Why does my CoreXY printer have substantially more ringing caused by the X axis movements?

Question
Why does my CoreXY printer have substantially more ringing caused by the X axis movements?

Posted May 18, 2022, 11:26 AM UTC

39
lapotronicOP•

This is the klipper ringing tower, with acceleration starting at 1500 and gradually increasing to 7000 as it goes up. I haven't done any resonance compensation yet, but this is obviously too extreme to try and tune out. Any ideas where I should look mechanically?

1
drumdude0•

I've all but eliminated ringing on my Ender by snugging the h outta the rollers.

2
drumdude0•

Reveal yourself, downvoter.

That was a tip.

Has a better print upset you, or was it the mention of the E-word?

1
DopeBoogie•

was it the mention of the E-word?

Eliminated?

Jokes aside though, it may be your suggestion of "snugging the hell out of the rollers."

Instead what you should do is alternately tighten the wheels and the eccentric nutsuntil the wheels can no longer spin freely (without moving the gantry) and the wheel remains centered within the v-slot. You should then move the gantry to both extremes and re-check that the roller wheels continue to be centered and captive.

This does not require tightening the hell out of them, just thought enough that there is no play when the gantry moves.

To be clear, I didn't downvote you, I'm just noting that simply tightening the hell out of the wheels will likely lead to a wheel misalignment rather than a perfectly constructed printer. Your comment just lacked specificity.

3
drumdude0•

S'all good. E as in Ender. Gets hated on all too frequently, albeit justified. Excellent fleshing-out of my gist, btw.

By snug I mean as in lateral force against the extruded aluminum. The firmer the rollers are, such they act like a constant brake pressure, the less push/pull the elasticity of the belts can impose on the finish of the outer surface.

I'll add some pictures in a bit.

1
questioning_alpaca20x Prusa Mini Clones (modded af)•

Make sure the belts are tight, try to reduce weight, use input shaper

0

Theres a nice band near the cross of the X with no ringing

1