything is fucking expensive. There are too many people not physically fit or too old (mid life crisis). And in the death zone you walk over bodies (some of them got named, e.g. green boots). If you are unlucky you find someone who is still alive. But helping them usually is your own death sentence. It's just a mess.

That doesn't sound like a fun adventure at all.

2