Anyone else watch Picard season 2?

I really didnt think it could get worse than season 1 but my word did it ever. Idiot ball plot after idiot ball plot with every contrived rehashed story line you can think of slathered in the most overt and lame fan service. Really hope the guys come in hot and rip this trash to pieces. It didnt even feel like Patrick Stewart was playing Picard.

Posted May 6, 2022, 1:34 PM UTC

2067
JustDandy07•

Disclaimer: I haven't yet watched the finale but I assume it's terrible.

This show was so bad. It's the same plot as First Contact but they made everything worse.

Hey guys let's do a full season of Star Trek in fucking PRESENT DAY. Assholes.

Sold us on a Picard vs. Q season and Q has had like 5 minutes of screentime.

14
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

the finale is possibly the worst ep of the season so enjoy. Yea Q and whoopi for 5 seconds of screen time. All of the focus of the show on these side characters that are all written with the same fast talking cringe inducing dialogue

7
mi-16evilThe Jamemaster•

Gotta expect that season 3 will leave the TNG cast for a similarly insulting amount of time.

6
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

yea their casting doesnt really bring me any hope that the series will get better. You can only make so much art when given shit writing to work with

0
JustDandy07•

Fuck.

2
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

Strange New Worlds was fun though. Not amazing but fun with room to grow

4
JustDandy07•

I will wait. All of the new Trek shows have a good first episode or two then they turn into disasters.

6
Alice_margareta•

Watch RLM’s reviews on it. They hated it so much they basically gave up on TNG too.

11
PolarCow•

Kinda broke my heart listening to Mike say that his love of TNG has been tainted.

13
Alice_margareta•

Same. Like, im very much a casual but i still remember fondly watching TNG and Voyager with my parents.

It really is Sir Patrick Stewart’s apathy that sullies it now. You feel no charisma or any form of the character at all.

Not to say he’s a bad actor and he’s not the main reason the show doesn’t work, but it is the penultimate shame.

8
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

yea I agree the stewart apathy was palpable but also the writing did him no favors. He basically had nothing to do and no impact on the resolution of the season

5
Alice_margareta•

Exactly. It’s not really his fault…but, I feel he should be more honest about how the show is to him. Obv he cant trash it, but those zoom calls make it just so facetious.

3
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

RLM typically isnt my cup of tea, but I will have to check this one out for sure

5
Alice_margareta•

Its perfect if you have a genuine love if old TNG because they really know their shit, without any help too.

4
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

I have been watching the picard RLM reviews and thanks for the rec, they have been a lot of fun

2
NeverAgain42•

“What if the Federation were fanatical purifiers and Picard was the Illusive Man” would make a great movie or 2 part episode. But…for a 10 hour season, no.

As soon as I heard they where going back to present day, I knew the show was in trouble. Cue hours of modern low budget car chases

10
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

yea and the climatic action being a lame fight with modern special forces, such great star trek. The only thing worse than the lame action was the hamfisted canon rewriting fan service. I am really done with seeing bret spiner in a new character

7
JoenameI SAW IT HAPPEN•

A very promising opening two episodes that very quickly were flushed down the toilet. The show's plotting, editing, and pacing add up to an incomprehensible jumble. The show is an absolute mess. There's no reason for it to exist.

Now, Strange New Worlds on the other hand. MAN what a premiere. Loved it.

9
allubros•

A very promising opening two episodes that very quickly were flushed down the toilet.

Now, Strange New Worlds on the other hand. MAN what a premiere. Loved it.

We're going to have to call this the Kurtzman Star Trek cycle

4
Hot_Dog_Cobbler•

I was watching it, but I fell behind. The fact that "Oh shit, I dropped my communicator badge" is a plot point three times and "Oh shit, we got arrested" is used twice proves how week the premise is.

Also, they're spending too much time in 2024. It's just not interesting.

But Strange New Worlds was FUCKING GREAT

8
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

Having a whole episode where they are interrogated by one FBI guy who just lets them go and does nothing else was really brutal. It really is purely on the writing how bad the show is, they have no idea what to do with the picard character and can only write fast talking smirking quip characters. And I am a MCU fan so it takes a lot to make me dislike quippy people, but when everyone is trying to be star lord it gets brutal

that being said, Strange New Worlds was a lovely breathe of fresh air. Not perfect but I had a great time

5
Hot_Dog_Cobbler•

It's baffling how fucking stupid they are in this series. Seven kind of has an excuse because her Borg implants are out. Same for Rios because he's always been kind of an idiot.

Picard comes off as a doddering old man (and hey, I didn't need him getting close to his MAID WHO IS YOUNG ENOUGH TO BE HIS GRANDDAUGHTER).

If they renamed Raffi and said she was an entirely new character I wouldn't even blink.

Agnes is just...who the fuck thought leaving the neurotic, unstable woman who killed her ex and is obsessed with post-humanity alone on a ship with The Borg Queen was a good idea?

Fuck! I wanted this to be good!

2
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

not too mention everything described is just rehashes of what they already did in season one. Rios is trying to be cold but is opened up, raffi is haunted by some grief and is really mean to everyone all the time because of it, Agnes is being mentally manipulated by an alien, soji from last season once again learns she is not human but a creation

its just all so basic and bad

2
Hot_Dog_Cobbler•

Brent Spiner was fun though

2
BoozeGetsMeThrough•

I made it about halfway. I was watching that and Halo every week and just eating the slop because I'm a pig. But then I watched a couple of HBO shows and remembered that TV can be very, very, very good and so I haven't been able to continue either of those Paramount+ shows. Maybe in a month or so I'll forget and finish the season for both shows

6
allubros•

Severance and For All Mankind are both great if you're looking for actually well-plotted sci fi

Apple killing it lately

Oh The Expanse is amazing too but that's a Prime show

3
BoozeGetsMeThrough•

I watched the first season of For All Mankind but couldn't get too into it. Same with the Expanse. I did love Severance though.

2
allubros•

Expanse starts slow but becomes literally the best space show ever made by the 3rd season. Gotta give it another shot

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
allubros•

What in the fuck

That's the name of the show

2
GenderNeutralBot•

Maybe they should have called it something less sexist? 🤷

-6
impossiblefunky•

Hated every second of it.

5
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

somehow it was even worse than the TOS backdoor pilot ep Assignment: Earth, at least that ep had Teri Garr and a mischievous cat

3
sonofodin25•

One of the worst seasons of television I’ve ever watched in my life

That “Borg” battle in episode 9 made Kirk Vs The Gorn look like a work of art

The stuff with the mother made me want to hang myself beside her on the ceiling

Q gets about 8 minutes in the whole season

Raffi exists, enough said

The scene with fucking Will Wheaton literally made me burst out laughing

They beat the Borg with the power of friendship

And worst of all they’re so fucking cheap they can’t even afford new actors, so some actors are playing multiple parts (Laris/Tallinn, Soji/Kori, Soong/Data) WITH NO FUCKING EXPLANATION WHAT-SO-EVER!!!!

Fuck this show

4
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

Couldn’t agree more, no notes

1
Uncle_BorislavLick my bunghole motherfucka!•

nah i ain't watch trash

3
calliduslupus•

I did! Overall I didn't care for it!

They sold me on Q being in it and I bought it hook, line and sinker. The only parts that I enjoyed had him in it so it was successful, but he was hardly around at all to make it worth watching the whole season.

3
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

Yea I was in the same boat. Cant believe they just redid first contact but made everything worse in everyway

3
nboylie•

I made it to episode 6 but I couldn't take any more abuse.

3
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

that is totally fair, I was 100% masochistically hate watching it by ep 2

2
DawgBroThe Borg Clit•

I actually had fun with it and thought the finale tied the season together really well.

3
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

must.... not.... downvote.... must respect, others opinions

4
charliefortean•

Fine, I'll do it myself

6
DawgBroThe Borg Clit•

It’s okay to like a TV show. But yeah, I can see why people don’t like it. It’s a very clumsy show that feels nothing like TNG.

3
ShaunTrek•

Me too! I thought it was way better than Season One. It is a couple of episodes too long, so it gets a bit wheel spinny in the back half, but in general it worked for me.

Still second from the bottom on my Trek series ranking (above Discovery).

2
udkyle2•

I thought it was fine.

It was for sure bloated. Paramount+ really needs to take a look at their shows and release them based on what works best for the show, because this should have been dumped all at once. If you're going to run in place for 6-7 episodes, that's a tough ask for an audience to come back each week.

If I had to guess, the gang will be mostly gentle with it (a polite dislike), with the exception of Cabin, who, if they made him watch it, is going to lose it when he gets to that finale cameo.

I can't see them coming in hot on it. There's still a lot of stuff they (and I) like about TNG-era Trek here. Stewart was good. Both DeLancie and Whoopi were fantastic, I could have used so much more of that. I'm not thrilled about the newbies (and Seven) other than Allison Pill who probably had the most interesting stuff of that whole group throughout.

They could have balanced it better with a couple more episodes in the Confederation MAGA hellscape and a little less in present day.

3
badluckartist•

Last night I watched the Strange New Worlds premiere, and then the TOS Menagerie two-parter for Pike's original story, and THEN the finale of Picard S2.

I'm still in the hospital for severe whiplash.

3

Fuuuuuuuuuck, it was so bad. Hey, Q’s back! Sike, he’s gone, mostly. SURPRISE MOTHERFUCKERS, he’s dead now! Where’s the Continuum? Fuck you, that’s where!

…What? He just did the same thing Data did last season (loosely served as a consistent plot device only to be shuffled off the board with the all the grace of a Soylent Green-style dump truck hearse? Get the fuck outta here. No way!)

Say, remember that bland lady with the super round face that killed that guy last season? She’s back! And she’s a Borg Queen, kinda! Also, she’s still theoretically human but gnaws on car batteries like a fucking maniac. Yes, kinda like the Man from Mars in Blondie’s “Rapture!” But waaaaay more stupid.

Also, we kinda forgot what to do with Rios after he got detained, so he fell in love and stayed on earth in this wildly unnecessary tangent past that Q created. What happened to him? Oh! No worries, he got murdered in a bar fight like Jaco Pastorius in Morocco off-screen.

Also, Wil kept hovering by the craft service table and wouldn’t leave so we slapped him in a denim jacket and made him a space genie so he could steal away with Brent Spiner’s suuuuuuper albino daughter.

In short, we nailed it.

3
ticklemenonoTrea-sure and jew-els•

I just don't care about any character that was created for this series. I just can't do it.

2
dejerikOPDon't tell me it didnt happen•

Couldn’t agree more, every character was written with the same fast talking style and it was annoying as hell

1