r/Android•
_Mark_

Any apps that *sync* from Canon cameras?

Just got a Gnote, my first Android device with USB OTG, so the second thing I try (after hooking up a Real Keyboard) is to push a picture from a camera, to the phone, to flickr. Of course, Canon cameras don't have a usbstorage option, they just have their own Picture Transfer Protocol - which gphoto2/gphotofs support so there's Open Source code out there for it.

Searching for this mostly finds

  • one or two apps that remote-control Canon dSLRs
  • suggestions to use EyeFi instead (wrong for a bunch of reasons)
  • pages about uploading pics from the toy camera on the phone itself.

Sometimes that means the answer is "noone's done that yet", sometimes it means "you're not phrasing the question well" - sometimes it means "some developer implemented that but isn't any good at actually marketing the answer" :-) Thus, I'm asking here...

(ps. I did use a USB SD adapter to get the picture posted, but that's tedious compared to just plugging in...)

Posted May 28, 2012, 3:31 AM UTC

523
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

I have a canon camera, whenever i plug it into my xoom, it asks me if i want to sync to my xoom. As for syncing to a web album, i'm not sure. Maybe using google drive or dropbox to auto sync. It autosyncs to google+... There must be a way.

2
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

Maybe use a third party to get it to the web, then move them to flickr? I dont know. I havent used flickr in awhile. Also, im pretty trashed right now, brain function is sub-par.

1
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

Maybe move them to your note from the canon camera (My xoom does this by default, i'm assuming yours will too) and then using an app like "Flickr Companion for Android" to move them to Flickr? I'm going to see how this works right now, and update you. I will try single photos, and multiple, since you said you take quite a few photos.

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Which model? (neither the S100 nor the Rebel show up when I plug them in; the Gnote claims to be running 2.3.6...)

1
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

I don't use DSLR, photography is only a small hobby of mine, i have a Canon SD4000IS. I will only buy Canon cameras, they are my favorite.

2
thetinguyNexus 4•

are you sure the note sports usb otg support out of the box? I was under the impression you needed a rooted device and modded kernel.

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

As mentioned, both a USB keyboard and a USB SD card reader Just Worked, which I think is a pretty convincing test...

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Looks like the Xoom is a 3.1 or 3.2 device, and 3.1 adds MTP support (client and host) at the API level, I wonder if the Xoom is also shipping an app that uses it.

1
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

Yup, running 3.2. Also, i have it rooted. But even before i rooted it, if i plugged my in my camera, galley would open on its own. It would open a menu where i would choose what photos to import. After importing, i could use any android app to upload the folder to wherever on the interwebs. I'm not sure why the note would be such a bitch about it.

2
phillashcroftVZW GNex - AOKP JB, Motorola Xoom - Rooted 4.1.1•

The reason i rooted it was for mass storage support, so i could use regular old USB flash drives with it. But before i did it, it worked perfectly with my camera.

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

The Xoom shipped with 3.1, and I think the conclusion is that this feature is new in 3.1; the GNote shipped with 2.3.6...

1
theghostracer34Nexus5, Galaxy Nexus & xoom•

I don't have a gnote but I do have a Xoom and a canon dslr. All I do is plug camera in and open the gallery a new folder appears for camera then I just select shots I wanna transfer and voila on tablet for editing and sharing. I also use the dslr controller app which takes over control of camera great for very long exposures it also imports photos it takes and leaves a copy on camera sd

Edit Xoom was on hc when I last did this now ics and haven't tried

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ouroborosityNexus 5, Stock•

I'm curious what your reasons are, we use EyeFi all the time around here and it works beautifully for automatic syncing.

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Two main reasons:

  • I used the first gen EyeFi which had severe overheating problems and lost both pictures and time to dealing with the problems (usual "early adopter effect", I'm sure they're much improved now but they haven't gotten their second chance yet) - and when they did work, they were really slow - fine for picking occasional shots to upload but not really OK for bulk upload - and trying to pick out specific shots to upload from the camera is a user interface nightmare (and none of the "eyefi aware" cameras fix any of that, as far as I know.)
  • wires work :-) I spend a lot of time in places where wifi congestion is a problem, plus I'm not entirely convinced about the security aspects of the uploading protocol (needing to go out of the way to not talk to their servers is part of that.)

I can see them working out well for some uses (and the "infinite storage" mode is something I think they should have pushed much earlier) but on top of the problems above, there are enough cameras they don't work with that it's not really a general answer...

1
ouroborosityNexus 5, Stock•

Interesting. Well they must have fixed the overheating problem because I've never seen it happen with our card. And it's definitely gotten faster through the software updates. We actually use ours most often in a sort of photobooth setup, and it transfers fast enough to check the shot and hit print within a few seconds. Of course I can't speak for RAW speeds as we only transfer Jpeg. I also don't know if there are any congestion problems these days, I've never been in a situation like that.

2
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Yeah, a photobooth setup seems like it would be ideal... you can upload them as you go - but on a nice day I go out and shoot 800+ pictures, away from the net, and then when I come back "online" I don't really want to wait :-)

1
fustercluckMoto Droid RAZR HD, Moto Xoom•

There are a few apps for not only connecting to Canons, but actually controlling them and seeing the viewfinder on your device. Try here.

Most of them are paid paid tho, and depend on the actual Canon model you have

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Yeah, that's the first of those "wrong" answers I mentioned in the post - the ones that actually control the camera don't do anything about transferring files, as far as I can tell. Also, half of the results in that search are for wireless cam viewers (Canon makes some of those too) and most of the rest are ebooks or lens calculators.

If I go through the first page (24 results) and look at the 7 that actually involve plugging the phone into the camera, we have:

  • Remote Your Cam WIFI Lite which looks like it does let you pull pictures off, but only to another computer, not directly to the phone
  • Canon DSLR Browser which requires a camera that already has WIFI built in via a WFT module
  • DSLR Remote Controller not only is it only for control and no image download, it requires you build hardware around an Arduino to use it (which is cool in it's own right, but has nothing to do with the question)
  • Remote Release also only does control, not images, but at least it's direct USB connect to the camera
  • DSLR Remote does handle a wired connection - to the headphone jack and again, trigger only
  • Remote Your Cam USB Pro Beta is also control and live-view only, no image download
  • CamCap - DSLR Controller is the only one on that page that comes close: it says "Transfer images to the device (RAW + JPEG)" along with the remote control features. Unfortunately it's only got a short list of cameras it supports and it requires 3.1, and we may have figured out elsewhere in this thread that 3.1 actually just works without one of these apps...
1
fustercluckMoto Droid RAZR HD, Moto Xoom•

Unlike a lot of Redditors, you have done your homework. Sorry to waste your time, but thanks for the clarification.

I suppose we need a dev in here taking notes.

2
twerps•

PTP, MTP and all of those variations piss me off to no end.

1
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

Thanks to the details from u/phillashcroft, I've narrowed it down to 3.1, and looking at http://developer.android.com/sdk/android-3.1-highlights.html I see

Gallery

The Gallery app now supports Picture Transfer Protocol (PTP), so that users can connect their cameras over USB and import their pictures to Gallery with a single touch. The app also copies the pictures to local storage and provides an indicator to let users see how much space is available.

So that's where the "what do you mean it doesn't work" bit comes from; as for there not being apps,

USB host API

Android 3.1 provides built-in platform support for USB host mode and exposes an API that lets applications manage connected peripherals. On devices that support host mode, applications can use the API to identify and communicate with connected devices such as audio devices. input devices, communications devices, hubs, cameras, and more.

So any apps that can do this, need to use APIs that were first introduced in 3.1 as well. "Yay fragmentation" :-)

1
thetinguyNexus 4•

what the fuck do you mean by sync?

-2
_Mark_OPG1→N1→GNote + 808•

I mean "I just took 300 pictures of great blue herons, I want to get them all pulled from the camera to the phone [but I already have 75 pictures of redwing blackbird nests from yesterday on the phone that I haven't deleted from the camera yet]" so that then I can "scan through them and caption the top give and post them to flickr." The "only transfer the new pictures" is the "sync" part. And there are multiple (all Canon) cameras involved.

The reason I mention gphotofs is that on my laptop, I just use rsync for this and it all works - and there is rsync for android already, but Canon cameras don't show up under /usbstorage...

But as you can see from this explanation, I have a strong bias towards thinking about the problem in Unix terms (what with it actually working and all, and the Gnote is fundamentally a Unix box) but that may be why I'm not finding other solutions...

1