Giving someone money, even life-changing amounts of money, doesn't give you a free pass from critism.

[Rant/Vent]

In AITA, there's a thread about an uncle pulling promised college funding because he overheard his 16yo niece saying something unkind about him. It's the overwhelming responses of him being justified in pulling her funding over it that I'm focused on, not the details of why he chose to pull funding. (The post doesn't have sufficient info to make a honest determination.)

The majority of comments are very much "He was going to pay for her college. She has an obligation not to say unkind things about him which she believes are true because he's going to pay for her education."

Bullshit! Giving someone money or gifts does not make you immune to critism. It does not exempt you from having consequences of your actions. A gift comes with no strings. A promise of a gift is empty until that gift, again with no strings, is delivered. It's not a payment or future payment for someone silence. It doesn't buy affection or loyalty. Your actions earn affection and loyalty, or the lack thereof.

You don't owe anyone, no matter what or how much they've given to you, including life, your silence when you see them do something wrong. You don't owe them your inaction when they harm someone else or you. You don't have to quietly take it because they paid you off. Be true to yourself while being as safe as you can and be as fearless as you can while speaking truth.

Posted May 15, 2022, 5:59 PM UTC

146

He didn’t owe her anything either. He was giving her something out of the goodness of his heart. The least she could have done is be kind. He was under no obligation to give her anything. And I’m glad he didn’t. This is how people become entitled assholes. They say and do whatever they want without consequences.

3
Perpetual_learner8•

He pulled funding because she was making fun of him behind his back, saying he was infertile and refused to admit it because of his “fragile masculinity.” And that it was a good thing his wife left him while she still had time to have children with someone else. Did we ever read the same post?!

2
eresh22OP•

Yes, we did.

Those details don't matter to my point. You don't owe someone your silence on things that matter to you just because they give you money, no matter how much money it is.

Do you honestly believe the details, where we don't have the most important details to make a judgement (i.e how did they actually handle their infertility and was what the niece said justified) are more important to talk about here than whether or not someone giving you money means they control you????

If you want to argue about their situation, find my comments on AITA. It's not relevant here.

-4
AutoModeratorMOD•

This is an automated message posted to ALL posts in this subreddit with some basic information about the group including (very importantly) rules. Why are you getting this message? Most people seem to not read the sidebar for information or the rules, so it is now being posted under all posts.

Confused about acronyms or terminology? Click here!

Need info or resources? Check out our Helpful Links for information on how to deal with identity theft, how to get independent of your n-parents, how to apply for FAFSA, how to identify n-parents and SO MUCH MORE!

This is a reminder to all participants, RBN is a support group that is moderated very strictly. Please report inappropriate content so it can be reviewed by the mods.

Our rules include (but are not limited to):

  • No politics.
  • Advising anyone in this subreddit to commit suicide or referring anyone to groups that advocate this will result in an immediate ban.
  • Be nice. No personal attacks, name calling, or bullying. No slurs or victim-blaming.
  • Do not derail the posts of others.
  • Narcissists are NOT allowed to post or comment here.
  • No platitudes or generic motivational posts.
  • When you comment/post, assume a context of abuse.
  • No asking or offering gifts, money, etc.
  • No content advocating violence, revenge, murder (even in jest).
  • No content about N-kids.
  • No diagnosis by media/drive-by diagnosis.
  • No linking to Facebook pages.
  • No direct linking to anywhere on reddit.
  • No pure image posts.

For a full list of our rules/more information, click here.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

while I absolutley agree with your ideas, I wouldn't touch AITA with a 10 foot pole, nothing in there is as people present it.

0
eresh22OP•

Of course it isn't. Everyone is the center of their own universe. We all look for validation in being right and adjust how we tell stories of the past to better get the reaction we're wanting for validation. I like figuring out which of the posts are creative writing exercises, which are legit questions, and seeing how people from different backgrounds feel about situations.

-1