Spending WC coins this event in hindsight (non spender)

Discussion

Hi All,

Just wanted to share my experience now that I'm done with this event, for those who may still be deciding whether to splash their WCs here. It's hard to know if I got lucky or unlucky cause IH didn't really specify the reward % but let's assume this is average luck:

Total gem spend 38,700 gems:

  • 21 pick axes to get to the 5* selection box - 2100 gems
  • 3 loops of WC so 720 WC -take out 7 mandatory daily = 713 WCs - Here I assume 30 gems each to replenish the stock pile asap (market rate, aspen store 2, 3. aspen store 3 is 25 gems each but let's be conservative) - 21390 gems
  • all 3 meat boxes - 15000 gems

Total gain based on how I value each:

  • 12 orbs - 0 gem ROFL who needs orb these days
  • 15 HS - 1875 gems
  • 6 core - 9000 gems
  • 40 relics - 2000 gems
  • 3 basic skin - 600 gems (I price purple skin at around 1000 gems each)
  • CI mats - I price 300k CI mats as 4500 gems (150 gems per 10k mat) based on the fact that I am willing to buy all extra duces to get the 230 box at Imp's adventure. However, I have excess of iron ingot and toolbox so 0 gem for those. Obviously we get extra stuff with Imp but it's not very often we can get to 230 stars without spending so arguably there is a premium for getting them faster
  1. 140k wood - 2100 gems
  2. 130k rock - 1950 gems
  3. 120k ingot - 0 gem
  4. 110k shard - 1650 gems
  5. 70k toolbox - 0 gem
  6. 2400 fine wood - 0 gem (not much value to me)
  7. 2400 hard rock - 0 gem (not much value to me)
  • 12 5* fodder - 3000 gems (250 ea)
  • skin from hitting 100 tribute - 1000 gems
  • glory box for hitting 200 tribute - 500 gems (I dont value this too much but 500 gems might be underestimating it)

Building residences:

I ended up finishing 10 island buildings and I chose the following rewards. With these, I have just enough points to reach the break require to boost gem production from 50 to 60 (once my statue is max which should take another short trip)

  • 4x 6* (+800 points) - 6000 gems
  • 2x 100k wood (+300 points) - 3000 gems
  • 2x 100k rock (+300 points) - 3000 gems
  • 2x 100k shard (+300 points) - 3000 gems

and I managed 1 residence building which I chose the SS mat.

Overall, I spent 38,490 gems and get 38,675 gems back + SS mat and 20 bonus gems per day

It would take me just short of 2 months to build the WC stock back (assuming 8 a day at market and 20 available for gems per aspen dungeon).

But wait, we will get part of that without spending any gems so we have to break it down further. If I extrapolate based on tributes gained, the break looks a bit like below:

Options to spend gem for best value to worst

With the latest change to imp and campaign drop event, I would say you could price the SS mat at around 5000 gems (assuming 20k gems for arti and a 4:1 ratio). So I lost about 8000 - 5000 = 3000 gems in opportunity cost. which will take roughly 150 days to break even.

TL;DR - the event is decent, but not overly good compared to some other events in the last 12 months.

Posted May 19, 2022, 8:47 AM UTC

2910
LightaxL•

I think this was a fantastic event if you can hit the 300 tribute for the artifact, and had the coins available.

I like your breakdown, but I think i give far more value to the CI mats than you.

If there was a way I could buy 5 red SS mats for 10k, I would.

If I could buy 100k wood/rock for 3k, I probably would too.

My bottle neck for getting stronger is my tenant levels, SS levels, and stellar shards. So anything that can increase those I value really highly.

9
ReRedditditOP•

Yea I try to be conservative with gems value. Po for example should have some residue values even if nobody needs them because you can still get fodder, core, relics, regression stone for doing a loop even if there's 0 extra reward.

4
[deleted]•

I figure PO are worth 153, just for fodder value during a normal event.

2
cathyouyou•

I still can't decide. I wanted to wait till last day. I have the coins, but with little to nothing extra. As f2p I don't think over buy WC every day it's a safe bet. More and more gems are needed this days, and anniversary is really close. I just used the 66 you get anyway . 550 more prosperity. I thin that's enough

2
Kadios77•

I bought all the meat I could, got to the amour box for pickaxe event, 100 WC short of completing the max 9 loops and i ended 2 stone short to complete final house to get that free artifact chest. Darn it, my acc has always been jinxed!

2
Budulai740•

It was a hard decision between the table and the market for me, because I'd value that table chest as 20k gems. But decided that ci mats for halora's slot are a better choice for me. Residence slot skin is actually what makes this event pretty. But most of all I enjoyed watching a dragon shit with bricks.

1
ReRedditditOP•

ROFL.. Yea the same took me a few days to decide. Ultimately I hope they will make the choices easier in future skin events so decide to take the reward now instead of the better house..

3
Jhyphi•

Spring well is a good middle ground. Buffs trans tenant spot and also 70 relics.

1
Budulai740•

I don't have an Asmodel yet and might need that slot not earlier than September.

1
uh123abcde•

if ur f2p(non spender) those relics are way way undervalued. at that rate a p2w arti is 20k or less during events.

1