r/classicwow•
bash3r46

People seem to be forgetting about LFD

WOTLK

From the recent threads on LFD, it seems like there is so many key facts that people are completely forgetting about or literally just choosing to ignore to make their points.

A lot of people seem to have completely forgotten that in TBC/Wrath there was still Battlegroups, people who didn't play back then might not even be aware. I haven't played retail constantly so I'm not sure when this feature was removed, but servers were clustered into several groups.

When LFD was introduced in Wrath, it only matched you with other players on your battlegroup, and not all servers within your region as some people seem to be under the impression it did. It also apparently prioritised people on your own server over the rest of the battlegroup.

People seem to have also forgotten that what constitutes a high population server in TBC/Wrath is not the same as what is classes as high population in Classic. A high population server back in the day was around 3-4k, there is classic servers with 20k+ players. Gehennas in EU has 20k horde players, firemaw is evenly balanced but there is 32k Players.

My entire battlegroup probably had less total players than these servers have. Being on one of these servers gives you access to more players to group with normally, than LFD gave me access to back in the day.

Sure you can make the point that as these players are on your own server you can bump into them organically in the world whereas you couldn't if they were on a connected server within your battlegroup. But these megaservers are divided up by layers anyway.

Posted Apr 22, 2022, 10:23 AM UTC

52151
Venythra•

Its only going to be Megaservers soon because almost everyone will transfer without LFD.

Too many positives on Megaservers after this change

45
Spazgrim•

I feel like people are ignoring that this will always be the case. Even in retail LFD did nothing to prevent low / mid servers bleeding towards higher pop realms because at the end of the day raiding is server only. It's just a bigger talent pool.

Not having LFD sucks when getting a group is a struggle but if you're struggling to get groups together, odds are the endgame situation isn't much better which is usually the goal for people playing anyway.

31
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Venythra•

I get what youre saying, i guess people like to play on servers that are full because it gives then the feeling that theyre not alone. Standing in cities and stuff.

But the cross server things helped immensely. There are still alot of good mid populated servers. (Ofc merged but still they stay on them, wow just had too many servers)

And i think for Endgame stuff you should be in a Guild. I'm 100% against lfr for that reason. But Dungeons are mid content and alot of casuals love them. Making them worse to get into wont help.

-1†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Venythra•

Yes, that is going to be me pretty soon too, sadly

1
Spiritual_Shift_920•

Its only going to be Megaservers soon because almost everyone will transfer without LFD.

Too many positives on Megaservers after this change

There really is no change. They are simply not adding a feature to the game that makes playing on low pop realms a bit more tolerable. Playing on a low pop server in TBC wasn't and isn't any better than in wrath, the people who didn't want to deal with it have already transferred a long time ago. That is kind of the reason there are megaservers and so many dead realms in the first place. Even if they added LFD, what are the chances someone is going to transfer out of a megaserver into a dead realm because it is not as bad anymore?

7
Venythra•

There are still alot of people on those servers who looked forward to LFD, me included. Its more like a progress thats still on the move.

Ofc no one would transfer on low servers but at least they wouldnt get fuller and fuller.

I can already see the ques when wotlk releases 😂

-1†
Spiritual_Shift_920•

Might not be as bad as you think. Firemaw was already filled to the brim when TBC came about but it was manageable.

Additionally from what I've gathered the hype for wrath hasn't been anywhere close the levels TBC had. A lot of people had played Wrath back in the day (Many more than they would have liked to during the 12 months of ICC). Naxx was quite hyped up during original WotLK since so many missed its original release, but this is now the 4th release of naxx. For me (and gathering from other posts many others) the one thing I am looking forward to in Wrath will be Ulduar, but mid expansion patches typically dont clog up the servers the same way expansion releases do.

1
Venythra•

Hmm i see, i stopped my progression on my mid server and considering giving a Megaserver a try.

Really? My excperiene is totally different xD

Alot of people were already hyped about wotlk when they announced Vanilla classic, also me included.

In the end we can only wait and see i guess.

But i think Blizzard is excpecting alot more players with wotlk because they are super fast with tbcc patches

6
ScoobyPwnsOnU:horde::warrior: •

Additionally from what I've gathered the hype for wrath hasn't been anywhere close the levels TBC had

What in the world are you talking about, wrath is the most popular expansion they ever made and there's been tons of people that couldn't care less about vanilla or tbc that talk about wrath as a "if they get that far, ill probably try it"

The entire time I've played vanilla and tbc i was constantly running into people who were "waiting for wrath".

0
TehPorkPie•

No one is transferring because of lack of LFD. It's the raiding scene that dictates that, and that is entirely unaffected.

4
Venythra•

Beep. Wrong. Alot of people will. You dont always do the dungeons with your guildies.

And when all the guildless people left to the Megaservers and guilds try to recruit new people and they cant find any, then they will move too.

-6
TehPorkPie•

And when all the guildless people left to the Megaservers and guilds try to recruit new people and they cant find any, then they will move too.

Yeah, almost as if it's the raiding scene that dictates it. Like I said.

What do you think will happen? You X-Realm'd dungeons to 80 and got pre-bis (even that's not much of a thing come WoTLK tbh), and then what, there's not enough of a raiding scene? You transfer. All you've done is kicked a can a few weeks down the road at most.

Edit: Like, on retail you can see the consolidation even with connected realms: https://i.imgur.com/Yqkkru9.png

3
Venythra•

What? No? The Mass does it. The guilds are forced to go along with it.

First, i wouldnt x-realm i wont give them my money for it. U.U Secondly the problem lies in the Dungeons you have trouble to find people for not the raid scene. You get badges in wotlk dungeons where you can buy raid gear with. Casuals, raiders and PvPers will have use of them.

All you've done is kicked a can a few weeks down the road at most.

Sorry dunno what you mean with that, english isn't my motherlanguage xD

Edit: Like, on retail you can see the consolidation even with connected realms: https://i.imgur.com/Yqkkru9.png

Are those US Servers? i understand what you tried to show me

0†
Mazuruu•

TIL LFD fixes literally every problem ever, and everything bad about classic can be contributed to the lack of LFD, and hundreds of players will only play for LFD and unsubscribe without it.

3†
itsRenascent•

Great, retail players can fuck off.

0†
RickusRollus•

To be fair, the server situation is so effed with or without LFD. Still need on-realm players for raiding, arena, and premade BG which is 95% of endgame content once youre done gearing in dungeons. And blizz been shitting the bed on server health since classic vanilla

3
Venythra•

Big true

1
evangelism2:horde::mage: •

Everyone transferred already. Don't act like no LFD is escalating the problem, people have been migrating since Day 1

1†
Venythra•

Well i havent and alot of people either. And for alot of people LFD was a ray of light. So no i am not acting. The megaservers are already extremly full

5
evangelism2:horde::mage: •

LFD is not a ray of light, it is cancer, and it is antithetical to social interaction in an MMO, there are far better solutions to your problem than LFD.

-2†
Venythra•

For you maybe. Not for all. Social interaction is dead since TBCC.

The only social interaction that may be happen, is on small servers.

5
Affectionate_Gene515•

Why would I transfer without LFD? I run dungeons fine on a mid pop server already.

0
Venythra•

Thats good for you. Have fun then. Alot of people will though

3
bash3r46OP•

At the end of the day your options are either, play on a lower pop server which has a tighter community, but risk struggling to find groups, struggling to find or fill a guild roster etc. Or congregate on a 20k+ megaserver with access to all those people to play with.

A lot of people including some content creators prior to launch were excited to play a game with a close server community again. But seems they were in a minority.

People chose what was most important to them.

-1†
Venythra•

Yeah thats the people following the largest crowd. Even people who will start wotlk fresh, they will choose the full servers because thats how people are

I'm on a mid pop server and finding groups not in Primetime is actually hard and takes time.

Thats why i dont understand whats so bad about LFD. At least you can have your peace on your mid/low server and still get groups in an easy way.

People talk about social interaction but on bigass servers almost anyone is a stranger anyways

5
bash3r46OP•

Not really being a sheep, people are just making a conscious choice over what sort of server they want to be a part of.

Social interaction has changed, people just join smaller communities, pug discords, class discords etc. Our actual server discord is pretty dead, it's just a place for people to post their discord links, in classic it was mostly just used to organise world buffs.

3
Venythra•

Yeh i changed that, was a stupid word. I can understand them doing that ofc.

Yeah, people also dont really want to. Look at dungeons "inv" "summ" "bye" thats all they say in 99% of the time. They just wanna do their thing and be done.

The game was just new back then and people wanted friends. Nowadays though, It became a routine. We know everything thats going to happen

3
fitprogrammer•

these megaservers are going to collapse into themselves. How many people are going to come back for wotlk? From the logs Benediction has 30k+ alliance toons that raid and can you imagine how bad this server is going to get when new players that only want to play wotlk start coming in during pre-patch?

-6
bash3r46OP•

The servers are classed as "full" but I was still able to make a level 1 alt on Gehennas, It just came up with a "server very busy queues in peak time" message.

Either blizzard would have to stop new characters being created on these servers if they wanted to cap out the population. Or just add more layers.

8
Venythra•

Yep, i can already see the complains xD

Its going to have such big ques and open world stuff like farming and questing will be near impossible without 1Million shards.

But its Blizzards fault, people NEED other people to play the content without LFD. So logically they go where the most people are

4
WonksRDumb•

They won't collapse. Layers will be added, queues will be added, but the pattern has been the same, the megaservers survive.

2
Swarles_Jr•

People are already transferring off of megaservers simply because they don't want to be stuck in queue for 3 hours after a long day of work. I imagine it will only get worse when wotlk goes live. So I guess, there will be a couple decently populated smaller realms as well.

-5
valdis812•

But where are they transferring to? If they're going from Faerlina to Whitemane or Grob, that's not much help for smaller servers like Sulfuras

6
Swarles_Jr•

I play on a med. Pop pve realm. I see regularly new people that came from firemaw (megaserver eu), because they were fed up with queues.

1
unoriginal1187•

Reckoning battle group was number 1 🤣 nostalgia makes me fondly remember dungeon finder but that’s because I would be farming heroics between 1-4AM when most of my guild was in bed.

23
bash3r46OP•

I can't remember the biggest EU one, I think it was the one with Tarren Mill in it

3
Coreylala_:alliance::rogue: •

Misery was the one with Outland, and it was where all the alliance pvp players went while the horde guys went to Cyclone, that had Stormscale!

2
bash3r46OP•

Maybe Stormscale was the PvP server, I was on Horde back in the day. Tarren Mill was the big raiding server i think with Nihilum/ensidia or whatever it was at the time.

2
Coreylala_:alliance::rogue: •

Yeah 100%. Tarren Mill was huge!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

What you forget is, that even tho you might have enough players on these servers.

Finding them is freaking annoying and time consuming..

LFD helps a lot with that issue.
Automatic Group builder is perfect.

7
Seraphynas:alliance::priest: •

I certainly don’t want to speak for all of the anti-LFD crowd, but personally I would be fine with an automatic group building system. It’s the cross server aspect that I am against.

I also don’t think that it should teleport you to the dungeon. It wasn’t a problem so much in Wrath because people had a year before LFD to learn where the dungeons were, but in later expansions people frequently did not know how to find the instance entrance (if there was a group wipe or if you died in a place where you could not receive a rez, etc.). I’m certainly open to other suggestions for speeding up travel, my thought was to make summoning stones usable by a single player.

1
Aoft032•

Why is it so bad if people don’t know where the dungeon entrance is? I personally don’t think it’s a bad thing because the run just ends up taking longer and it forces people to learn and know for next time. Curious to see an opinion on the other side of that. Lastly, wiping a having to find the instance portal just gives people more time for all that social interaction blizzard keeps talking about.

0
Seraphynas:alliance::priest: •

Lastly, wiping a having to find the instance portal just gives people more time for all that social interaction blizzard keeps talking about.

Hey, so does travel time to the dungeon! I was just trying to compromise, you know, find a reasonable middle ground that most folks could live with, but no, you’re right, we shouldn’t be reasonable and we shouldn’t seek to speed up travel after all.

Was that sardonic enough? That seems to be the only type of communication some people understand.

3
Aoft032•

Damn it, I knew that I shouldn’t have put that last sentence in. I was just trying to be sarcastic, but I can see now that I failed. The first part of my post was completely genuine, though. As for your response, I guess I’m trying to understand why you need to find a middle ground. Summoning already exists in the game and reduces travel time to 0 for 60% of the group, and changing the LFD feature to basically inconvenience people with no legitimate justification just seems weird. Like I said in my first post, I am trying to hear opinions different from mine to understand everyone’s point of view.

1
Psy-Koi•

Even if they remembered they wouldn't approach it from that point of view.

The negative perception of LFD is mostly about peoples feelings and little else.

5†
No_Put_8210•

when the truth is, by putting a party together you're signing up with play with each other. if you make a bad decision its on you, and the lack of consent and essentially forcing people to play with someone or suffer penalties encourages bad behavior.

Also some people enjoy constructing an awesome party. which they wont be able to do because the game will have fundamentally changed what is best for the growth of your character at the expense of everyone's enjoyment.

There were literally 30 min dps queus in wrath on some battlegroups. same as final fantasy, thats WHY people trolled queu as tanks and healers with dps gear and not a real specc.

Theres like absolutely no upside to lfd outside of dead servers who i believe should have the innate option to always move to a flagged "big server" for free.

-2†
LeftyHyzer•

Theres like absolutely no upside to lfd outside of dead servers who i believe should have the innate option to always move to a flagged "big server" for free.

there's a lot of upside, actually. downside too, but lots of upside.

6
osburnn:alliance::shaman: •

Also some people enjoy constructing an awesome party. which they wont be able to do because the game will have fundamentally changed what is best for the growth of your character at the expense of everyone's enjoyment.

There is literally 0 restrictions for posting in trade/guild chat and filling with 4 other people to do LFD.

2
No_Put_8210•

Imagine thinking LFD didnt increase wow toxicity in the player base.

If you werent the "tank" in full fury gear trolling the queu who -you'd incur a punishment for kicking- screaming the n word in party chat, by the time you did a couple hundred of the icc heroics with one and you had gear, you were convinced the entire rest of the population were shitters and enforced toxic achievements and gs requirements to keep the fucking wrath babies away from you.

-7
e-kul•

So what you're saying is blizzard wants you to transfer AGAIN to one of these hugely populated servers to find groups easier. Got it...

5
Jeffrey122•

But, contrary to back in the day, if you are on a server with 3k people today, that's still not enough people to find people doing 1-60 dungeons because people play differently. That's the difference. Back in the day, on a server with 3k people, you would always find low level dungeon groups. Now you don't with 3k people.

5
bash3r46OP•

The game was still growing in tbc as well lets be honest, the sub numbers went up consistently throughout the expansion and through most of wrath right. So there was a constant influx of new players. Do we really have that now?

1
Pekeno954•

I just want LFD so I can lvl my rouge. Make LFD 10-70 and let us grind to 80. I really want a rouge so I can pvp but I can’t see my self putting in the hours and stress of grinding a rouge to 80 and I’ll definitely not pay for a boost. I guess my SPriest will be the only toon I play.

3
Traveledfarwestward•

Following a leveling guide is hard and stressful.

/s

1
Gigalypuff•

Just tie LFD to be server only.. but that won't happen, blizzs party finding tools have always been cross server, they'd have to put in dev time to change it

2
marks716•

Is there anyone out there who thinks merging servers is a bad idea? It seems so many issues in classic would be remediated with higher server capacity and getting rid of the ultra tiny servers

2
bash3r46OP•

No, but blizzard has never been able to address server population issues of any kind almost as long as the game has been out.

4
marks716•

Small indie company

1
Cephell•

Also LFD wasn't out for most of the content and the only reason it was even out for any meaningful time at all was because Cata was delayed for almost a year.

1†
bash3r46OP•

I wonder how much of the 5 man content was designed with the idea of dungeon finder in mind. If they went into wrath knowing it was something they wanted to implement.

The HCs in wrath were a lot easier than the TBC ones.

If you look at the use of dungeon finder in Retail and a similar system in FFXIV. It's only used for the easiest content. Once you get beyond normal and HC dungeons which are pretty faceroll and hard to fail, and start doing proper raids and M+ it's a completely different party finder system

10
Hypermetz•

The wrath hcs got a huge nerf right after LFD. Should answer that question.

3†
bash3r46OP•

And then it was a massive issue when people complained that HCs were too easy, and harder HCs were introduced in Cataclysm it became an issue.

6
valdis812•

I think this is why they're trying to skip LFD this time. Cata will have pre-nerf heroics, so they don't want to have to deal with people complaining about it then. I guess they figure it's better to just not have it vs. having it then trying to remove it later.

2
zzrryll•

people complained that HCs were too easy

That didn’t happen for the most part. The decision to make harder heroics was a dev decision. See: Ghostcrawlers long blog on the subject.

1
MarineDinkPrime•

Yeah i despise LFD after what happened to cata hcs back in the day. Wrath babies literally ruined cata hcs.

0†
desperateorphan•

The terms wrath baby, dumbing down the game and welfare epics came about heavily in wrath. People absolutely complained about heroics being too easy, compared to TBC, throughout wrath. They were a total joke. Threat was a total joke.

Heroics in Cata weren't hard at all. You literally just had to cc a mob here or there, los pull or pull mobs back to get out of a patrol or god forbid click the rope to dodge the explosion in Deadmines. Unfortunately, 2 years of being able to afkaoelolfiesta your way through heroics really set an expectation that "heroic" didn't mean Heroic anymore.

0
zzrryll•

I know they changed a few mechanics in like Oculus to make it less shitty. But I don’t recall widespread nerfs.

The dungeons were already trivialized by badge gear by then. Which had much more of an impact on difficulty than any specific nerfs.

1
Key_Photograph9067:horde::warlock: •

On October 4th the release date for cata was announced, and released on the date they announced which was 7th December, where did you find that it was delayed for almost a year? Given 3.3 came out pretty much an exact year before cata released, unless you think the final patch should be immediately released with the next expac around the corner, how is that a delay? A year is not really far off of all the gaps between last patch and expansion launches if you look at the timeline.

2
Cephell•

Blizzard doesn't announce dates until they know they can meet them. The announcement of the date was already delayed. And yes, the evidence is that a full year on last patch is not normal when looking at how they normally do it.

0
Key_Photograph9067:horde::warlock: •

It’s not though, you haven’t even looked, I know you haven’t. It’s exactly the average of the past.

Cata 4.3 - mists = 10 months

Mists 5.4 - WoD = 14 months

WoD 6.2 - Legion = 14 months

Legion 7.3 - BFA = 12 months

Bfa 8.3 - Shadowlands = 10 months

Why are you asserting something you clearly haven’t read?

https://wowwiki-archive.fandom.com/wiki/Timeline_(World_of_Warcraft)

0
Cephell•

You may wanna check the time it takes from when the betas got release for the upcoming expansion vs that expansion release date. The results might surprise you.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Darkgale69:horde::paladin: •

bloodlust battlegroup was full gigachad

1
Splatacular•

It's crazy I was really looking forward to Argent dailys while burning time in lfg, as someone who plays primarily dps roles this just makes everything a giant pain in the ass for no reason. It's so puzzling because they don't run a good private server so they should still be concerned most other ones are at least free and you could start onto wrath there today. All they had to do was nothing, and instead they butchered TBC. They are in a toxic feedback loop with their preview discord getting just the worst of worst takes consistently. Now with signals at restricting duel spec and LFD gimp it just is plainly in bad faith. They added an abomination of it to TBC to be able to say "see it sucks!". There was literal backlash when they implemented the awful version over the one we all expected them to use that worked well. Everyone in that fight just accepted that at least in wrath it would end up fixed properly and went about the LFG spam. Fun detected, scatter lol.

1
LongBeing•

Also dungeon finder was a quick easy way to farm badges.

1
Kreatonfeldoe•

Yup. I've been saying since day one of Classic Vanilla's launch the realm cap was too damn high. We're already playing with randos.

1
areusureaboutthis•

Wtf is a battlegroup?

0†
bash3r46OP•

Groups of servers connected servers. Added at the end of Vanilla initially, so when you queued up for a BG instead of being put into a BG of players only on your server. You were matched with players from the other servers in your battlegroup.

14
Eccmecc•

Realm pools

6
missinginput•

A server rack

2
jbrux86•

LFD makes the most sense for all the small realms to be banded together as that is where it’s hard to get groups together.

On mega servers you don’t need the LFD as there are plenary of people and DKs + dual spec removes the tank shortages.

0
Nogamara•

It also apparently prioritised people on your own server over the rest of the battlegroup.

As someone playing on one of the smaller (nowadays: dead) servers I never knew this!

-1
Mazuruu•

With so many people on one server I'm sure you will have no trouble finding groups without LFD then ;)

-2
osburnn:alliance::shaman: •

Max level content wont be a huge issue, but leveling content will still be a pita to get a group for. I'm on benediction and the other day it took me 2 hours to get a group for ZF.

1
daywalker91:horde::priest: •

So many words to say LFD grouped you with your servers battle group

-4
bash3r46OP•

People don't seem to be able to grasp what that means though, and that server populations now are different. And that the population of an entire battlegroup was less than the megaservers people are currently playing on.

People playing on gehennas with 20k horde have no idea or have completely forgotten what playing on a 3k population server in tbc was actually like.

8
zauru193:alliance::hunter: •

because you're confusing what 20k and 3k means. They're referring to two different things.

-3
bash3r46OP•

The maximum concurrent players is still higher on classic servers than it was on TBC/Wrath servers.

6
jbrux86•

Keep Dungeon Finder = No Bonuses -receive a debuff until out of dungeon that prevents bonus crate, bag of gold.

Organic Group = Bonus Crate, gold reward.

-4
YesNoMaybe2552:horde::paladin: •

But why? only cus you don't like the dungeon finder ?

4
jbrux86•

I love the dungeon finder, but Blizzard said they want to preserve the community aspect.

Give both options. A bonus for being part of the community and none for removing yourself from it.

Blizz has already shown they will incentivize players to take action, like with BGs for the Alliance getting a crate.

-2†
YesNoMaybe2552:horde::paladin: •

As long as they don't take away badges from LFD, I wouldn't mind but they should rater do

LFD = Only scarcity spec gets bonus

Organic Group = everyone gets bonus and gives it all to the Tank for their service, just as the grand social fiber of the community intended.

0
jbrux86•

ROFL….scarcity spec should always get a bonus, but not sure we will have as much of an issue with DKs now.

2