About Radagon's Seals

Discussion & Info

I see a lot of people that seem to think that the seals are always good or that they are always good unless you have 40 Vigor, but I think a lot of people focus too much on hits to kill from max HP and miss some very important considerations.

For simplicity's sake I will focus on Radagon's Soreseal. The "better" one. It increases Vigor, Strength, Dex and Endurance by 5 each, but in return reduces your physical damage negation by 15%.

Since the assumption is already that going above the soft cap of 40 gives diminishing returns I will deliberately avoid it and operate with a build that uses 35 Vigor. At 35 Vigor the build has 1,216 max HP and with the Soreseal it reaches 1450 max HP. An increase of 234 HP or 19.24%

Thanks to test results from Fextralife we know that the increase of damage taken in percent is proportional to the absolute damage taken. For strong hits (for example from most bosses) the realistic damage increase is 12.5% on average.

That means our max HP increases more than our damage taken. Great right? On the surface? Yes, but let me show you why the answer isn't that simple.

Scenario: A boss hits us with 850 damage. That is increased to 956 with the Soreseal.

After the first hit we are left with 366 and 494 HP respectively. Neither build survives a second hit. We heal with a flask +12 for 810 HP. Now we are at 1,176 and 1,304 HP. A second hit takes us to 326 and 348. We heal again and the boss hits us a third time. This is where it gets interesting. Now our HP are 286 and 212. The Soreseal variant is losing ground. This deficit becomes bigger and bigger the more often we get hit and have to heal.

Why is that?

Most people only focus on hits to kill from max hp, but forget that we won't always have max HP. We can't afford to always overheal to stay at maximum. So instead of comparing the gain of max HP with the gain of damage taken I would suggest comparing the gain of effective max HP to damage taken.

What is effective max HP?

Effective max HP is your character's max HP + the total amount of healing potential you have. For simplicity's sake we'll only assume the use of Crimson Flasks. That means the effective max HP is max HP + 12*810 or 10,936 and 11,170 respectively. We have a gain of 2.13% effective max HP compared to the 12.5% of increased damage taken.

Let's go back to our example and talk about how many hits it would take the boss to kill us through all the healing. At 850 or 956 damage it would take the boss 13 and 12 hits respectively to kill. That means overall the Soreseal actually does lose us some survivability. With it we'll run out of healing quicker than without.

What does this mean? Should I use the Soreseal or not?

That heavily depends on the situation. If you find yourself often running out of flasks you may want to reconsider your use of the seal. Additionally if you have Vigor above 40 you probably don't wanna use it either if you're trying to maximize your survivability.

However, if you are using quick weapons and an aggressive playstyle, that can afford to overheal, the Soreseal is perfect for you. Additionally for builds that keep very low max HP it is always worth using the seal, because you will always overheal with a +12 flask and your hits to kill never go down.

Final words

This is by no means meant to be an exhaustive analysis of this topic. I don't claim to be an expert and the topic overall is to complex to break down in a short post. However, I hope it gets people thinking about the item and helps optimize some builds.

Posted Apr 24, 2022, 4:11 PM UTC

310
Ono_Palaver:str:•

It would still be absolutely busted even if didn't increase vigor at all tbf.

4
PrescientPotato•

Not by a longshot, it's quite mediocre for a DPS talisman. 5 STR and 5 DEX isn't even 30 AR in most cases

4
Bare_Foot_Bear:hollowed2:•

It’s not great for pvp unless you’re running a lvl 90 or 60 build imo. Fine for pve

1
KrandoxReddit•

Yeah okay but it still gives me additional levels for all my damage related stats, making it quite worth it for me. That's 10 levels towards my damage, 5 towards my endurance to dodge/hit more/easier.

Worth it for me

3
PrescientPotato•

That "10 levels towards my damage" is even in best cases less than 30 AR. Decent damage oriented talismans can give you at least twice that and without compromising defences

3
golforceOP•

That depends very heavily though. 5 endurance are worth an average of 7.5 points of stamina and 5 points each of strength and dex are worth 20-40 AR depending on your weapon choice. For low level characters this is significant, but it quickly falls off for high levels.

1
PrescientPotato•

Seals are only good in Twink builds, at low level or when you're desperately trying to reach requirements for spells. Using them above level 60-70 is just bad.

They screw you defensively and the offensive bonuses are pretty meh compared to alternatives

2
CrappyBark•

Honestly I use it for the 5 str/dex/end more than the HP, being able to undercut str and dex for the min req on items makes more builds viable, the end helps with sta and equip load and the better damage and armor is already nice, the HP is just gravy on top

2
TheBlaringBlue:fai:•

The seals are fine at low and mid levels but it punishes you at high levels, especially against any boss after Morgott.

I was initially a believer, but I’ve since removed Radagon’s (the only one I ever used) from my build permanently.

2
MrTopler•

One thing to note is increasing stats via the seals gives you flat damage reduction.

Now obviously you'll still end up squishier using the seal then you would without but typically you use the seal to either hit weapon requirements or tune your build to funnel those 20 points effectively.

1