r/AskHistorians•
mderekt

Was there any Judicial tradition around washing one's hands at the time of Pontius Pilate?

In the lead-up to the Easter celebration, I came across a series of essays by Austrian theologist Arnold Mettnitzer. In one of them, he discusses Pontius Pilate's gesture of hand-washing as follows (translation mine, German original available here):

Washing one's hands of guilt was not a gesture particular to Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor. Instead, it was a well-established Jewish custom, and part of ritualized judicial practice at the time. As a Judge that could not base his ruling on investigative evidence or hard proof, but had to rely on witness statements, Pilate uses this public display to assign responsibility to that there crowd, which had [.. celebrated Jesus' arrival in Jerusalem only recently.]

As I read this paragraph, it appears to me that Mettnitzer is making a historical claim here. It is one I've never heard previously, and which I could not find any corroboration of online -- though the religious subject matter is making Google searches challenging.

Thus, my question. Was there any tradition of (publicly?) washing one's hands of an uncertain ruling, or any other related judicial practice, in Pilate's time or at the time of the Gospels' writing; either Jewish or Roman? Is there some other historical context to Pilate washing his hands of guilt?

Posted Apr 20, 2022, 3:38 PM UTC

51
Loading comments…