Question about 2188

Spoiler

So the 15 sentinel pilots are all clones of the last 15 survivors of humanity, and they mention as much in the conversation between Professor Morimura and Professor Takamiya. But later Professor Morimura mentions to Sekigahara that there are only ten survivors, and this is corroborated when they mention that 7 people died in the shootout that left Ida and Shinonome as the sole survivors of humanity, since it was after Morimura already died. Obviously, at some point they lost 5 of the survivors, but I'm fairly certain they never mention anywhere in the game who or how. Have the devs mentioned anything about it in interviews? It doesn't really matter to the plot, it's just that with how much info we got on how humanity ended in 2188 it feels like a big gap in what we know.

Posted May 3, 2022, 7:17 PM UTC

212
Takfloyd•

What we know is that as far as Morimura knew, there were 10 survivors left when Sekigahara blew up the reactor and doomed the rest of them. There is some uncertainty here though - we don't know if Morimura knew about Yakushiji being taken in, for instance, and we don't know if she includes Sekigahara in those 10. The survivors weren't working as a close-knit group - they were living in different sectors of the massive space station.

Either way, we can make some educated guesses about who weren't on the station by then - Kisaragi for instance talks about returning to the surface in her one 2188 log, so there's a good chance she actually wasn't on the colony when the virus struck, and died on Earth. Kurabe also seems to have only been working on the project up to a certain point - when the AI work was done, she might have left.

7 people died in the shootout that resulted from Okino wanting to halt Project Ark in favour of extending life support for the survivors. We know they included Izumi and Ogata as well as Okino and Hijiyama, leaving 3 unknowns, who were probably on Ogata and Izumi's side considering Hijiyama's mention of "goons". Probably 3 out of Sekigahara, Miura, Minami and Takamiya, as they would all be in favour of sacrificing themselves in hopes of saving humanity.

Seemingly after the shootout, Gouto is still alive and talks to Kengo Ogata's AI - this is after the probes have already launched and life support is almost out. Gouto wants to sabotage the project out of spite against it being controlled by an AI, not knowing that Izumi had already done so in secret. The implication seems to be that he gives Shinonome the idea to sabotage the project remotely via transmitter. But she only does so in despair after Ida ditches her to commit suicide alone - this is not mentioned in the game, but in a developer interview. After Ida dies, Shinonome is the last survivor.

4
Automatic-BootOP•

alright, I like the analysis but I'm gonna dispute some things, one is that in the conversation between professors Morimura and Takamiya, they mention using the DNA of the 15 survivors, which to me pretty solidly implies that all the 2188 versions were gathered together and knew of each other when the world became uninhabitable, and that they had to use every single DNA sample available to them to improve the odds of the project succeeding, so I'm pretty sure everyone knew of each other and were on the colony at the same time. Second, since all the survivors were together, I think Gouto and Sekigahara must have been included in the shootout too, so that leaves just one unknown in the shootout.

2
Takfloyd•

All the 15 deposited their DNA as part of the plan, but we don't know when or where the first ones of them started dying - if they were all safely inside the station, it's very odd that going by Morimura, several of them died BEFORE things started going badly. I feel it's more likely they left the station for Earth after finishing their contributions - even knowing the virus was down there.

The survivors were definitely not all working together as a group - for one, Gouto and Morimura were enemies, and Sekigahara was just there to kill Morimura at the first opportunity. A lot of the logs imply travel time between the sectors and various labs and habitations, reducing the knowledge the survivors had of what the others were doing. As for the shootout, there's no reason to think everyone was present, as Hijiyama indicates the meeting wasn't supposed to be a huge deal until Ogata brought guns. We just know that out of the ones who were there, only Ida and Shinonome survived, and 7 people died. But Gouto doesn't seem to have been one of them, since he's still alive after Project Ark has been successfully launched.

2
RandomFFXIplayer•

What we know is that as far as Morimura knew, there were 10 survivors left when Sekigahara blew up the reactor and doomed the rest of them. There is some uncertainty here though - we don't know if Morimura knew about Yakushiji being taken in, for instance, and we don't know if she includes Sekigahara in those 10. The survivors weren't working as a close-knit group - they were living in different sectors of the massive space station.

She has to, since everyone DNA got taken and accounted to be placed in the sims

1
Takfloyd•

Good point, the number of clones being 15 is mentioned in Morimura's conversation with Takamiya, right?

1
Nicobizzle•

Yeah, what exactly everyone was doing in 2188 is still a big mystery, we can make some educated guesses from the mystery files about who LIKELY died when, but ultimately for about 9 of the 15 we have no clue.

If there’s one good thing, it’s that it leaves a big open area for a sequel or spin-off to take advantage of!

3
Gasarocky•

There is no way they'd be making a sequel lol

2
Automatic-BootOP•

c'mon man, at least let us have a directors cut XD

3
Nicobizzle•

They might do a comic spin-off or something!

1
Automatic-BootOP•

didn't they do an official comic anthology? here?

1
Gasarocky•

That's kind of what the switch version is since it had some rebalancing

1
Automatic-BootOP•

I mean sure, but I really really could go for some of that cut content *coughplayableokinoandtamaocough*

1