r/Guitar•
FishFloyd

Best amp to buy with ~$300?

Hey. I'm selling my Crate GLX1200H half-stack for about $350, but $50 is going to my dad 'cuz I owe him money. Anywho, I'll have about ~$300 to spend on a new amp - I'm thinking either a Fender Mustang III or some kind of tube amp. I definately want it to be loud enough to overcome a very heavy-handed drummer, whilest still retaining a good tone. I generally play with distortion, but good, warm, clean sounds would be nice to be able to produce, too. Versatility is a big bonus... I'm really open to anything, as long as it can overcome a LOUD drummer (and the rest of the 5-piece, with me on lead). Thanks!

EDIT: It's really starting to look like a toss-up between a tube and a Mustang III. Which do you guys recommend?

Posted May 30, 2012, 2:05 AM UTC · edited

318
reid-oGibson/Fender•

Used Peavey Classic 30. That thing is a workhorse at a reasonable price and sounds great. Also well modified if you want to make changes.

8
FishFloydOPLikes Fish•

That amp looks pretty pricey, but somewhat doable. However, I don't really have any FX pedals... so that's a bit of a minus, and why I was really considering the Mustang III.

By the way, distortion-wise, I like a pretty heavy distortion - anywhere from a light crunch to a balls-out METAL distortion. (Such as the tone from For Whom the Bell Tolls, and also Still of the Night.)

Upvote for visibility, anyone?

2
tibbon'59 Jazzmaster•

Get a good clean amp (like the Classic 30) and get pedals.

1
sspaceboy1•

I've got a used Classic 50 that I paid like 150 for, but only because I obsessively scoured craigslist for a month looking for a cheap tube amp. It's a fantastic amp, but it's got a bluesy, growly overdrive, not great for metal, maybe stoner metal though. But mine's from the late 70s, maybe newer ones sound different.
I remember liking the Valvetronix and Vypyr amps when I tried them out. Good tube emulation and lots of good effects. I liked them better than Line 6 and much bettern than the Fender modeling amps. I remember the Fender amps having level issues; switching preset channels the volume was way different. I only tried it out in store, maybe you could learn to fix that, but I didn't have that prob with any other modeling amp. I also have an old Marshall Valvestate that gets great distortion for metal, you can get them used for really cheap (which is why I haven't sold mine, just can't get any money for it).

1
JimmyInnernetsG&L / Fender•

Great amp. I had the classic 50 4x10. Loved it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tibbon'59 Jazzmaster•

I concur.

1
Ecator•

This for sure, I have wound up with a few of these over the years trading. There is also a pretty easy mod you can do to it changing out a couple resistors to help with the lower end. After the mod it has a really good marshal style distorted tone without much sacrifice to the clean tone. Well worth the money and the ones I had were super reliable. It also matches up well with other cabinets.

1
analgapingjesus•

don't get a modeling amp.

3
[deleted]•

I got my used Fender Blues Jr. for $300 (It normally goes for like 400ish I think). I spent three days calling shop to shop looking for one. In the end I found one that belonged to the employee at a store I called at. He was looking to trade it in for some guitar he wanted at the time, and told me he was ok with selling it for 300. Drove like an hour and a half down to pick it up to find out it was essentially brand new. Sales tag still on it, and warranty untouched. Tested it out for a bit and took it home with me. I've been using it ever since, and I love the thing! -Basically what I'm trying to say is that you might be surprised what deals you can get if you put effort into looking around for a bit.

2
Butlaa123•

Mustang III for versatility, Fender Fuse is a really good amp modelling software.

2
zeroesandonesEpiphone, Fender•

I've had a Mustang III for about a year, and I'm still consistently surprised by the versatility, tones, and the volume.

2
Butlaa123•

The direct recording is also a major advantage.

2
YourRealName•

If you want something you can keep for a while, get a tube amp. Otherwise you'll find yourself wanting to upgrade again every couple years. Trust me, I did that for about 10 years. If you are serious about getting good tone, forget about solid state amps. Pretend they don't exist.

A 30 watt tube amp with a 12" speaker will be able to keep up in practice situations, and you can always mic it at gigs. 15 watts may be enough too (depending on the amp) but the cleans will break up at higher volumes.

2
GiraffeKiller•

You're best bet is to go to a store and sample different amps. Doing that, you'll fond your sound.

1
notdertrollD'Angelico•

Jet City JCA2112RC

1