AITA for changing the price on a customer after finding out more information about what I was selling?
This happened in the mid-to-late 90s, but I told the story to friends the other day and got very mixed reactions, so I want to take it to the asshole aficionados here for a verdict.
I was helping out at a church rummage sale. We had a whole bunch of random donated stuff of unknown provenance, and didn't price anything in advance; we'd just decide what we thought an item was worth when someone came and asked.
A man saw a fax machine on the table, and asked me if it worked. I answered honestly that I didn't know. He asked me how much it costs, and I said, "Well, since we don't know if it works or not, I can give it to you for $15."
He asked if we could test it out. I said sure, but unfortunately it didn't have any paper in it (it was the old kind that needed paper on a roll), and we were outside with no convenient power outlet. So I spent at least half an hour tracking down some paper, bringing it inside to the parish office, hooking it up to a phone line, and making a test. Sure enough, it worked!
The guy tried to give me $15 for it. I told him that $15 was the price when we had no idea if it worked or not. Now that we know it's a working fax machine, I'm going to sell it for $40. (note: I might be a bit fuzzy on the exact prices I'm quoting. At the time it would probably cost around $200-$300 new, so the higher price was still a good deal as I saw it.)
My man absolutely freaked out. He got up in my face, called me a dishonest cheat, and stormed out. I was damn near crying by the end.
Now, I know that guy sucked for his extreme reaction--I was about 13 years old at the time, and this was a grown-ass man. But AITA for raising the price on him after we found out it worked?
Posted May 3, 2022, 9:09 AM UTC
I can't believe that in the year of our lord 2022, I'm reading an AITA post about a fax machine
Edit because I guess I better give a judgement.
NTA
I think it's a tiny bit weird to sell an appliance that you don't even know if it works because what is the $15 version for if it doesn't? Parts? Decoration?
But the caveat was given when you gave the price as to why it was $15. He had follow up questions, you found out the answers, and the reason for the cheap price no longer applied. He did it to himself, and it's certainly not cheating.
Lol, fair. I'm gonna claim that by the diversity of the responses it was at least an interesting question, though.
It's true. I suppose I have to give a judgment now.
Let me think about it...
[fax connection noises]
Amen