Do y’all agree that Old WB still seems stronger than BM even after seeing her fight?

SpoilerDiscussion

I’ll admit kaido does seem stronger than old beard by a bit, but that’s definitely not the perception I have with BM. While she does seem incredibly powerful, I just don’t see her beating old beard. I also can’t see old beard losing to Kid and Law, even by ring out the way she lost. Do y’all agree?

Posted May 7, 2022, 9:07 PM UTC

056
jobin3141592Slave•

There’s no common point to compare those two so far, can’t say for sure.

That, and the fact that Big Mom has had quite a big uh… anti plot armor so to speak

9
Noxazz•

I’ll admit kaido does seem stronger than old beard by a bit

by a very very very very huge bit

4
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

Defensively yes otherwise no.

I'm not talking about Dyingbeard mind you, but Oldbeard on a good day.

1
KeepCopingForwardOP•

Lol no not really. Why do you say that???

-1
Noxazz•

Kaido is MUCH stronger than Marineford Whitebeard

3
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

Yes he is stronger than Dyingbeard, but not Oldbeard.

0
KeepCopingForwardOP•

What’s the evidence for that?

-1
Noxazz•

read the manga lol

0†
omicron-7Pirate•

Nah man. All the injuries Whitebeard took except for Akainu's would have just bounced off of Big Mom. Everything Kid and Law threw at Big Mom would have been much more effective on Whitebeard.

3
KeepCopingForwardOP•

Same could be said for any other top tier. BM is the only one with “iron skin”. The scabbards easily cut kaido, shanks got his arm eaten by a fish, roger was stabbed by fodder, BB was pierced by ace etc.

1
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

Kaido seems to have a very mild weakness to blade attacks, he must hate paper cuts.

0
boahancocks_nose•

I'd say WB has her beat in strategization. WB still has some brute strength in him, as seen by him throwing around giants and that shockwave he made that reached the platform in Marineford. Old Beard would probably tie, because fighting Big Mom is never a 1v1 with Hera and Prometheus. He'll probably beat her by a hair(but I assume he's bald under that bandana).

2
Adventurous-Union-28Pirate•

If he was healthy sure but not with that sickness

1
Own-Ad8986•

No.

1
rancorg•

Anyone powerscaling stuff that we don’t have full info on.......you just assuming lol,we can make any kinda point we want but really we don’t know

1
KeepCopingForwardOP•

What? We have seen both BM and WB fight now lmao. Do you read one piece?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Secret_Soldier007•

Raw power maybe, but overall strength I disagree. WB could even barely use he's CoC haki in the Marine Ford war.

1
ShiroYaksha01•

No, he never was, especially not with that illness. Big Mom lost because she was an idiot not because she was weak

0
SultaNN_K5Cipher Pol•

Isn't that a weakness?

2
RuncornThristleExplorer•

More like she underestimated Law/Kidd. If it is 1v1 without any interference and reward is some rare sweets, she should be able to defeat old WB. 🤣🤣

1
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

Oldbeard on a good day would fight her to a draw, otherwise BM would win.

1
ShiroYaksha01•

No, she severely underestimated the two and didn't even use advanced conquerors

1
SultaNN_K5Cipher Pol•

Personally I don't really see the difference. It's always the same thing with Big Mom being cocky which leads to her fall

1
ShiroYaksha01•

True, I'm not disputing they won, because they definitely did, it just doesn't make them more powerful than her nor will it help them against an opponent with more than 3 brain cells

1
Megadoomer2•

Not really - if not for extremely specific circumstances (the battle taking place on a crumbling island floating in midair) and blind luck (neither Kid or Law knew that there happened to be enough bombs directly beneath Big Mom to destroy an entire island), then by all accounts, Big Mom would have just gotten up from that railgun blast and kept going. (I wouldn't be surprised if she climbs out of the hole that she's stuck in by the end of the arc)

If the fight took place anywhere else, it seems like Law and Kid would have lost.

1
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

That hole goes to the bottom of hell, we will be there with her soon. xD

1
ylcknightPirate•

Big Mom is a 20 foot tall woman with a sentient cloud and sun, both named after gods, who can literally rain lightning and fire from the heavens, her skin is like iron (yet Squard easily stabbed Whitebeard), yet a RAILGUN couldn’t even put a dent in her skin. Mind you all, Big Mom lost the fight because she fell through the floor, not because she got KO’d

0
KeepCopingForwardOP•

WB is known as the strongest pirate and worlds strongest man. He wields the most powerful paramecia and in lore is said to have the “power to destroy the world”. He went toe to toe with admirals, the navy’s strongest military weapons. I don’t see what naming their abilities and lore does lol. Also, you bring up WB being stabbed, but most top tiers don’t have “iron skin” like BM. Kaido was stabbed by the scabbards, shanks got his arm eaten by a fish, roger was stabbed by fodders at his execution, BB was pierced by ace etc. I could go on and on.

It’s true BM was not KO’d, but she was still being overwhelmed by kid and law, that much is undeniable, which is how she got rung out, which I stated in my OP.

1
ylcknightPirate•

WB was old. His body was easily pierced by bullets, cannonballs, and regular swords. He still had shadows of power from the man he once was, but not anymore. The World’s Strongest, is merely a title. Kaido or Big Mom would have outperformed him at that time. Shanks too. Even Blackbeard, who now has the strongest logia and paramecia. Akainu blew half of WB face off, Blackbeard finished him off with normal bullets. He was literally a shell of his former self. If he’s so weak to attacks, then Kaido is REALLY going to mess him up. And so will Big Mom, who can legit casually launch Ikoku Soverignty.

And that “most top tiers don’t have iron skin”, isn’t a good argument, because CLEARLY, Kaido and Big Mom can’t be damaged by just any ol’ attack. The Scabbards can all use Ryuo, they’re stronger than most pirates at Marineford. Roger let himself be killed, we don’t know why or how Shanks let his arm get taken, BB was pierced by Ace fire, but we know how his body works, he will be hit by anything because of his fruit.

Law has attacks that CAN NOT be guarded against. His sword pierced your body without making a wound, and destroys you internally. If sick Whitebeard took the same attacks she took, and then got nuked like she did, he’d be in the grave, again. If Law attacks you, you have no choice but to avoid the blow, or tank the attack.

1
grandnock•

No not even close he had a heart attack dropped down like 3 times and couldn't use proper haki

0
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

Oldbeard = Kaido = Big Mom = Shanks = Blackbeard

Anything else is a lie.

0
KeepCopingForwardOP•

Agreed sort of. I do think there is a slight hierarchy, but they can all still take each other to high diff. Shanks > Kaido > old beard > BM. Again, they all really close.

1
WiseXcaliburThe Revolutionary Army•

You forgot a certain cherry pie loving bastard.

1
BestMusicInTheGame•

MF Whitebeard was literally getting stabbed by fodder, he didn’t even have the energy to dodge and unlike Big Mom those attacks actually hurt him. He was significantly weaker than the other yonkos at that point.

0
KeepCopingForwardOP•

Idk why people bring this up, it only applies to her, not all top tiers except Old beard. BM is the only one with “iron skin”. The scabbards easily cut kaido, shanks got his arm eaten by a fish, roger was stabbed by fodder, BB was pierced by ace etc.

2
BestMusicInTheGame•

No Kaido also has “iron skin” the scabbards have advanced armament which is why they cut him, and you could even argue that they only did so because of his PTSD. At the end of the day Kaido still has the single most impressive durability feat to date, which was no-selling a G4 onslaught.

1
KeepCopingForwardOP•

Still, getting cut by kinemons air slash doesn’t make him look good lmao. Anyone with mild advanced Armament can cut him easily then.

1
BestMusicInTheGame•

Anyone with advanced armament haki can cut anyone. It’s not like there are a whole lot of characters who actually have it.

1
Akitokami9000•

I disagree Marinford whitebeard would lose to both kaido and bm. since both them will take him seriously unlike with law, kidd and luffy, heart attacks and basically weakened reflexes and possibly no adv coc He doesn't beat either of them

Old Whitebeard when he met shanks is a different story

-2
KeepCopingForwardOP•

When he met shanks, That was a week before marine ford.

1
Akitokami9000•

When he came to marinford his health became even worse

While when he meat shanks it was still in control

-2