AITA for changing the price on a customer after finding out more information about what I was selling?

Not the A-hole

This happened in the mid-to-late 90s, but I told the story to friends the other day and got very mixed reactions, so I want to take it to the asshole aficionados here for a verdict.

I was helping out at a church rummage sale. We had a whole bunch of random donated stuff of unknown provenance, and didn't price anything in advance; we'd just decide what we thought an item was worth when someone came and asked.

A man saw a fax machine on the table, and asked me if it worked. I answered honestly that I didn't know. He asked me how much it costs, and I said, "Well, since we don't know if it works or not, I can give it to you for $15."

He asked if we could test it out. I said sure, but unfortunately it didn't have any paper in it (it was the old kind that needed paper on a roll), and we were outside with no convenient power outlet. So I spent at least half an hour tracking down some paper, bringing it inside to the parish office, hooking it up to a phone line, and making a test. Sure enough, it worked!

The guy tried to give me $15 for it. I told him that $15 was the price when we had no idea if it worked or not. Now that we know it's a working fax machine, I'm going to sell it for $40. (note: I might be a bit fuzzy on the exact prices I'm quoting. At the time it would probably cost around $200-$300 new, so the higher price was still a good deal as I saw it.)

My man absolutely freaked out. He got up in my face, called me a dishonest cheat, and stormed out. I was damn near crying by the end.

Now, I know that guy sucked for his extreme reaction--I was about 13 years old at the time, and this was a grown-ass man. But AITA for raising the price on him after we found out it worked?

Posted May 3, 2022, 9:09 AM UTC

1348
Left-Car6520Supreme Court Just-ass [109]•

I can't believe that in the year of our lord 2022, I'm reading an AITA post about a fax machine

Edit because I guess I better give a judgement.

NTA

I think it's a tiny bit weird to sell an appliance that you don't even know if it works because what is the $15 version for if it doesn't? Parts? Decoration?

But the caveat was given when you gave the price as to why it was $15. He had follow up questions, you found out the answers, and the reason for the cheap price no longer applied. He did it to himself, and it's certainly not cheating.

46
tkfuOPPartassipant [3]•

Lol, fair. I'm gonna claim that by the diversity of the responses it was at least an interesting question, though.

9
Left-Car6520Supreme Court Just-ass [109]•

It's true. I suppose I have to give a judgment now.

Let me think about it...

[fax connection noises]

8
[deleted]•

Amen

3
EternalChrysalism420Partassipant [4]•

YTA

He wasn't right for yelling at you the way he did especially because of how young you were, but the way you switched prices on him like that is shady. If you hadn't told him $15 to start off I'd say he's the AH. But he asked how much, you told him, then you changed your mind.

As for the paper, you could've just let him take his chances, or let him hunt down some paper on his own to test it.

21
tkfuOPPartassipant [3]•

You don't think it makes a difference that I told him specifically that it was $15 because we didn't know if it worked or not? My thinking is that when I said $15, it was a $15 lottery ticket that might or might not be a working fax machine. After we tested it, it was a working fax machine, and that's worth more than a lottery ticket.

-4†
EternalChrysalism420Partassipant [4]•

I mean maybe? You didn't know if it worked so you were selling it for $15 and it worked so you wanted $40. But if you sold it for $15 and it didn't you would have sold trash for $15. You were playing the same gamble and kinda cheated.

9
Curious-Mousse-8714Asshole Aficionado [10]•

I don’t see it that way since OP did the work to resolve the question before the sale. If the guy had bought the fax machine, taken it home and tested it, then come back and said it worked, OP would have been the AH for changing the price.

3
tkfuOPPartassipant [3]•

I guess that's where the disconnect is: I was selling a gamble, just like you said. Might be trash, might be a working fax machine. Different opinion about cheating, though: I think it would be cheating for the customer to scratch off the lottery ticket first, then decide whether to buy it, which is what this guy wanted to do.

-2†
EternalChrysalism420Partassipant [4]•

Would you have given it to him for free if it didn't work?

4
SelectNetwork1•

I get your logic here, but I think there was probably a disconnect on his end between "you can have it for $15" and "we don't know if it works or not." I know you said "since we don't know if it works or not, I can give it to you for $15," but people don't always process our words precisely, especially if they hear something different from what they expect. If he wasn't expecting to hear a conditional price for a lottery-ticket item, he probably didn't realize that was what you were giving him.

I think it probably would have been better to say, before going to test the machine, "I can test it, but if it works, I'm going to have to charge you $40. Or you can take it now for $15 and test it yourself." If he didn't understand he was buying a lottery ticket, I can see why the price change felt like a bait-and-switch. But as I said, I see your logic! (And if I'm wrong, and he did get that he was asking you to scratch the lottery ticket off before he committed to buying it, then he's TA.)

3
HazelFrederick•

No it doesn’t make a difference. You posted a price. Is your responsibility to honor that price. If you were unsure you could have posted a higher price and then lowered it if nobody bought it. Of course, you were 13 and shouldn’t have had this responsibility, and the customer’s reaction is not justified, so ESH.

4
tkfuOPPartassipant [3]•

Just to clarify: no prices were posted. At a rummage sale, everything is typically an ad-hoc negotiation, and he didn't agree to buy it for $15 under the condition I told him ("you can have it for $15 because we don't know if it works").

1
blah618•

ESH/YTA

You could have said 15 as is, but 40 if we test it and it works

Not sure about how severe his reaction actually was so possible ESH

12
tkfuOPPartassipant [3]•

I think I agree with this one the most out of the YTAs. I thought it was implied/obvious that he's only getting the $15 price because he's taking a gamble, but it would have been better to be explicit about that, and he clearly didn't share that understanding. If I had it to do over, I think I'd probably communicate better today, as an adult.

1
[deleted]•

NTA. He's the one that asked to test it out. That's his fault. He should have just bought it for 15 dollars and tried it later on.

10
Gummy_yumyumAsshole Aficionado [18]•

ESH, especially the idiot who put a 13 year old in charge of pricing.

9
Old_Ship_1701Partassipant [3]•

NTA.

  1. You were 13. Not, I think, a business owner or someone with a lot of experience in pricing. Pricing is tough for those of us who are adults and have owned or currently own businesses!

  2. You were given vague instructions for something that was charitable in scope.

  3. You gave him a price for it based on it potentially being a really big paperweight. He wasn't willing to pay the price at that time, so that nullified your original offer.

  4. Once you shifted to actually resolving his question of whether it worked, you spent a half hour on this that you could have spent getting other things sold for charitable purposes.

  5. You then offered a slightly higher price and he went ballistic -- on a 13 year old boy trying to help out his church.

If you had been an adult, I would have possibly answered differently BUT an adult would have mostly likely told the guy to take it or leave it at the price you initially offered. He took advantage of your youth to get a good deal, and $40 was an exceptionally good deal back then for a fax machine!

7
jecksidaAsshole Enthusiast [6]•

YTA, you didn’t tell him you were going to change the price after testing it out. He was right to want to make sure it was working. You were a child playing a stupid game.

7
AgoraiosBumPartassipant [1]•

ESH. If you told him "$15 as a mystery fax; $40 if we test it and it works" that would be fine. But you told him $15, he asked to test it, and then you changed the price. He felt misled; rightly so. He also totally overacted, so is a bit of an AH himself.

6
aphrahannah•

It seems like that is basically what they said. They said the price was 15 because they didn't know if it worked or not.

2
AgoraiosBumPartassipant [1]•

But there wasn't another price noted. And he wasn't warned "you want to test it...if it tests as working, the price goes up."

It's basically a garage sale and the buyer says "how much" and is told "15, no promises that it works, though."

2
aphrahannah•

Why would they offer a second price in that moment? It was hard work to test it. They were offering a price for a non tested item. The buyer refused that by asking to test the item.

If the buyer had taken the price, and risk, then your garage sale comment would be accurate. The buyer didn't do that. They asked OP to spend half an hour trying to find a way to test that it works. Why would the "because we don't know if it works" price still be relevant at that point?

2
AgoraiosBumPartassipant [1]•

Seller could have avoided all the confusion with more clarity.

3
very_busy_newtPartassipant [3]•

The buyer (an adult) could've clarified if the price would change if the machine worked after being tested by the seller (a young teen).

The buyer was told the price with a 'because we don't know if it works'. They have human logic abilities, it's not on the seller that the buyer had an incorrect assumption based on selective listening.

1
bethanymonday72Certified Proctologist [22]•

No, that's fair enough. You were clear that the og price was based on it maybe not working. If he didn't take that in, that's on him. NTA

5
8LeggedHugsAsshole Enthusiast [6]•

NTA, he should have paid extra for asking you to spend an hour and a half testing it anyway if he was gonna demand that. Now, you probably should have said upfront the price would be higher if you confirmed it worked. If not he could take a gamble on the lower price.

5
RanniSimpAsshole Enthusiast [7]•

YTA

This is so scummy. You were a dishonest cheat.

5†
XoRMiAS•

NTA - The price was for a “mystery box”. Once you open it, the price changes.

5
catfoodonmyshelfCertified Proctologist [23]•

NTA. I mean it’s annoying but it’s a church sale and you weren’t dishonest or a cheat, you were very clear about the $40. Dude’s got issues lol

4
kaokoh373Partassipant [2]•

YTA- you don’t agreed to the price and reneged on the deal. That is shady business practices. BUT unless the money changes hand, the business is not done, so you are fine legally. You were still the AH though. If you pull something like this in the real world, people will not trust anything you say because it is like you can change your mind at any time if it benefits you. It is not good for business in the wrong run.

Let me ask you a question. Did you ever sell that fax machine for $40?

4
BuddyPsychological72Partassipant [3]•

NTA- One time I had a lady grab a shirt from our sale bin which was put in there due to the fact there was what looked liked stitching coming loose(another workers action). She came up to the counter and I asked if she wanted me to cut the loose stitching and when I grabbed it to cut it, it turned out to be some fuzz. I told her since the shirt wasn’t damaged it would be full price. Prices can change all the time based on quality. He asked if it worked, it worked, therefore it wasn’t broken which isn’t $15 worth.

3
ReadyGrapefruit5449Asshole Enthusiast [9]•

YTA. You upped the price for the fax machine.

3
A2ZKIRBY71Partassipant [2]•

OP YTA......Just because you went through an effort to determine that it worked, you should have just sold it for the original price and left it at that. OR....you should have found an adult to help this guy and let the adult determine if the price should be different after realizing the machine works.

3
oscilliusCertified Proctologist [23]•

NAH - when you mention his extreme reaction he’s an asshole but you aren’t asking for a judgment on that. You set a price and then decided to up the price when you found out it actually worked.

Nothing wrong with changing the price, there wasn’t an agreement in place. Nobody put pen to paper and said “these are the agreed terms”. No sale had happened, he didn’t go out of his way - actually you did for agreeing to test it for him. I wouldn’t say what you did makes you a cool person but I don’t think it makes you an asshole either.

2
KittiesLove1•

NTA because the cheap price was because it was kind of a "bet". You either get a broken machine and loose 15 dollars, or a working machine and earn 25 dollar (40-15). He chose not to take the bet and instead check it. Fine. But then you get the full price. You can't stay in the bet but only to pay after you've checked the results

2
AutoModeratorMOD•

^^^^AUTOMOD Thanks for posting! This comment is a copy of your post so readers can see the original text if your post is edited or removed. This comment is NOT accusing you of copying anything. Read this before contacting the mod team

This happened in the mid-to-late 90s, but I told the story to friends the other day and got very mixed reactions, so I want to take it to the asshole aficionados here for a verdict.

I was helping out at a church rummage sale. We had a whole bunch of random donated stuff of unknown provenance, and didn't price anything in advance; we'd just decide what we thought an item was worth when someone came and asked.

A man saw a fax machine on the table, and asked me if it worked. I answered honestly that I didn't know. He asked me how much it costs, and I said, "Well, since we don't know if it works or not, I can give it to you for $15."

He asked if we could test it out. I said sure, but unfortunately it didn't have any paper in it (it was the old kind that needed paper on a roll), and we were outside with no convenient power outlet. So I spent at least half an hour tracking down some paper, bringing it inside to the parish office, hooking it up to a phone line, and making a test. Sure enough, it worked!

The guy tried to give me $15 for it. I told him that $15 was the price when we had no idea if it worked or not. Now that we know it's a working fax machine, I'm going to sell it for $40. (note: I might be a bit fuzzy on the exact prices I'm quoting. At the time it would probably cost around $200-$300 new, so the higher price was still a good deal as I saw it.)

My man absolutely freaked out. He got up in my face, called me a dishonest cheat, and stormed out. I was damn near crying by the end.

Now, I know that guy sucked for his extreme reaction--I was about 13 years old at the time, and this was a grown-ass man. But AITA for raising the price on him after we found out it worked?

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1