Canada is not building enough Single Family Homes

I know that this is going to be heresy to many of the "just increase density" crowd, but lately I have been alarmed by the level of villainization against any Canadian who aspires to live in a Single Family Home. There seems to be an orchestrated push among multiple levels of our government and amongst our media, political, and corporate elite to discourage the construction of middle-class SFHs, ostensibly to meet GHG emissions reduction goals.

On social media, people like me who want to live in modest SFHs are called entitled, wasteful, disgusting, and privileged. All for wanting a standard of living that was readily obtainable by our parents' generation, our grandparents' generation, our great grandparents' generation and beyond. In fact, Canada has been a mostly home-owning nation since its founding through to the present day. And yet somehow anyone who desires the opportunity to live at the same standard of living as past generations is now worthy of public scorn.

This push to eliminate the middle-class SFH is most apparent when we look at their relative share of housing stock and housing completions. Since 2000, the share of new construction consisting of SFHs has halved, from 62% to 31%. If this trend continues, Canada will increasingly become a nation of high-rise dwelling renters, as the proportion of SFH stock continues to fall. Only the rich will be able to enjoy the previous middle-class standard.

​

https://preview.redd.it/2t7e5w5zvrv81.jpg?width=576&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=0ae1794057774e205eb48e33847708d6cf7da745

This push is occurring even though Canadians still by-and-large prefer SFHs. When the pandemic gave many Canadians the freedom to relocate to their preferred housing type, rather than flock to high-density towers in city centres, Canadians overwhelmingly chose to move out of cities and into SFHs in the suburbs and beyond.

This failure to build SFHs is the major supply-side component of housing crisis.

Canada is now at an existential crisis. We have to decide whether we are going to maintain the standard of living that Canadians have enjoyed for over a century as a nation of home owners, or whether we are going to allow our political 'betters' to push the middle-class into tiny rental boxes. So far, the policies and propaganda to push Canadians into those rental boxes have been wildly successful.

Posted Apr 26, 2022, 1:32 AM UTC · edited

1430
kamomil•

I live in a house and I never want to live in a condo or apartment ever again. Getting a bunch of groceries in the front door is so much easier with a house. You don't share a wall with neighbors. There is no elevator to break down. I can open all my windows and smell the fresh air. You can't necessarily do that in a condo unless you have a balcony. I love having the option to have a garden that is not just in flowerpots.

I think those people who push hard for density, they... I don't know. They are edgy teens? They are developers?

We don't need to build that many single family homes. We need seniors to downsize. My neighbor has got to be around 75. She lives alone, in a 3 bedroom house. These are the older Baby Boomers. So there's a larger proportion of them than Gen X, Millenials etc

17
bleb_ploleman•

Sfh zoning creates shit cities

1†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
SaxManSteve•

Single family homes are bad on almost every metric imaginable. They rob children of independent mobility. They bankrupt city finances by costing more in maintenance then they generate in property taxes. They force people to be car-dependent which increases traffic, pollution, and noise. They produce significantly more co2 than their urban counterparts. All for what? so you can own a front lawn that you never use? so that you can support the lawn mowing industry?

What canada needs is to build more middle density. Look at places like the Netherlands. Theres barely any skyscrapers there, but theres plenty of rowhouses, midrises, ect... and people love it. They love the walkability, the sense of community ect...

Proposing to build more single family housing to fix the housing crisis really shows you have no idea whats causing the crisis in the first place. It is precisely the predominance of exclusionary R1 zoning that is limiting housing construction across canada. If it wasnt for all the single family loving NIMBYs who constantly block proposals to build more mid and high density the housing crisis wouldnt be as bad as it is.

I personally have no issues with single family homes. What i have issue with is subsidizing its costs. We desperately need property tax reforms in canada so that property taxes better reflect the true cost that each housing unit incurs on the city. For the last 100 years urban residents have been subsidizing the cost of suburbia, and its time for this to change.

0
pvtv3ga•

I know right, fuck people who want to start families in anything other than a box with people on other sides of the walls.

4
SaxManSteve•

ever hear about sound proof insulation walls? they are very common, used across the world.

1
pvtv3ga•

Yes, this is an adequate equivalent for a yard that my kids can run around in.

​

EDIT: just realized you're a moderator on r/CanadaHousing. That explains your stupid viewpoints.

4

the current state of things is saying "fuck people who want to live in communities where schools, groceries and services are within a walking or biking distance from home, and where children can make lots of friends"

0
defishitOP•

Single family homes are bad on almost every metric imaginable. Blah blah blah....

Then later...

I personally have no issues with single family homes.

What?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1