Sadie is the most overrated character ever

I really do not get why so much people love Sadie, she is the worst, most stupid, selfish character the game has, she gives no fucks about the safety of whoever is with her, first of all, I am not going to say that it is out of reason that she becomes a gunslinger because there WERE gunslinger women in the wild west, and whoever makes that a point in their rant is just a sexist ass(although it does feel a bit like a woke favor exactly due to my point in the part that I highlighted but I am going to touch in all the things that have NOTHING to do with SJW things).

Now, to why I hate her(I disliked her until I saw how most people fall in love with the character, then I started hating her); her arch makes no sense, you can see it with the rest of the girls, they are wild, always have been, always will be, and Mary Beth is the only one that stands out, because she is not like that

Then there is people like Charlotte, she is not a suicidal careless selfish asshole like Sadie, but she can hold her own, she even tells Artie that she can defend herself if he tries to do something funny, you see that trait from her from the get go, yet with this beatch she is moaning and moping for literal months, and then suddenly the spark goes on, and not in a smart storytelling way but in the dumbest way

Dutch asks for them to not make a mess near camp, yet the first thing she does is a shootout 2 right in front of camp, then she is full of herself telling Arthur that she will only ride with him if he proves himself, he is a freaking killer and robber, and she acts all high and mighty when she shot 2 people and Arthur shot the rest

Then risking Arthur's life and the rest of the camp for all that matters, when the Odriscolls attack shady belle, "What, and miss this?" she forces Arthur to go out and protect her because of her selfishness and stupidity

Then her idiocy when trying to rescue John, she don't give a fuck that they should not call attention to themselves because they are about to bust John out, and she goes on a rampage that causes the ballon guy to die, risks the plan to rescue John, and she doesn't give a shit

Then her stupidity in saint denis as well, they are wanted criminals, and even after watching Colm die, she doesn't hesitate in throwing Arthur and Dutch under the train, if it means she kills 5 more odriscolls, if they had been caught, they would all have hanged then and there

And then her arch goes from the stupid moron, to the savior of everything and becames a lead character and a caring loving woman? Please, bullshit

And she is not a badass, EVERY single time she goes on a rampage, she is saved by someone, Micah would have killed her if he wasn't keen on toying with her

The Lemon raiders would have killed her if Arthur had decided not to stick around and go back to camp(Which is not in his nature, but I hope you get my point)

The Odriscolls would've overwhelmed her in Shady Belle if Arthur had not been there to back her up

The Pinkertons the same in Lakay

She wouldv'e died in the chase if she didn't have Arthur taking out odriscolls from the balloon

She would've hanged in Saint Denis(Or would have been shot) if Arthur was not so loyal and had said "Fuck this, Dutch is gone and I am not dying and letting the rest of the team die or be captured because of these two assholes"

Hell, she gets knocked out in the trading post because of her carelessness(And I so enjoyed every bronze medal I got for the missions where I just sat there and watched her getting ded because of how stupid and incompetent she is, every single mission where she was a part, i would just watch her die the first time through lol)

​

So yeah, she makes no sense and in her suicidal revenge lust she doesn't care if she takes down those that tried to look after her

​

Edit: And I still think she is the worst character because

A) Dutch, he is clearly a manipulative egomaniac that uses people, I saw though that facade since the get go

B) Micah never hides how evil he is, he is a coward and a turncoat, but he is so since the get go

C) Bill is dumb as rocks, in RDR1 my guess is he was pushed to hard because of the heart break of the gang going haywire, especially Dutch, who was his savior and that is why he becomes evil

D) all the other evil characters are clear and express their character from the get go