After the event reward changes, there's absolutely nothing to do besides daily quests as a F2P drafter.

So, it seems that basically no event on the game can give you gold anymore?

It is proven that quick draft/premier draft is the best value for F2P players like me, so I find myself logging in, doing dailys and quit, even if I have the time to play more games, I know that the value of constructed events is trash right now and not worth the gold. So..tf should I do besides dailys? anyone else in the same position?

Edit: I still love magic and have lots of fun with it. I'm just frustrated that the time spend on Arena feels less rewarding now, because the >possibility< of getting more gold, to draft more, and expand my collection (to have more fun trying new things out) is now gone.

Posted May 4, 2022, 3:01 PM UTC · edited

131109
SlickBurn•

No hate, I just want to say that… I think a primary reason to play a game is to have fun, right? You’re not alone your thinking, a lot of other commenters agree with you. I’m just finding I’m uncomfortable with the idea that so many people seem to be playing this game like it’s a job or something. Like it’s not worth doing if you don’t earn something for doing it. If it’s not fun enough to just play a game of Magic against another person, maybe it is ok to stop playing.

And I know WotC plays into this. I’ve heard other games use this same mentality too. I don’t know if it’s gambling psychology or whatever, but man, I don’t know how to feel that so many people got caught up in this.

I started playing this game 30 yrs ago. It was just about having fun. Sure sometimes you’d go to a comic book store and you’d play for some kind of stakes, which was cool. But 90% of the time you just played because you wanted to play a game of Magic. Which I guess is the equivalent of the Play button.

But, with that said. If it’s more that you’re bored playing a normal constructed game (you see the same decks, same gameplay, etc), there’s some other formats and variations to play. I’ve joined a couple Discord groups who do drafts and cubes on external sites. Then we import our decks in and play it out on Arena. Those have been a blast.

Jank Diver Gaming (cube): https://www.reddit.com/r/mtgcube/comments/jafhrz/jank_diver_gaming_unrestricted_cube_for_arena/

Arena Gauntlet League (sealed variation): https://www.reddit.com/r/lrcast/comments/u7m886/arena_gauntlet_league_is_back_with_its_new/

76
Midguy•

I think his dilemma is that he has fun drafting and he only plays the other events to get gold to draft. If they reduce the amount of gold he can earn in other events, it makes it harder for him to acquire enough gold to do the thing he enjoys. Packs and cards as a reward don’t mean anything to someone who just wants to draft as much as possible.

45
SlickBurn•

Ahh, gotcha. Wants to draft more but can't earn the gold to do so. I guess I jumped on my soapbox too quickly. I'll leave the comment, maybe a couple people will find the links interesting at least.

22
Sglied13•

I was with you with my initial read, if they had some sort of free draft mode w/o prizes op would probably play that I’d assume after doing his normal stuff on the game.

5
Chilly_chariots•

Only OP can solve this mystery really. On the one hand they call themselves a ‘ftp drafter’, on the other hand they say ‘ It is proven that quick draft/premier draft is the best value for F2P players like me’.

Which doesn’t make them sound like a drafter, because if drafting is what you want to do, why would you be bothered about whether it provides ‘the best value’?

2†
pensivewombat•

I don't really understand. The new events pay out gems. You can draft with gems. What's the problem?

0
Dir_Quabity_AssuanceTimmy•

I like this comment a lot. I am in the same boat wanting to do drafts as an FTP but honestly the most fun I have is hitting the play queue with a weird deck and blasting someone with 3 [[Stensia Uprising]] triggers to win a game I shouldn't have.

I get satisfaction from targeting a rank to hit in standard for a few pack reward, drafting what I can, then do the play queue.

MTGA has pockets of non-grinding fun, just think back to why you started playing Magic in the first place.

7
MTGCardFetcher•

Stensia Uprising - (G) (SF) (txt)
^^^[[cardname]] ^^^or ^^^[[cardname|SET]] ^^^to ^^^call

1
M4xP0w3r_•

For me the biggest reason that it feels like a chore is that what I enjoy most is brewing, playing around and trying new things. Which is by far the most expensive thing on Arena, as even any Trash rare or mythic that Nobody wants costs the same as the top of the meta cards do. The other thing I enjoy, depending on the Set, is limited, which also is not cheap to do. So my options are basically to spend a lot of money to actually play what I want to play for digital cards that I dont even own, which is what I did in the beginning. Or to grind with a competitive enough deck to get a few wins and try to get the ressources to do the things I enjoy.

Ironically Arena has cost me already way more money for a combined year of playing mostly Standard than my decade of Modern & Commander on MODO has.

6
dpman48•

I would gladly pay a monthly subscription for a phantom collection of everything. I just wanna try silly decks against each other.

4
TrueBlue726Dimir•

It's hard to play casually and for fun when you need to do your dailies, and that means you need to win. It's also tough to play only jank decks when the meta is filled with cut-throat decks that all want to win (and are good at it). I try to get into Arena for about 30 minutes each day. During that time I'd play my competitive decks (only Play queue. I gave up on playing ranked last season) to get the 4 wins then switch to jankier decks for a few more games before logging off. Playing unranked allows me to concede whenever the opening hand or the game don't go my way, so I can move on to a new game without worrying about losing rank.

4
Cytrynek•

I think it is about the way has been built for F2P players. I've been playing M:tG for almost 25 years att this point, spend some money on building collection, but still - thanks to Arena I have the best time ever. So even if it sometimes feels like "job", it is still quite a fun one. For most of the time I had to spend money to play M:tG, now finally it is possible to play for free, and I think iIm really enjoying it. Obviously there is a side effect - I don't think I'm interested in playing M:tG in person like ever (ok, maybe some Cube with friends, from time to time) - it just seems so ineffective.

3

Arena has set its self up to keep you playing, even if you are tired of the game, because you will fall behind if you don't. That's probably why they are trying to ruin historic, because it doesn't rotate every year. If you don't stay playing most cards will be obsolete, and the money\time you spent will just be wasted.

1
KnightTimeHSOPLyra Dawnbringer•

Thanks for the comment. Those custom formats looks like fun.

0
SlickBurn•
1
EmTeeEm•

If you are a F2P drafter you should make alts.

You don't have to play more than normal, but it makes any amount you play more efficient by making sure you always have full Quests and Dailies. Instead of a pittance of Gold from a Constructed event you pop 3 Quests for 1500-2250 gold. If you want to play more you hop to a fresh account, if you don't you just let them sit.

It makes it pretty easy to go infinite-enough with a low win rate, so soon you won't need to play anything but Limited if you don't want.

46
thedeafbadger•

This is the way.

I have been playing on 4 accounts since VOW and have never had to grind to enter a draft since then. I also get to play more drafts than I would be able to on a single account.

25
Parker4815•

You play 4 different accounts on Arena? Wouldn't you just rather just play another game every now and then?

7
DanutMS•

The thing is that you don't have to play them all every day. In fact, you shouldn't. The point of having multiple accounts is making sure that whenever you play you have 3 daily quests up.

You just play the exact same amount as you would with one account. But when you do, you get slightly more gold for your time, making it so that you have to grind less (or not at all) to play limited.

21
Zeiramsy•

As someone who also has 4 accounts I can say:

No but also I don't really play more than I did with one account. I averaged around 10 games a day including drafts and now I split this across multiple accounts which means each win is worth more and I get to shift more games towards limited instead of constructed. My win rate is also higher because I am on lower ranks due to lower activity per account so I get to smash some lower ranks every now and then so I need even less games to reach the max payout level of daily quest plus four wins.

15
Cytrynek•

Really, 4/15 on each account and you get anywhere from 4200 to 5000 gold per day, and you can do it quickly with 'speed magic" approach. Much more efffective, and WotC is very happy that they can show how many active accounts they have, it is a win for everyone.

1
jorgewerty•

Do you play with the free decks on your alt. accounts? Or you try to make competitive decks in all of them ?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
ferretgr•

Add me to the list of people who are playing for free using alts. I had enough gems/gold socked away between three accounts to draft 14 times when New Capenna dropped. Still drafting for "free" based on by winnings (I'm not a great drafter, just good enough to maintain, hovering at a little over 50% win rate right now in the new format).

All I do is get to 4 wins each day with my three accounts. If you're a daily player this isn't onerous. In fact, for me, it was the same amount of play I was dedicating to a single account, only now, I'm being rewarded for my time instead of just playing for fun. The dailies tend to take care of themselves, as long as you play the right deck/colors.

9
fimbleinastar•

12 wins a day is so much, jeese.

9
Zeiramsy•

It really isn't if you spread it over multiple accounts because each of those has less games, less rank and lower MMR so on my main account I have a win rate ~57% so I need almost 8 matches for 4 wins. But on my alts that goes up to 80% almost so after 5 games I already have my 4 wins. Now I don't max all four accounts to 4 wins every day but I'm much closer to it than not and can draft whenever I want due to that.

4
Cytrynek•

Also you can make it faster with hyper aggro decks and conceding early any game that either doesn't look promising or has a good chance to become a long one, very often this enables a player to get 4/15 in less than 20 or even 15 minutes. Also, doing this in ranked constructed tanks your MMR, so future games become easier and even quicker - yes, getting to constructed mythic top 250 will be painful if you go for it at any point in the future, but seriously, only very small number of players cares about it.

1
Burt-Macklin•

Gotta take forever to collect cards, though, right? Because in order to have halfway decent decks on your ‘alt’ accounts to win dailies, you have to collect some rare cards..

With three alts, you don’t just need four of a card to make a set, you need 12…

1
ferretgr•

I like playing aggro in constructed, so my games tend to end in either a win or a loss pretty quickly. And to be fair, 12 wins in a day doesn’t feel like as much if you’re just playing here and there… a couple of games in the morning, a couple on a break, a couple before bed… I will admit that I do have the advantage of having a lot of free time, though.

1
NINETY_LIVES•

Sounds dumb but can you just log out and create a new account and do it that way?

7
EmTeeEm•

Yep! You can even use the same email address with random periods added, if you use gmail or another service that ignores them.

And be sure to skip the tutorial. You still need to play the color challenges but it saves a lot of setup time.

3
bulksalty•

With gmail you can also add +[text] to your email handle and gmail will drop the plus sign and everything after.

3
just_call_me_ash•

If you just want to draft, the color challenges can also be skipped via the Options menu.

2
kenxo51•

How do you do the dailies on an alt tho?Won't you lose a bunch to better decks at first?Sounds horrible if true.Or do they give a lot of frontloaded wildcards and gold to make first 1 deck?

1
EmTeeEm•

You get a ton of packs from old codes plus you'll pick up the two-color starter decks eventually, so you can cobble something together. Plus always playing with full Quests reduces the need for wins. Just play a bit of jank, get your 1500 from Quests, and go to a fresh account.

Midweek Magic is also good. I'd always play on alts when it was pauper or pre-constructed decks. And you can do the Phantom Bot Draft on each one!

Eventually though, you just go infinite on drafts and don't need to play Constructed at all. It is a lot easier when your Rank doesn't skyrocket to Platinum faster than your skill does, and when you are getting 1/2 a Quick Draft (or 1/4 a Premier) back in Quests/Dailies every time.

2
Cytrynek•

From the initial collection and codes you can actually build some decent aggro decks - if not for Standard, then for Historic (I recommend Sliver Aggro, it has only 3 mythics, some rares, a lot of commons and uncommons and only 4 rare lands are necessary (Sliver Hive) - this deck is not anything from top meta, but when it hits (especially on play), then it hits really hard. My personal best is 4/15 wins in 10 minutes). Actually, getting alt account started becomes easier, and easier every set - these 3 packs from codes really add up.

3
ferretgr•

In addition to the stuff mentioned by other folks, the Jump In format is a place where getting stomped by meta decks can be avoided.

1
nottooloud•

You get paired against play who have your ranking. Being a new account, your ranking is nil. You win some games, gets some packs, get some wildcards, and you're good to go. I have the account I paid to learn on, and I have an alt that I haven't spent a dime on beyond the ridiculously good starter deal. A few months in, I play the same competitive decks at the same level on both accounts.

1
redeyedreams•

I made a second account a while ago to stock up resources for drafting when my main account is tapped out. Might be worth for you. And for dailies I just play Historic Brawl.

28
Basnap•

...only a second? ;)

7
Cytrynek•

If you have full time job that is not remote it can be difficult to have more than two, so this makes a lot of sense. Also stocking up a lot of resources on multiple accounts along with converting gold to gems is a lot of fun. At some point maybe I even will find out what to do with these resources.

7
Cabra_da_Peste•

Same here, I just play less. Kinda. Now all I play is PD and ranked explorer, there's no incentive to play anything else and the events are made for spikes but with low enough rewards that it's just not attractive.

21
bubbles_maybe•

Did y'all really manage to grind gold from the old events? I know the EV was solid, but they were suuuuper long compared to the low stakes, so any gains were minimal. If all you care about is f2p drafting, then surely doing the daylies again on a second account has always been more efficient?

19
forward_only•

Yeah, it was pretty easy to get gold out of the old event reward structure. Four wins got you a free reentry and everything above that was profit. But more than that, playing in a low-stakes event with a little bit of gold on the line is just way more fun than randomly queuing on the ladder.

13
bulksalty•

That's what I miss most too. It was just the right amount at stake for me.

4
jordandev•

full agree

1
C39Zexal•

It was more like increasing daily gold. A modest profit of 100-200 gold per day could translate into an additional 10k-20k gold when the new set drops.

To put it in another light, it's like rerolling the 500 gold quest to get a chance at the 750 gold ones. A small change, but it drastically affects how much gold you can get if you play daily.

7
KnightTimeHSOPLyra Dawnbringer•

At least the possiblity was there.

One thing that I miss out SO MUCH, is for exemple:

I log in, do my dailys, and I'm left with 4000 gold and something like 200 dead gems that can't be spent on anything.

I could use those dead gems at constructed event to get more gold, to reach the 5000 entry point and join a draft, trying to get even more gems.

It just feels like less and less options of things to do now.

5
Mrfish31•

At least the possiblity was there.

Not really though?

Like even if you went 7-0 every run, it would take you 10 runs - 70 games of magic - to earn the 5000 gold needed for an extra quickdraft. If you were just barely going positive at 5-3 every run to make 600 gold from the 500 pay in, it would take you fifty runs. That's four hundred games of magic. And of course variance likely screws you out of that so it takes longer.

I don't know about you, but that's almost a month worth of Arena for me. I don't think anyone was realistically grinding gold for draft through these events. At best you'd get one extra draft a month unless you literally dedicated your life to Arena for a day job.

In fact, the event grind is actually better now if you can maintain the win rate you had before, if you pay in gems at least (which you should). At 7 wins you get a profit of 125 gems, meaning it would only take six 7 win events to earn enough gems for a quick draft. If you were going 5-3, it still only takes thirty events to earn the 750 gems for a draft, rather than the fifty it took to earn 5000 gold under the old system. And on top of that you're earning packs rather than ICRs, which is much better as you get wild card progress and the event is now effectively "break even" at 3-3 (the old event broke even at 4-3 because 3 uncommon ICRs are utterly worthless).

My advice? Enter Bo1 Historic events with a deck like Selesnya 9 lives combo, something basically no one is prepared for. In every event I've done with it, even under the new system, I haven't gone less than 5-3.

6
TheKumaKen•

In fact, the event grind is actually better now if you can maintain the win rate you had before,

Which is definitely much more difficult because now the stakes are 5x more costly. New players with incomplete/non-meta decks are less inclined to participate now. This in turn will create a much more competitive environment akin to high end ranked queue, where your win rate is constantly pushed to the 50% mark, or worse.

I don't know about you, but that's almost a month worth of Arena for me. I don't think anyone was realistically grinding gold for draft through these events. At best you'd get one extra draft a month unless you literally dedicated your life to Arena for a day job.

Also, I think you are missing the point. The old event is basically a more lucrative alternative to the ranked queue for constructed. I can do my dailies with these events without the stress of high entry cost like drafts while still having the opportunity to make small gains. The rewards may seem small, but it does stack up over time.

Now though, it directly competes with the expensive draft events. You can win more, but you can also lose more.

1
rustledddAzorius•

It was something to do after u finished dailies… even at 50% win rate u got some ICRs… it’s not much but it still feels like progress… The random rare ICRs here and there helped! It wasn’t so much the gold grinding for me, more just knowing that time I put into the game helps my collection somehow!

3
davwad2•

I skipped the "regular" events, but did at least one run on the special events.

1
quintarium•

I played the old events as part of my dailies after reaching platinum on the ladder. I kept track and in the end, I earned about 60,000 gold from events.

1
igorwarzocha•

I personally had like 80% win rate and only just started getting gems as ICRs (which is the whole point of grinding the events IMO). FML.

1
bekelevenMirri•

It was more interesting and profitable than just laddering, at least once you get past the easy ranks.

You used to break even at 2-2, now you don't get your entry fee back until 4-1. Absolutely shameful.

1
Lord_Omnirock•

Weird, I play because I enjoy playing Magic....

13
KnightTimeHSOPLyra Dawnbringer•

We all do.

9
Lord_Omnirock•

I'm not un-sympathetic to your criticism to the changes btw. And my posting is more a response to a lot of posts about only playing to for daily wins to maximize profits, and only doing this or that to totally squeeze every potential coin out a day and call it quits...

It just seems like such an unfun way to play a game.

Maybe I didn't catch the edit, or glanced over the draft part, and for that, my bad. As others have said , you could make alts.

-1
jcalx•

I play to get the same feeling that I get playing the paper version, and I can only get that having enough cards to brew, since I spend only with paper the only way I can get this feeling is the same way OP described.

7
Rubbany•

I have much more free time now. No motivation to do more than 4 wins a day. For me fun was those random rares without stress with losing gold. Now when quick draft is possible, I draft, otherwise I play some brawl. Ladder is totally boring - one pack a month more for better league... Playing new events means almost for anybody less drafts, because almost nobody can play infinite 71% winrate against top players (during old events I had 71% winrate, but now the competitiveness is much higher because of 5x higher stakes)

13
KnightTimeHSOPLyra Dawnbringer•

I feel you bro. Constructed events means less drafts now, and this sucks.

7
cocteau93•

This is the best game ever made, just play it because it’s fun. I’m honestly confounded and mystified by the grind mentality — the notion that the only reason to play is to get a reward seems demoralizing.

I’m newish to Arena but I’ve been playing MtG since Arabian Nights and it’s never been free to play, so the idea that it needs to be free to play in what is frankly an infinitely more convenient digital format doesn’t compute for me. Just buy a few gems now and then and draft draft draft! It’s still the greatest game on earth whether you can go infinite or not.

8
M4xP0w3r_•

it’s never been free to play,

That is true. However it has also never been this expensive (whether you pay in time or money) to brew and play around with different cards, try out different things.

As a Kid, I would trade my way around to get to try out the cool things I want. As an adult I spent pennies to play all kinds of whacky stuff on MODO. Eventually I would end up spending a bunch on more expensive singles, but only after I tried out a lot for cheap or with resell value. I never liked to just find a good list online, spend 300$ and play it until rotation. That sort of playstyle has probably gotten cheaper on Arena, yet it still requires a lot of money every Set, and the main difference is you can never get any money back after you dont want or need the cards anymore.

It is more convenient now than ever, true. But if you consider the lack of owning/selling/trading it is probably also more expensive than ever for many types of players, despite the free to play appearence.

5
Bojangleslive•

Been in this boat for awhile. Play way less, maybe the occasional Brawl for shits and giggles

5
DUELETHERNETbro•

To many people in this sub treat this game like a job. Trying to optimize your gold per time intake sounds horribly depressing.

5
Cytrynek•

But optimiziation with this Player vs. Economy part of game is actually quite fun :-)

3
ghalta•

I do dailies on two accounts. On the primary I draft to set completion. On the second, I play events with restricted entry (e.g. one free entry type events), dailies, and, well, anything else I want that doesn't require constructed cards, since at this point it has 250k gold and 40k gems from playing and drafting when fun but otherwise just doing dailies.

4

Same here. The new event is basically buying packs at variable rates (depend on performance) unless you go infinite. After all, it's still buying packs. I'd rather save my gold for drafts.

4
Baratao00•

Same boat and can't even do draft until Quick Draft of SNC releases, really sucks not being able to farm gold and there is still people defending the new rewards nerf

4
Ootter31019•

Yeah same boat. To be fair I was most already in that boat previously. Never really got competitive on arena. Push ladder maybe but the events have always felt bad to me after the very initial update.

Leave the competitive stuff to fun in-person events.

3
godofawe•

what kills it was the rare removal from rewards, No good way to build historic rare collection now.

3†
Basnap•

Basically, rare card rewards have been replaced with boosters.

7
bubbles_maybe•

But packs are strictly better than ICRs? I know the EV went down, which obviously sucks, but on the other hand, grinding a historic collection has actually become WAY more time efficient.

2†
rustledddAzorius•

Packs were basically ICRs for newer players! And the lower potential loss from the old events helped!

1
Vegetable_Ad3750•

I am F2P as well. I draft and play Brawl, Historic Brawl, and the mid week events if they are the free draft, pauper, provided decks, or brawl.

That is enough to satiate my need for playing Magic.

3
bpetey•

For a casual the new event changes have ruined it for me. Twice now I dumped 2500 gold in and got like 75 gems out.

3
ScionOfTheMists•

I mean, you could also just play because the game is fun?

2†
KnightTimeHSOPLyra Dawnbringer•

Of course!
I play magic for more than 6 years and still find it extremely fun.
I like constructed to try new things, interesting card interations.

But I absolutely love draft, I think its where magic's prime glory lays at.

The reason to my frustration is the fact that previously we could get more gold, from gold entry events. So the >possibility< of getting more gold to draft more and expand your collection was always there.

This is gone now, so feels less rewarding to play arena, but ofc it is still fun.

4
ScionOfTheMists•

But I absolutely love draft, I think its where magic's prime glory lays at.

Draft is the best! I'm basically a 100% Limited player a this point.

3
metalhevStormCrow•

Yeah, there's zero reason to actually do them now. Seems to me like a bizarre move by wotc.
It's like the normal play queue but worse lol.

2
DanceOnBoxes•

I'm a bit ootl, did they gut constructed events or something?

2