r/dune•
subucula

If Leto wanted to (eventually) free humanity...

SpoilerAll Books Spoilers

... from prescience, why did he put his own prescient consciousness into sandworms? Or was that unintentional, a side-effect of a plan that required becoming part-sandworm to live long enough, etc.?

Context: If I recall correctly, in Heretics of Dune the Bene Gesserit realize that the continued presence of Leto II's prescient consciousness in sandworms traps humanity in his vision. So they orchestrate the destruction of (Ar)Rakis at the hands of the Honored Matres.

Except they save one sandworm, so it seems like they didn't actually fix the problem. If one sandworm survived, it would seem that so did Leto II's prescient consciousness.

Posted Apr 12, 2022, 12:28 AM UTC

717
BossgrimmMentat•

Leto gave humanity the best chance it could get to grow beyond prescience, centralized government/religion and being influenced by the dramatic. He knew that he could only do so much and that the stage would have to be set for future humanity to take the reins and do this not only without him but directly against him. He knew that a pearl of his awareness would persist, and his message at the horde at Sietch Tabr was meant as a final spur to get humanity (albeit through the BG) pointed in the right direction. Taraza knew the need to overcome this force, but didn’t have quite the right vision for the future. Leto’s path became open-ended, allowing humanity to face the fruits of its past as the results of the scattering were felt.

13
Dana07620•

IIRC, they mentioned that by the time the sandworm numbers would increase, humanity would be beyond the reach of their prescient influence.

9
BaldandersDAO•

My take: Leto needed everything to reach the point of the BG finding his message to them, to ensure a successful "launch" to his Golden Path, so having his remnants remain to that point was necessary to keep things on track. (Maybe to ensure the BG are around to unite the Old Imperium?) After the BG find the message, the Path requires no one can predict any large scale events, and Arrakis gets razed to ensure that---as Leto foresaw.

5
subuculaOP•

Makes sense. But it didn't, work, right? Because the Bene Gesserit save a sandworm (and in the Brian Herbert sequels, it turns out a bunch of Arrakis sandworms survived by burrowing deeper down, but let's ignore the sequels).

3
BaldandersDAO•

As another poster pointed out, the BG figured there would be too many humans with the prescient-invisible gene at the point that sandworm became a whole ecology for it to matter.

Evidently, the sheer number of sandworms on Arrakis added up to the "frozen future effect" of one Leto, but one sandworm had little effect.

IMO, we should always avoid consideration or direct mention of the Abominations. (I've read 2 or 3....it was like watching a car wreck)

3
subuculaOP•

I agree with you on that. Give those abominations to the storm, to paraphrase the last Padishah Emperor!

2
Demos_TexFedaykin•

The BG have a history of overestimating their grasp of things that they don't really understand and can't control. Leto saw far enough that he knew who would discover his spice hoard. Why would the BG still imagine that they could thwart him or the Golden Path?

My guess would be that there's a point in the far future that's past his vision, but by that point the continued scattering over thousands of years would've done the work he wanted anyway.

5
slycam86•

Unintentional side effect from his atredies genes, as far th BG believing his consciousness in the new worm trapping them in his vision i just chalk that up to their typical resentment toward "The Tyrant"

3
lunar999•

Yeah, that always bugged me as well. It's worth noting that due to buying second-hand books as and when I could, I actually read Chapterhouse before Heretics, so my view on it is kind of different. In Heretics, it's painted as kind of a deliberate plan, eliminate the sandworms to eliminate Leto's vision, but in Chapterhouse, it's portrayed as "oh crap, we had no idea the Honoured Matres would go that far and now we're screwed". I lean much more towards the latter interpretation.

The best I can guess is that the BG made a mistake. They assumed that Leto's prescient vision worked the same as Paul's, someone who had seen all of the futures, chosen one, and by doing so locked humanity into that vision. This is reinforced by how Leto used his power, the Tyrant forcing the Empire into a fixed immutable shape for his entire lifespan and then it exploding as soon as his influence was removed. The difference seems to be, Leto used his power only (with rare exceptions, such as looking at Hwi's short-term future) for humanity's survival. That was all. The only parts of humanity's fate that was locked into a vision were the parts that immediately impacted that, everything else was still free will, or at least as close as one can get in a universe like Dune's. We know that having prescience and using it are two different things. Odrade had a constant prescient warning throughout Chapterhouse - the hunter with the ax - but was resolved to not risk locking in a future by questing for detail.

I will leave things with this quote that seems to imply Odrade's acknowledgment of how the Tyrant was not maintaining a grip on humanity, but he wanted people to think he did:

Ahhh, Tyrant! You droll fellow. You saw it. You said: "I will create order for you to follow. Here is the path. See it? No! Don’t look over there. That is the way of the Emperor-Without-Clothes (a nakedness apparent only to children and the insane). Keep your attention where I direct it. This is my Golden Path. Isn’t that a pretty name? It’s all there is and all there ever will be."

3
subuculaOP•

OK that makes a lot of sense - thanks for explaining! It would also mean that the Bene Gesserit saving one sandworm from extinction didn't undo anything, either.

1
GraconBease•

The pearls of consciousness are made out as a sacrifice undertaken by Leto, so I assumed it was out of his control, a side-effect as you mentioned. With that in mind, I think he still incorporated it into his plan the best he could; he knew the Bene Gesserit were purposeless outside of wanting general control of the universe, so he used the worms to make them realize this, giving them a new "noble purpose." I think his plan was also to employ them to remove the sandworms, since he could but die and let them spread.

3
subuculaOP•

I like that, that makes sense. But then, do the Bene Gesserit mess it all up by saving a sandworm (to take to Chapterhouse and turn that planet into a new Arrakis)? A single sandworm left means Leto's consciousness, however small, remains.

Weird.

1
pete_k22•

This may be a dumb question that’s been answered here already, but can someone explain how the presence of sandtrout with pearls of Leto’s consciousness after his death locks/traps humanity into his presience/presient vision?

2
subuculaOP•

The general idea is that someone like Paul or Leto II, with a strong prescient vision, being alive locks humanity into one of the paths that they see. There are (at least) two ways to understand this, in my mind.

The more trivial one, but the one that makes more sense (is less "mystical") is simply that there being a powerful figure with prescience or a figure with powerful prescience rules out any possible futures for humanity where prescience wasn't important. In other words, there being someone with powerful prescience itself excludes any possible futures that required there to not be anyone with prescience.

That much makes sense. But it doesn't really help here, because sure, the sandtrout have some prescience from Leto II, but they can't actually affect human behavior.

The less trivial understanding, one that's probably required here, is that once Leto II (or even Paul, who said that he himself was locked in on a path he didn't like by his early choices) set up the Golden Path, humanity will stay on that path for as long as the prescient vision he used to create it exists - even after Leto II stops being able to direct humanity. All it takes is his vision remaining, not his power.

This is a bit mystical, a bit magical. But it's the only thing that makes sense to me.

So, to answer your question, Leto II's consciousness persisting in the sandtrout means he is, in effect, still alive. His prescient vision remains, still locking humanity into a course, or locking it out of others.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

-4
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

0