jmcgeejr•

My guess is that the TV manufacturers lobby will put up a major stink on this, since a lot of tv's have been sold with ATSC 3.0 support.

6
Ginge_Leader•

See the thread on SiliconDust's forum for clarification on the (non) issue.

https://forum.silicondust.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=76772

Sounds like the Tablo article is either misunderstanding/communication issue or just them trying to make an excuse for why they screwed up and their product will be delayed, since there isn't any new part of the standard that they wouldn't have been aware of.

6
Qasar30•

Wow. A simple explanation VS. pending doom for all ever created to date.

3
PoundKitchen•

Best I can figure is the station(s) might want to makeup lost revenue, from cable companies losing customers, with a paid subscription for the ATCS3 version OTA.

Enabling DRM in any device could be as simple as a firmware update and the device contacting an authentication or key server. Not hard, far from impossible or bricking devices. In that regard, the article is Chicken Litte click-bait.

4
IHScoutII•

I think it is more like OTA stations might offer a pay per view service for new movies and other content like certain sporting events. I don't see regular network programming going paid.

3
Ginge_Leader•

with a paid subscription for the ATCS3 version OTA.

Yeah, if you mean pay for any of the currently-free stations, I see the amount of people being willing to do that being only slightly more than zero. I imagine there is no overlap in the venn diagram of people who go through the trouble of setting up OTA and the people who are willing to pay for the stations that have always been free OTA.

But like IHScouttII, I expect there will be some sort of pay service that is encrypted as is already being done via Evoca (though they require their own receiver).

2
PoundKitchen•

Yeah, chosing to pay for clunky 4K and lossy Atmos over HD with 5.1... pass!

As cord-cutters are now opting for streaming services over antenna channels, offering an subscription OTA station with streaming service grade content makes sense, particularly PPV.

1
PoundKitchen•

I don't see regular network programming going paid.

I can't imagine it'll be worth the outlay, but who knows what the Sinclairs and Nexstars are thinking and planning. For example, when Nexstar takes over CW they could be carrying CW, WB, and CBS content OTA. That could be under a subscription.

1
IHScoutII•

I can totally see them making events like the super bowl a paid event.

2
DrSueuss•

I am pretty sure they will work as the ATSC 3.0 spec was finalized on February 2, 2018 and manufacturers TV/DVR/Broadcasters have built hardware and software to that specification. The ATSC 3.0 spec is what all current hardware/software was designed to meet so they can't just obsolete all hardware sold so far.

3
caseyatbt•

Yes, read it this morning. I bought mine from the Kickstarter project and am very concerned that it won't ever work for 3.0. I hope HDHomerun comes up with a plan.

2
Ginge_Leader•

I can't image that it is as they are saying (or at least implying) is correct; that all ATSC 3.0 devices today will stop working for all channels. What is far more likely is they are saying that some additional channels or services will be added that might be subscription that will be encrypted.

But even if it were true, or some portion of it is true that you might care about, 1.0 will still be broadcast for another 3-4 years so there will be plenty of time to see how things shake out. And of course at the moment there is no benefit in 3.0 (other than edge reception cases) vs 1.0 . So worst of worst case, buying a 3.0 HDHR device in this bleeding-edge early adopter phase means it goes in the large pile of our tech purchases that didn't pan out as intended. (but again, I doubt this is the case so no point in getting worked up about anything yet).

3
Gibsons1264•

No bloody way they screw over manufacturers that put in 3.0 tuners in their TV's. I'm sure pay/subscription 3.0 programming will be encrypted or regular 3.0 having some sort of copy protection, but I can't see normal OTA 3.0 content not being able to be shown on devices with tuners built in. I bought a 2021 Sony TV specifically for ATSC 3.0. If it somehow doesn't work and there's no workaround, I won't be buying another tuner.

2
hdjunkie•

I can’t speak for the future but I get all the major networks in atsc 3.0 now without issues

Also, that links to a 404

1