Shield of the Hidden Lord - Hiding the true nature
I know I've seen this question a couple of times, but I've never seen many answers or suggestions, so I thought I'd ask in case there are any fresh suggestions.
My players recently came across the Shield of the Hidden Lord. As per the recommendation in the Alexandrian, I have had Gargauth refuse to name himself (stating his name was lost to time, and that he is instead only known as "The Hidden Lord", and also claiming the shield he's trapped in is the Shield of Silvarth). He also has claimed that he is a powerful angel trapped in an infernal device.
Naturally, my players are suspicious, and one players wants to cast "Identify" on the shield (although one player has already attuned to it). When the player attuned to it, I gave him only the basics - what it did. I removed all the rest of the lore contained in the item's description.
Does anyone have any suggestions on how to hide the true nature of the shield if we follow RAW? Of course, if I allow Identify then they should be made aware that the shield is of a Celestial nature instead of Infernal, but I don't really want them to know the rest of the story behind it.
I realise I could have the shield under the permanent effect of "Nondetection", but I feel that's a bit of a letdown with just a "you can't detect it" (though I imagine it is a viable way, even if I bend the rules slightly for a permanent version of the spell).
I'm also curious, and struggling to find the answer to this - does Identify reveal the nature of a creature inside of the object - e.g. would Identify in this case Identify Gargauth, or would it only be the prison that contains him?
So please, tell me - how did you run the true nature of the Shield?
Posted May 4, 2022, 8:45 AM UTC · edited
Gargauth Nystuls himself?
"The shield is of celestial design, woven with enchantments of Warding, Protection and many others. It exudes an aura of power. It smells faintly of elderblossom and the colour purple."
Honestly, enchantments may be the way to go. I was just hoping for something more than just "the spell doesn't work".
Perhaps I'll have Sylvira "try" to cast a spell on it down the line and inform them of why the spells appear to fail - strong magic above even her expertise, due to the infernal nature of the enchantments.