Shield of the Hidden Lord - Hiding the true nature

HELP / REQUEST

I know I've seen this question a couple of times, but I've never seen many answers or suggestions, so I thought I'd ask in case there are any fresh suggestions.

My players recently came across the Shield of the Hidden Lord. As per the recommendation in the Alexandrian, I have had Gargauth refuse to name himself (stating his name was lost to time, and that he is instead only known as "The Hidden Lord", and also claiming the shield he's trapped in is the Shield of Silvarth). He also has claimed that he is a powerful angel trapped in an infernal device.

Naturally, my players are suspicious, and one players wants to cast "Identify" on the shield (although one player has already attuned to it). When the player attuned to it, I gave him only the basics - what it did. I removed all the rest of the lore contained in the item's description.

Does anyone have any suggestions on how to hide the true nature of the shield if we follow RAW? Of course, if I allow Identify then they should be made aware that the shield is of a Celestial nature instead of Infernal, but I don't really want them to know the rest of the story behind it.

I realise I could have the shield under the permanent effect of "Nondetection", but I feel that's a bit of a letdown with just a "you can't detect it" (though I imagine it is a viable way, even if I bend the rules slightly for a permanent version of the spell).

I'm also curious, and struggling to find the answer to this - does Identify reveal the nature of a creature inside of the object - e.g. would Identify in this case Identify Gargauth, or would it only be the prison that contains him?

So please, tell me - how did you run the true nature of the Shield?

Posted May 4, 2022, 8:45 AM UTC · edited

1017
Shadows_Assassin•

Gargauth Nystuls himself?

"The shield is of celestial design, woven with enchantments of Warding, Protection and many others. It exudes an aura of power. It smells faintly of elderblossom and the colour purple."

5
ShadowReaperTOP•

Honestly, enchantments may be the way to go. I was just hoping for something more than just "the spell doesn't work".

Perhaps I'll have Sylvira "try" to cast a spell on it down the line and inform them of why the spells appear to fail - strong magic above even her expertise, due to the infernal nature of the enchantments.

2
Mojake•

If they don't follow it through any further then they shouldn't find out. I thought the dichotomy of my players using a super powerful shield and allowing it to guide them through Hell fully knowing that it is evil made for some fun dilemma - so had Sylvira cast Legend Lore on it for them and relayed information about Gargauth.

3
ShadowReaperTOP•

I know they definitely will cast Identify on it, which is why I wanted ideas before I got to that point and had to make things up on the spot to avoid them knowing everything about it. I do fear they may refuse to take it if they learned that it housed a Pit Fiend though, which is why I'd like to keep that hidden from them until they're in Avernus. Although the +4 AC and Fire Resistance might tip them to use it anyway.

1
Mojake•

When my Cleric (who uses the shield) learned it had a Pit Fiend, she casually said she'll go throw it in the River Styx. Gargauth immediately telepathy'd her and told her how dangerous Avernus was, and that without him acting as their guide they are likely to perish.

I think if the party go through the motions to learn more beyond just an Identify spell (which should only tell the party what it does, not it's lore), such as research in Candlekeep then you should give them that bone as they've earned it.

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

It might sound odd, but I'd be fine with them learning more if they took the time to try and research it in Candlekeep instead of just casting identify. That said, with the information given to them so far, they won't find much. Though they could find out that the "Shield of Silvarth" was actually a Celestial shield instead of Infernal, which could lead to them questioning him.

1
Mojake•

If you look at the Identify spell, you'll see exactly what they find out. None of that should tip them off to the true nature of the shield.

1
NguTron•

My party cast identify on the shield. They found out the list of powers the shield has, and that it was of celestial origin. They found out nothing about the creature trapped within because identify doesn't do that.

Sylvira did tell them the legend of the Hidden Lord though and that Gargauth was trapped in it. She asked the party what they would do with the shield, strongly hinting that it was too dangerous to be left anywhere, and saying she would be incredibly hesitant to hold it with her.

With the party about to head off to Avernus, and not really having much time to find a safe location, they took it with them, though the Paladin who has the shield in her possession completely distrusts Gargauth, since he lied to her about being a celestial at first.

1
Angelus_Demens•

The adventure is written that they find out about the nature of it quite quicky, -Sylvira will tell them all about it at Candlelkeep. why do you want to keep your players in the dark about it?

2
ShadowReaperTOP•

A couple of reasons, really. I want to keep the mystery of who is inside the shield to last longer, but I also don't want them to just toss it out. Obviously there's incentives to not throw it out - the AC bonus and fire resistance being pretty big boons in Avernus, but they may not be comfortable with working with a Pit Fiend.

That and they've already been told what I mentioned in my original post - if Sylvira suddenly mentioned it was the complete opposite, why would they keep the shield when he's obviously lied so far?

1
Angelus_Demens•

Never underestimate a players hubris, or desire to keep the shiny powerful thing.

3
Devlonir•

I made both my parties find out relatively quickly. One was told in Candlekeep, the other Gargauth himself was up front about it.

I think wanting to keep it secret is a trap because honestly, using it is such a clear and direct 'corruption' moment for any character. The shield is clearly OP, and clearly evil. Are they still willing to use it despite these risks?

Both wielders made the choice deliberately and are kind of revelling in it's power, even when Gargauth does some nasty shit at times they still excuse it. And it is lovely.

Oh yes, speaking of nasty shit.. I do let Gargauth sometimes use his abilities when he wants to, or let him whisper to the wielder that 'hey, that enemy is not fire resistant' to make them use the fireball even if it is not the best time to do so (like killing innocent bystanders they do not know of in the ghasts in the house encounter in Elturel).

TLDR: Do not hide it, them knowingly using an evil shield because it is both so strong mechanically and so useful as a guide is a great tool for you to use.

2
Solaries3•

RAW they don't get much more than the mechanics, so really there's no issue. They definitely don't learn the "nature" of the shield. You're free to give as little or as much other flavor as you want and still play this RAW.

Identify:

You choose one object that you must touch throughout the casting of the spell. If it is a magic item or some other magic-imbued object, you learn its properties and how to use them, whether it requires attunement to use, and how many charges it has, if any. You learn whether any spells are affecting the item and what they are. If the item was created by a spell, you learn which spell created it.

2
RyanFromGDSE•

In my campaign he's been lying and calling himself The Fallen Angel/Solar named Lucius and since we're playing online I created a custom magic item called "Shield of Lucius" so they could add it to their inventory without it having all of the unrevealed aspects. I didn't want to even use Shield of the Hidden Lord because we play online and the item on DNDBeyond has all of the hidden stuff in its description. He's also incredibly charismatic and ruthless so lying about his name is pretty standard for a devil of his status.

The Paladin did Divine Sense and it showed both Celestial and Fiendiest energy coming from the shield but that just played into its a Celestial trapped in a Fiendish Artifact.

Nobody in the party has Identify but if someone did I would probably play it up like so:

"You sense the divine power, its unlike anything you've felt before. When you've cast this previously you would learn precise nature of the item but this - this feels different. Warded perhaps against such attempts. And in that moment make a Wisdom saving throw" on a failed save they'd get confusing visions, maybe even the sense others are scrying for the lost artifact.

2
KoolAidMage•

Identify can't tell you everything, and it doesn't give you any real context or insight into why something is the way it is. That's why the Legend Lore spell exists.

1
KoolAidMage•

If you look at the Iron Flask (a magic item that traps creatures), it says that casting Identify will confirm whether or not a creature is trapped in the flask, but it cannot tell you anything about the creature. The only way to find out what's inside is to open it. You could apply tge same logic to the Shield of the Hidden Lord.

1
ShadowReaperTOP•

Thank you, this could definitely be an idea.

1