1_p_freely•

Crazy that these companies get an entire software stack for free and still can't comply with the terms. If it were up to me, I would just notify them of termination of license... meaning they have to immediately cease selling the product

34
IterativeSieve•

Doesn't really work like that in this case. The SFC is filing suit as a third party beneficiary, meaning they're basically attempting to get the court to enforce the GPL based on the rights the GPL would grant them upon receipt of the licensed code.

They don't have standing to enforce the copyright or termination clause itself, only the copyright holder does.

35
mrtruthiness•

... I would just notify them of termination of license... .

The SFC is not acting as the copyright owner and thus does not have the right to terminate the license. The SFC is suing based on being the beneficiary of GPL'd code in the TV and asserting that they are being denied their rights to the code.

It's an interesting case because if Vizio loses, there are minimal damages. IANAL, but even if the SFC wins, I think the judgment will be: "SFC gets a copy of the code" or "the cost of the TV". I think the SFC is dreaming if they think that the judge will stop Vizio from using GPL code without meeting the terms of the license.

5
OsrsNeedsF2P:arch:•

“The ruling is a watershed moment in the history of copyleft licensing. This ruling shows that the GPL agreements function both as copyright licenses and as contractual agreements,” says Karen M. Sandler, executive director of Software Freedom Conservancy. Sandler noted that many in the Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) legal community argue incorrectly that the GPL and other copyleft licenses only function as copyright licenses.

Huge win. Love you SFC

5