A Backrooms theory for consideration.

SpoilerNew Game Theory!

Hello everyone. I'm sure by now most if not all of you have seen MatPat's latest video on the Backrooms, but some of the things highlighted there got me thinking and while I don't want to sound like some "um akshually" type of person, something about it just didn't add up for me. So I went and re-watched the videos in both release order and then in canonical chronological order and I...might have found something.

Now a disclaimer; I've not gone into the deep-dive of bacterial phenomenon that Matpat did, or indeed a deep-dive of anything. This is me trying to take what's given at face value, so to speak, and I'll explain why in a moment.

In short, I don't think the Backrooms is meant to be a part of an implicit simulated reality. If anything I think I can prove it's something far darker. At least within the context we're given.

My first piece of evidence for this is garbage. Literally. Now this is a dumpster seen in the "first" video, the Found Footage video. What struck me was that there's graffiti along the bottom. So what, right? Except dumpsters don't "start out" with graffiti on them. Which means someone must have put it there. If you were lost in this place and you had the ability, inclination and excess spray paint to tag something, why would you wait until you saw a dumpster?

Now, sure, we do see other drawings in the same video. The arrows on the walls leading to what appear to be a warning about the monster. The same advice that Kane completely fails to follow (stand still, don't move) and runs for his life. But look at the actual arrow and the warnings Neither are done with spray-paint and even if they were the colour is different. In fact it looks like they're written in the same mouldy explosion goop we see later but I'll get to that. In fact we can prove that whoever made this had no tools, because there's a handprint in the top left. This was done partly through "finger-painting" it on somehow.

Which means that at some point that dumpster must have been accessable to someone outside the Backrooms and then was either brought into them or returned to them. So what? Games have assets added and removed all the time, that's what state-changes are, I hear you say.

But that got me to dig deeper.

When I was re-watching The Informational video I noticed something I'd been hoping to find. When we see the team later in the video (and occasionally also other teams in other videos) walking around, one is holding a red rope or line which leads the way back. You can clearly see the start or anchor point of this line here Why is this important? Because later when the team "glitches" out, the line disappears too. Why is this important? Because it shows that these teams aren't used to this happening. What's interesting is that the teammates of that researcher don't respond to anything he says before or after he enters the side-hall that protects him from "the glitch." Which might in itself be a clue, he's lured over by sound, sound that stops as soon as the glitch occurs, and he can't rely on his voice in that area to communicate, but look at the team as they walk past. Entirely calm, entirely unconcerned, they just lost sight of a teammate and they don't seem to care. How can you explain that? They obviously know that getting lost is a serious risk, that's why they're pulling a lifeline along behind them in the first place and relying on compass points rather than left or right to orient themselves.

It's almost as if the team didn't know he existed.

Now, let's consider the end of that video. The lost researcher finds what appears to be an exit door locked with a keycard lock, and he steps through into what appears to be some kind of control room. Presumably run by Async since his keycard opens the door, and presumably connected to the rest of some kind of facility because it has workdesks and some kind of larger servers, as well as a big exit door and non-Backroom lighting. Why is this important? Because we can see this room being built in the "motion detected" video. Here it is in the informational video, notice the columns and the tiles, and here is the room under construction. Again, the plus-sign shaped columns and the tiles. So Why. WHY is this so important?

Because the date of the instructional video is the leap year, 02/29/1990. The motion detected video's date is 03/05/1990. Six days AFTER the room is apparantely discovered by that researcher. He stumbled upon a room that Async had not yet started building. Which means it wasn't his team that was glitched, it was him, and it wasn't a glitch. The clue was in the date the entire time. 02/29/1990, a day that never happened, a time that never happened. That researcher didn't lose his team, that researcher was moved through time into the future, he manages to retrace his steps and get back to the threshold, but by now the motion detector cameras have been set up and caught the monsters, so by now Async knows it needs to protect its' researchers better while still being able to observe. the Threshold is widened, as we see in the instructional video, and other "glitches" have clearly been reported because Async has replaced Backroom lighting with its' own, maybe hoping that glitches can't happen if the lights don't flick off. That's also why the alarm goes off even though the researcher accessed the room with a valid keycard. It's a failsafe, something has entered the room when nobody should be in there, which means it's probably a monster.

In fact I think there's another clue to support this theory in the autopsy video. The Doctor points out that the decomposition of the body makes identifying the date of death very difficult, but he also states that the body seems to have simply stopped decomposing in some places. A minor throaway line, maybe, or is it? Because judging by the black goop explosion we can probably safely assume that this is the person that wrote the warning messages and arrows that Kane finds years later because the body shows some of the same identifiers MatPat talked about; hoodie, wide nose, tall forehead. However, that would mean that the black goop is presumably organic, but if it's organic it too should eventually break down over time, but it doesn't. A full six years between the death of Nicholas Bolton and Kane's entry into the backrooms that goop is still there. Sure some of the arrow has faded but you can still make out just about everything else. Kind of, it's panicky. So why does this matter? Because decomposition doesn't just stop, especially not for six entire years. It can be slowed down, sure, and sped up too, but it can't be outright halted, and most liquids in the body will be gone after just one year, in Nicholas' case they seemed to be gone after just a handful of days which makes sense if he died of malnutrition. So why is the black goop still there? Because in that part of the Backrooms, for whatever reason, time halted, the decomposition of the goop ceased, and the message was preserved for Kane to find.

The term "noclipping" was used in the original description of the backrooms, and MatPat was right to identify that as a gaming term. Idnoclip is a cheat code I used a lot when I couldn't find the right skull or keycard in Doom as a kid. But what if "noclip" is an oversimplification? What if you're not slipping through space, but through time...because there's one more clue I think that points to the Back Rooms being a different time rather than a different place, and that's Kane's Camera.

At the end of Found Footage Kane is attacked by the monster, drops his camera and we watch from its' point of view as it tumbles down a slope and seems to appear again in our world, but instead of appear out of a wall or through a floor, it spawns in mid-air, and falls for more than long enough to have killed Kane if he'd followed it. If the prior theory about time standing still in that section of the Back Rooms is accurate then "our" time kept going, which means that the camera could have found the exact same entry point, remember Kane "fell" into the Backrooms, but the planet itself had moved sufficiently far that instead of being at ground level it was now in mid-air. It would help explain why even with the jump in missing persons since the back rooms were opened, discovering them still seems to be pretty rare. Now sure, the Back Rooms are huge, but if entering and exiting is as simple as finding the right spot then the more people that go in, the more evidence they should leave of their presence and the more should start to just accidentally find exits, but there aren't, which suggests it's less about where and more about "when".

There is one final clue that the Back Rooms are about a different time, rather than a different place...and that's Async itself. Asynchronous simply means...not happening at the same time. It's a little obvious, I know, but I feel like with how often their logo gets pushed in our faces it seems like someone is saying "Please notice this Senpai"

The various objects, from the axe to the dumpster to the filing cabinets, aren't there because they weren't used. They very obviously were intended for use. They're there because they're from different times. They're things that have been lost, things people put down or left in storage and lost track of, and now they're preserved, because rope is made out of fiber and that axe had a wooden handle, those things break down too, given enough time, and yet they haven't. The time-jump hypothesis also helps prove how an entire team and their lifeline could be lost when that lifeline existed outside the Backrooms. They didn't stop existing, the researched jumped to a point after they had left and they'd taken the lifeline with them.

BUT HEY, THAT'S no I'm not doing that, that is not my thing to do. If you disagree then please fogive my insane ramblings, I'm going to go pre-emptively stand in the corner now. But also fight me.

Edit: Damnit I just realised I used the wrong flair as it's a film theory. My apologies.

Posted Apr 13, 2022, 12:31 AM UTC · edited

106

BUT HEY, That's just a Theory! A GAME THEORYYYYYY!

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

Welcome to r/GameTheorists!

Make sure to read the rules and we also have a discord!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
BananaArcher72•

Very interesting! Also seems kinda plausible. I hope matpat reads this

1
VeridasOP•

I doubt that will happen, but thank you for saying so.

1
Orc_Magnum•

That was very well done good sir, I applaud you.

1
VeridasOP•

Thank you very much.

2