Would you pay for Echo Project's visual novels?

Discussion

This is purely from a curiosity stand point. I played Cliff's new update in The Smoke Room and after getting to "that" part, I kind of looked back and thought "you are giving this out for free? Really? THAT. For. Free." I have bought way worse games for full price, I bought the new Battlefield game for god's sake and that game sucks ass. The ratio of how much I enjoyed Echo to it's free cost is honestly kind of crazy. I've bought plenty of full fledged VN's that I enjoyed less than Echo. Like I'd at least pay 40$ for Echo and I know I would def pay for future projects.

I already sub to their patreon because I felt bad getting Echo for free with how much I enjoyed it. So yeah would you pay for their projects/future projects?

Posted May 19, 2022, 12:39 AM UTC

3517
StoicMegazord•

This is why I will generally go in and play a VN, and if I feel like it's a quality game I'd personally like to see completed, I sub to their Patreon. A TON of work goes into these, so I feel like helping them fund their venture in such a niche market is a worthwhile expense.

That being said, I'm always hesitant about those that charge up front since quality and depth of content can vary so widely in FVN's. I'm willing to pay if it's got a good reputation/reviews, but again with it being so niche, it can be hard to find any significant source of reviews to make an educated decision.

21
kingpoke0901•

Would I pay for it? Yes, depending on the prices.

Should they start charging for the game? That's their decision to make.

And imo they shouldn't, being free makes the game more accessible so more people are willing to try it. In turn they can have more Patreons and merch because as you said people feel like they should be paying for an experience like this, which I think is wonderful as it help the devs do what they love. There's not a lot of long form vn that are paid for and get much attention, they'll be as popular as Knight College (cus hot men) and gets forgotten after a while. Overall, the pros to being free out weight the cons for the devs.

The Echo project games probable wouldn't be as popular in the fvn community if it wasn't free.

6
Paid-Not-Payed-Bot•

that are paid for and

FTFY.

Although payed exists (the reason why autocorrection didn't help you), it is only correct in:

  • Nautical context, when it means to paint a surface, or to cover with something like tar or resin in order to make it waterproof or corrosion-resistant. The deck is yet to be payed.

  • Payed out when letting strings, cables or ropes out, by slacking them. The rope is payed out! You can pull now.

Unfortunately, I was unable to find nautical or rope-related words in your comment.

Beep, boop, I'm a bot

1
kingpoke0901•

Good bot

1
B0tRank•

Thank you, kingpoke0901, for voting on Paid-Not-Payed-Bot.

This bot wants to find the best and worst bots on Reddit. You can view results here.


^(Even if I don't reply to your comment, I'm still listening for votes. Check the webpage to see if your vote registered!)

1
DNAbroOP•

You are right they definitely wouldn't have been as popular if they weren't free, but my thought is that they have enough clout that I wouldn't be shocked if they made their future games paid. I'm just kind of used to paying for visual novels, it seems only when it's a furry visual novel that free is the standard. I wouldn't have tried Echo if it wasn't free, but now that I have I would pay for it. Basically the same thing I did with Doki Doki Lit Club, once Dan Salvato made a paid version, I bought it day 1. If Echo Project packaged Echo/Route 65 together, maybe added voice acting, and put it up on Steam (or hell if they could somehow get a Switch port) then I'd 100% buy it.

1
kingpoke0901•

A switch port with voice acting sounds really cool, but that would just take so much effort and not enough payback, fully voice acted that is. It would be better if they did it like Cryptid Crush, still a nice idea to think about.

Also a switch port would be kinda pointless cus everyone and their moms have phones.

1
DNAbroOP•

I've never heard of Cryptid Crush before but now I'm very interested so thanks for introducing it to me.

Main reason I would want it on Switch is that it's my first choice for reading visual novels if I have it. Don't have an android phone so can't exactly download many VNs on there.

1
JoshuaTheFoxWho needs ass when you have tail?•

I basically already am. After I finished Adastra (my first VN of theirs) i almost immediately went and subscribed to the Echo Project Patreon and Haps Patreon

3
apollogamez60•

I think that with the quality of what the Echo Project puts out, they definitely could be charging and that would be totally understandable. However, the stories they come up with are so good that I really appreciate how accessible it is to everyone. They make it so that anyone slightly interested can still enjoy their stories. They really need to make their own website so they don’t have to have all their games on itch.io. It would be really cool to see all their projects, updates, and community comments in once place.

3
yaxom•

Knowing how much I enjoyed it? Yes. Would I have paid for it before I played it? Probably not.

3
PatrokManzanaOwO What’s This?:linclean:•

No but I would support them

2
Outside-Log5887•

Personally I think that they are comparable to a triple A game price of like 50 or 60 dollars. But in reality if they ever did put out a release for people to buy as a collection or if they did like a remaster with more cgs or voice acting it could maybe be more reasonable for it to actually happen. I do think that the accessibility is very important for its success since if I had not been able to play it from build to build (its why i have been a patreon from near the beginning) and see the story/characters and even the writers/artist evolve it would not be as beloved as it is in the community.

1
targea_caramar•

I'm actually thinking of becoming a patron once I have the money. I almost feel bad for getting that amount of quality material for free, too (although I think they did the right thing by allowing payment to be voluntary)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
broccolibear1•

Realistically, I would think lots of folks would just start finding ways of sharing the games with each other (aka stealing) if there was much of a price tag. That's kinda the reality for some digital goods, especially considering the subject material. There are furs who for sure throw money at the fandom, but for many it's more or less a hobby they engage in for free.

I think the honor system we have set up for online content creators works pretty good. The content is free for all to enjoy, but if you like it and can afford it you can donate or subscribe to their patreon or twitch or whatever their platform may be. They've got like 2000 patreon supporters so clearly people are willing to pay out of their own volition.

Would I personally pay for it? Not right now, maybe when I have more spare money.

1
07ShadowGuardScalie Household•

Subscribe to their Patreon if you really like their work and want to see them do more.

1
BigBaraLover•

Honestly, I think I would pay at best $5, there isn't enough quality to pay over $10. I mean, I'm not fucking paying $25 for Knight College, but the art, the music and the multiple languages at least try to compensate.

Echo lacks good art, good sprite work, good background, good use of music and others when compared to professional games. Yeah, the writting is definitely better than Knight College (minus Jenna's route).

Adastra I would say it could reach $10, still a bit overpriced for such a short game with bad writing.

Then, The Smoke Room, the only good game from EchoProject (it doesn't include Howly as a main writer, so curious). I think this one could reach $20, depends on how the writing goes.

-2†