Questions about cutting steel stock

I’ve been using an angle grinder to cut out knife shapes out of 1095 stock but I’ve been finding myself checking out bandsaws lately but am not finding enough info on their capabilities. Does someone here have any good knowledge, or resources to point me into the direction of, moving on from an angle grinder or something that would be a little more efficient for these projects moving forward?

Posted May 9, 2022, 8:11 PM UTC

320
thebeginingisnear•

I have a harbor freight vertical/horizontal bandsaw and it's a great value buy especially if you can get it used. Works great for rough cutting lengths out. One of the few tools in my shop I would consider a true workhorse. You can setup a table on it and cut out profiles, but for that purpose it's slow, and requires a good amount of hand pressure to keep the cut going. Not my favorite operation to do in the shop. If your material somehow got work hardened along the way forget about it.

I have a Milwaukee compact portable band saw. Great tool overall. limited width/depth gets in the way. cuts quicker than my HF bandsaw but sight lines arent great if your trying to cut out profiles carefully.

Angle grinder is going to be your fastest method if your trying to cut shapes out rather than grind them unfortunately. Its loud, and messy, and dangerous but it's popular cause it gets the job done

this is all based on my experience trying to profile 1/4- 1/8 inch billets.

3
ANDRADE101OP•

Would this happen to be the central machinery bandsaw HF sells for $150? I just got back from the store and checked it out, but the box said to cut “some hard wood and soft wood,” and the employees didn’t seem to have an idea either. I don’t mind the angle grinder, but like you said it’s loud, messy and can be very dangerous if you’re not dialed in (which should never be the case). I can see me using the bandsaw for multiple purposes (wood working) as well, so I feel like it would be a great addition, I just wanted to gather a general consensus since I’m a little new to this. Thank you for your response, by the way.

1
thebeginingisnear•

This is the HF bandsaw i was referring to.

https://www.harborfreight.com/power-tools/power-saws/band-saws-scroll-saws/horizontal-vertical-metal-cutting-bandsaw-93762.html

You might be thinking of the wood bandsaws. I had the ryobi equivalent and sold it. Was getting way too much drift on the blade no matter how much i tried tuning it. Didnt have the power and precision to make it worth keeping around for me.

You cant use something like that on steel. Totally different blades, different rpms. Would be a disaster. You might be able to cut some soft materials like aluminum maybe.

Generally speaking you need to think of wood and metal as two totally different materials that require their own set of tools. Different blades, different machine specs (HP, rpms, torque, etc). I dont think youll find any meaningful overlap for power tools.

1
ANDRADE101OP•

Thank you. This is the information that the store reps were unable to help me out with. I appreciate the information here, very helpful.

1
thebeginingisnear•

No problem, happy to help. It can be daunting early on with all the tools you realize you need. The further along you get the more you get lured towards the sexy stuff like 2x72 belt grinders and all the possible accessories, forge presses, heat treating ovens, etc.

You don't necessarily need all the stuff if your just trying to make a few knives for fun. You can get away with files, hand sanding, drill press and mailing out for heat treat. But if your actually trying to build a business out of it they become essential cause of how much time they save you and improve your consistency and quality once you learn to use them properly. You can easily be in the hole for thousands trying to outfit your shop with things you will convince yourself you need. Make sure your budget aligns with your ambition.

1
Coop_1800•

I have the Milwaukee portable bandsaw w swag off road table and it was a definite upgrade. Works well and is quick and clean. Obviously it's limited on power but I don't need it for much else so it's fine for now with limited space and budget. Upgrading to a bigger unit would be nice for the fence and deeper working area, but this setup is pretty effective.

2
ANDRADE101OP•

That’s the one my neighbor was telling me about, he didn’t know about the table tho. What type of blades are you using to cut your profiles?

1
Coop_1800•

The table is a pretty popular option and is well built. Definitely a good solution to get thr capability of a bandsaw without committing to a full size one. I put a zip tie on the trigger and have a foot switch. These are the blades I got based off others recommendations and they've worked well. They last a good while and it's obvious when they need to be changed. I also use a wax stick, just apply the wax when you first get going.

LENOX Tools Portable Band Saw Blades, 44-7/8" x 1/2" x .020", 18 TPI, 5-Pack (8010838PW185) https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0042T0SWK/ref=cm_sw_r_apan_i_CNWA2Q3Y29GK61KT99D7?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

Foot switch (overkill maybe but it's badass) SSC Controls F300-1501 Foot Switch, Maintained Action (Push On/Push Off), 8-ft Cable with Piggyback Plug (3-Pronged), Die-Cast, Electrical, Single Pedal, Made in USA https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01819NABM/ref=cm_sw_r_apan_i_40V94VMXWKAB5W1015NH?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1

1
Jlandon_p07•

I bought my Milwaukee portaband for $20 from a lady the other day. Lol built my own stand and table for it all under $25.

1
CasperFatone•

I have this bandsaw from harbor freight with a swag off road table and a foot switch. For me it’s perfect because I’m not doing a ton of larger knives. It struggles with cutting stock over 3/16”, but for 1/8” and thin titanium it rocks. The cuts are very controlled, clean, and cool. For thicker stuff I will just grab my angle grinder.

https://www.harborfreight.com/10-amp-deep-cut-variable-speed-band-saw-64194.html

2
ANDRADE101OP•

Great. Thank you for sharing!

1
Made-a-blade•

If you just need to cut a rough shape, an anglegrinder is 100% better. Discs are cheaper and easier to change and it cuts faster. You CAN get bandsaws that can do the job, but it's not worth it. The blades wear out, they cost more, they're a pain to change and the machine is just bulky.

Get a rough shape, then head to the belt grinder to remove the rest with an aggressive belt. With a bit of practice, you can make some pretty neat cuts with an angle grinder.

Oh, and most of the high strength band saws are fixed and work by laying the rotating blade down on the material, meaning you can only cut in straight lines, one cut at a time. If you're thinking about pushing around a piece of metal and finely cut the shape like you do with a piece of wood. Nah, not really going to happen.

1
ANDRADE101OP•

Good to know. I appreciate the response. I don’t mind using the angle grinder, but was jonesing for another tool. Thought maybe I should maybe focus on a drill press instead.

1
Made-a-blade•

Drill press is a major upgrade if you don't have one. Grinder attachments. Tilting modifications. Good vises, etc. So many things to spend on.

2
ANDRADE101OP•

So many. My wife is annoyed lol

1
WUNDER8AR•

Drill press is the better upgrade for you. A vertical metal bandsaw is convenient but its slow and still only a tool for the rough work. Drill press elevates your game in getting good tight fits and you can make your own tooling that doesn't suck because the holes turned out crooked or oversized. It is just so much more efficient and fun than a handdrill.

1
failedattempt1•

I have a Milwaukee portaband with the deeper throat and a cheapo horizontal that does double duty as a vertical bandsaw. If I had to choose one it would be the horizontal/vertical bandsaw. I hate cutting profiles with a cutoff wheel and a grinder. Lots of heat and mess. I found my horizontal for $100 on craigs list. It’s a little beat but it cuts steel and bands are cheaper than discs for the amount of cut steel you get.

1
ANDRADE101OP•

Would you happen to have the brand and model number so I can take a look?

1
failedattempt1•

It’s a Grizzly G1010 from the early 80’s. Grizzly still makes one but the quality is much better than what I have. Jet also makes a similar model. I’m sure there are other manufacturers of varying quality.

1
ANDRADE101OP•

Awesome. Everyone is giving me good info here. I appreciate the info

1