If they continued the trend, and season 36 was Fans vs Favorites 3, using the Ghost Island cast, who makes up the fans? Who are the favorites?
I find this excercise interesting since we have a cast to work with to makeup a fans tribe.
For the Fans, I think they’d take the feedback from S26 and cast better newbies. They did for S38, and it made that season a lot better because of it. So because of that, I think players like Domenick, Wendell, Stephanie Johnson, and Laurel all get cast. Laurel played hard whether you liked her game or not, she played. Anyways.
A fans tribe, consiting of the following, would’ve been incredible imo:
- Domenick
- Wendell
- Donathan
- James
- Jacob Derwin
- Laurel
- Stephanie J
- Angela
- Kellyn
- Morgan
For the favorites.... you do have less to choose from in general. Chrissy wouldn’t play back to back I imagine, nor would Devon, so any HHH pick is tough. Cydney has said she wouldn’t return, which also doesn’t help. Tai, Aubrey, and Debbie all returned already. So...
- Jay
- David
- Reynold
- Joe Mena
- Sean Rector
- Natalie Bolton
- T-Bird
- J’Tia
- Jessica (s35)
- Carolyn
I think if Game Changers weren’t a thing, Tai, Aubry, Debbie, probably Brad, and Zeke/Michaela change this cast a lot.
Ghost Island wasn’t my favorite season, and I would enjoy this a lot to be fair, but it’s clear why this was never a thing. Since the theme of the season was basically “old survivor moments” it does make me wonder if the idea crossed their mind.
Who would your casts be?
Posted May 4, 2022, 1:54 PM UTC · edited
Well I think David, Kelly and Joe probably all would of been cast. It's hard to judge who else though because they have never really casted actual fans or favourites for those 2 seasons lol There are some exceptions of course but yeah I can't say I miss the concept though an actual Fans Vs Favourites would be cool.
I like your fans cast, I don't know who I would of had as Favourites. David I would certainly of had. Jay would of been cool also. If we are casting like Survivor would and include non favs I would certainly pick Michelle from s33 to return as I think she would be a great returnee. I would actually like to see Scott return without Jason, I think the partnership of him and Tai was really cool. I'd cast Tai if it wasn't so close to s34. I'd bring back Terry actually from s31 to give him his proper 2nd chance. I am trying to think of who I would go with from s30, Mama C would be a possibility. From 29 I'd love to see how Nadiya would do. On that note, had they done fans Vs favs I think Natalie would of been a potential cast member as she was planned for game changers.
Anyways that's some of the potential favs, I could go through all the seasons but il stop there, I'd love to see Sean Rector and Natalie Bolton return also. Speaking of Natalie's and especially if they were bringing back winners for the season, I'd love to see Natalie White play again.
Only issue with Joe and Kelley are that they tend to only cast 2nd time players on a FvF season, that was consistent thru the first 2 so idk why that would change.
Ah right ok fair enough, I actually didn't know that lol My first season was 30 and while I have pretty much watched every season 26 was one I didn't watch a lot of as the cast and all the Brandon drama was just not for me. I never even realised it was only returnees playing for the second time.