Trapped_in_Reddit•

Posted by u/syri4u, a 5 day old account . . .

Every day sublestern's theory on the military's use of reddit seems more and more belieavable to me.

1.3K
stanfan114•

I've been saying this from day one but just get referred to conspiracy subreddits.

260
Trapped_in_Reddit•

When it was first posted, I thought sublestern's tin foil hat was on too tight. Then I started to actually pay attention, and it's become a bit more believable. How can we test it? What observations would we expect to see if it were true?

173
Sleepy_One•

I've started just always checking the content of an account a bit when I see an overly patriotic or ridiculous post that is pro or anti corporation.

88
[deleted]•

Also notice that these posters never address these accusations and never comment within the comment thread of their own posts.

103
1Ender•

Theres also pictures of movie props showing up every few weeks so keep that in mind as well.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
winteriscoming2•

You are wasting your time because those are just political posts. Who is going to pay someone to run around and be "pro-corporate". If you see someone who is zealously pro-XYZ corporation then you might be onto something, especially if XYZ corporation has a poor reputation and is in an industry that does not attract private fans. For example, if you see someone zealously defending Monsanto they might be a shill, but it is unlikely that someone zealously defending GM is, because many people are zealous about their car choices. Even if you meet these criteria will get more false positives than anything else.

-3
stanfan114•

Profiling and investigating individual accounts. There must be a process for detecting sock-puppet accounts, and it sounds like there may even be some kind of blueprint on how to manipulate social networking sites. Look at that and find similar patterns here.

Other than that, just remember not everybody has your best interests in mind even on Reddit.

25
[deleted]•

I have noticed a select few people post links to fallen soldiers in r/politics. They always get down voted though. Perhaps something else to investigate as well.

Also, let's blame this on karmanaut.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
[deleted]•

If i were not too wise but not too stupid and i was creating an account on here to spam something and wanted to look real, I would probably post a few links first. Just like OP. However notice that the 4 videos she posted are stuff that would probably show up in a youtube search for "amazing" or something stupid like that. they're stupid typical videos that reek of trying to fit in. Here's the clincher for me anyway:

third and fourth videos posted by OP are related. click the bell video and in the related videos is the carrots vid. obviously these were found at the same time. but posted 3 days apart. why? to appear to be a normal user, not a spammer filling their account. 5 videos in one hour then an army video looks obvious, especially after the feedback on all the other armyfeelgood videos. the video is lame. not good enough to come back 3 days after clicking it and submit it to reddit for downvotes.

look here.

5
giveitago•

Here's another one of these, http://www.reddit.com/user/bannerflags.

2
Rnad•

I've noticed it as well. People with controversial posts or pro military posts will often have their account active for a really short period of time. Imo this could be because of one of two reasons, that they were excited to finally able to contribute to the reddit community, and by extention forced to create an account. Or the government is flooding pro-war propaganda to lessen the frightful image of serving one's country. Either way, I believe the latter since propaganda has always existed, and since they aren't allowed to advertise on campus grounds anymore, how else are they going to reach the younger generations?

2

I thought the foil was cooking sublestern's head for a while too until I visited syri4u's profile. All of the videos, and they are mostly videos, are "repostable" material that would see reddit's pages every now and then and get a good amount of karma.

Some questions:

Why would the author of the video use a watermark from a Dutch video-sharing website, including a link from LiveLeak?

How is his/her/it's commenting style connected to their posts?

2
Aldrnari•

Tin foil hats don't work anymore, not since they replaced all of our tin foil with aluminum foil... O.o

2
kaiise•

ive been watching reddit from day 1 and i am a wide subscriber to a lot of sub reddits. compulsion.

r/mil used to have 1 post a week and rest of reddit was quite anti war.

2
conluceo•

Upvote for good scientific method.

1
Chris_the_mudkip•

We need to get a crack team of hackers. A few hours of typing set to the inception theme and we'll have our answer.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
BallsackTBaghard•

Somebody has to take screenshots and keeping a journal.

I am too lazy to do it.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
SombreDusk•

The problem is the military will learn and adapt sooner or later we need to get the Vietcong to help us fight them guerilla style!

-7
Trapped_in_Reddit•

Right. Like they'll learn to somehow weaponize karma and some mystery account will come along and end up with a half-million karma in two months or something crazy like that.

8
claychastain•

Well, there are a lot of us military types cruising Reddit on our downtime. r/military is pretty lively with this sort of thing. Doesn't seem to be much of a conspiracy. So many posts are just one hit wonder style things. I mean, shit, my dog went nuts when I came back home too. That said she is a fat chihuahua so she just waddled into my arms.

38
Ass_Dragon•

Yes, but what's weird is that the ones who are successful always come from brand new users with very few submissions and comments. Anyone can be a "one hit wonder" with submissions. What is odd is that they are so successful right out of the gate with very similar video content.

EDIT: Also, the users often delete the accounts shortly after.

16
claychastain•

True, doing a little more research into it, it is sketchy. How does that even... promote the military in any way though? I mean, if anything, it heightens the separation of people from the ones they love, animals or people. Seems like they should be covertly giving Redditors information on soft IT jobs and things that would appeal to them.

0
Randamba•

Hey, I'm in the navy too! Unfortunately I owned a demon cat at the time when I came home from deployment, so she ignored me for a while and bit my hand.

3
claychastain•

Cats just don't have that same connection that dogs do. Our last cat was a demon that lived 19 long years.

2

Can someone explain to me how this helps the military?

I guess it makes soldiers seem more relatable. But when I see these videos, what comes to mind is how sad it is that a daughter and father, or dog and owner, had to be separated from each other for so long.

35
Darkstrategy•

As someone who takes this video at face value without worrying about the underlying intentions in why it was posted, I'll play devil's advocate to you.

It provides an image of a healthy strong woman in uniform coming back to a loving family in a nice home and able to share the simple love between a human and a dog.

The reality is many of our soldiers if they survive combat areas come back either physically or emotionally scarred. They aren't paid well for their services, and most jobs irregardless of rules surrounding it tend to dump those going on leave if possible. Many stories of loved ones moving on while they're gone for long periods of time. And a host of other issues that returning soldiers face with little to no support system in place for them.

Edit: To those with issues of my use of "irregardless" - it's a part of the English language. It wasn't once, it is now, languages change. They use the term "dead" when talking of unspoken languages for a reason, because "live" languages evolve and grow; they aren't static. I love the English language, and it shows in the areas I've chosen to study, but I'm not afraid to embrace the new.

124
infiniteslinky•

Seems to me you're correct. Seems like psychological and emotional manipulation to associate good feelings with uniforms.

26
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7†
dumtardo•

It's a double negative and makes no sense. Just because enough morons abused it to have found its way into a dictionary doesn't make it a word that ought to be used. You shizzling my wizzle? Don't be a dumbass and promote dumbassery.

6
Triviaandwordplay•

If there was some sort of conspiracy associated with this account, it'd be more likely that it's to build karma so the account can be sold. http://ultratonfist.com/sell-us-your-reddit-accounts/

A number of entities will buy established reddit accounts.

2
unknownSubscriber•

irregardless

1
Jspiral•

Irregardless certainly is a word, however, the online dictionaries make no bones about the person who uses such a word catching shit for it. But alas, this is the internet and none of us should feel like we're writing some sort of dissertation when posting on social websites. I do find it immensely amusing how we all resort to educated speak when we get in arguments online though. lol

1
androph•

irregardless ಠ_ಠ

-1
foobiscuit•

I loved every minute I was in the Air Force. I kind of wish I didn't get out.

-3
electrikmayhem•

I had to downvote you for "irregardless". Sorry.

-20
agrey•

It helps thin out the reports of the military behaving badly.

usually when the military is discussed here, we hear about some new human rights abuses, or we learn that women in the military are more likely to be raped by their comrades than they are to be shot by the enemy. Or how more soldiers commit suicide than are killed in combat.

So you get these diabetes-inducing saccharine sweet heartwarming videos of returning soldiers to loving families and it helps temper out the bad stuff.

Myself, I downvote 'em. Seen one, seen them all. They don't really add anything to the conversation.

8
MisterFanBlades•

The military doesn't behave "badly." They behave exactly as they are supposed to. They are puppets who have gone through TRAINING to willingly become tools of death. They RAPE because they're trained to do so, they MURDER because they're told to do so. These posts are propaganda designed to trick us into thinking soldiers are people, when in reality they are sheep trained to destroy all that humanity has to offer.

-8
fuzzo•

soldier in the field, i.e., locked up in a compound when not out risking his hide on patrol will think this video is heaven. that's how it helps the military. do you think reddit is not popular with military?

3
pomel•

Suicide reate among U.S. Soldiers You can get heart-touched by a soldier coming home, but not realice you are actually losing the war and soldiers killing themselfs. War Propaganda, it helps the people think good about your military and not question they'r actions. Sorry about the grammar.

2
allie_sin•

You'd be surprised at the crazy bullshit they try http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stargate_Project

1
peckx063•

It really has nothing to do with the military at all. In the simplest way I can put it, Uploader puts link on reddit, a few other accounts upvote it, builds traction on reddit, hits frontpage, gets tons of views, uploader gets tons of advertisement money. It has nothing to do with military propoganda, it just turns out troop-coming-home videos are pretty compelling and universally liked.

-5
Snoogliebear•

This makes me want to join the military...

4
DeathHamsterDude•

Yvan eht nioj! Yvan eht nioj!

40
mrbugle81•

Its a 3 prong attack, you've got Subliminal, liminal and superliminal.

"Superliminal?"

"I'll show you, hey you! Join the Navy!!"

5
Idocreating•

Give him a minute, he's probably offline. I'll send him a text, what do you want him for?

1
opaleyedragon•

All it makes me think is how sad it is to be separated from family.

6
Grande_Yarbles•

You have been assigned to the elite Reddit squad. Your duty, if you are man enough to handle it, is to sit on Reddit all day long and occasionally submit heart-warming links.

2†
verik•

Your mission, should you accept it, is to browse nothing but AllReddit's new page.

1
tophergz•

Go Air Force. Staff Sergeant (rank in vid) is the start of the sweet life. Get a commission if you can.

-1
MisterFanBlades•

DON'T. Are you really swayed that much by propaganda? You really want to become a murderer of innocent children?

-3
Snoogliebear•

Not every soldier is a corrupt soldier. Some of those men and women have seen shit that you will never see in your life. Their innocence has been murdered too.

1
executex•

To the tin foil hat people that talk about how US army might be sending these posts out to recruit soldiers??!?!?!?!...

If anything this is a Ron Paul campaign move, to convince people that the war needs to end because poor dogs and parents are not happy when their loved ones go to war. Ron Paul's campaign has been from the start, to make it seem like as if all soldiers vote for Ron Paul because they want wars to end. His campaign has maneuvered itself to paint Obama and Mitt Romney as war mongers, and himself as someone who is pro-peace and sympathetic to soldiers plight. So these videos only profit him, they don't encourage recruitment at all...

This seems like a more plausible theory to me, then the US army spreading a propaganda message by reminding people that soldiers have families and miss them a lot when they go to war.

-7
SgtBanana•

Ron Paul? This campaign is far too vague and uncoordinated to be in support of any particular politician. In fact, it's kind of curious that you would blame a specific person. He's never, ever mentioned in the post titles, or by the OPs. Also, the sock puppet account names never allude to politics, or anything in particular. The only consistent thing linking these sock puppet accounts is the nature of the posts.

If this is indeed a pro-military campaign, the goal is to glorify soldiers and soften views towards the military. Reddit's main demographic is within the 16-25 year old range, which is exactly what the military is looking for. This is the only community on the internet that has both a consistent demographic age range, and a gigantic number of unique users. (Yes, Reddit makes it's unique user count view-able to whoever wants to see it, which makes this site a prime advertising platform)

If this were a pro-Ron Paul campaign, it would purely consist of posted articles that directly reference Ron Paul. It wouldn't just be a mild allusion to one subject that a politician talks about from time to time. You're clearly the tin foil hat person in this thread for pulling that wild conclusion out of your ass.

1
wheresmyhouse•

The matter is starting to get a lot more mainstream attention.

1
83A27_M0D3•

YVAN EHT NIOJ

98
ndcj12•

"Otto! What are you doing?"

"I dunno. I just got an urge to join the Navy."

"You're being brainwashed!"

"Yeah, probably. Yvan eht nioj!"

24
[deleted]•

Did you notice how the "welcome back" sign on the door was backwards? Dun-dun!

1
daanavitch•

This'll surely make the front page once again.

Edit: It just did…

47
tankosaurus•

Hey I liked the video... to be honest I don't care if it's propaganda..... It's a cool doggie.

23
Sevsquad•

yeah honestly the reasons these get upvoted isn't because of some grand military conspiracy. It's because regardless of your views on the military things like this are rather touching.

edit: I guess pointing out that something can be touching regardless of whether or not it was posted by a military spokesperson is the exact wrong thing to say on reddit.

10
Heylooloooo•

You use the word honestly like you think it makes opinions facts.

25
iluvzpuppehs•

People take things a little too seriously here, sometimes. It was a cute video. I rolled my eyes when seeing the first comments here were about conspiracies and military propaganda. Yep, okay.

2
Badong11•

And such a BRAVE female soldier! God bless her!

-12
cyberslick188•

SO BRAVE!

YVAN EHT NIOJ

YVAN EHT NIOJ

YVAN EHT NIOJ

YVAN EHT NIOJ

YVAN EHT NIOJ

14
melancholymelon•

Yeah! They are the bravest one's over there because they have to deal with this shit too. " According to several studies of the US military funded by the Department of Veteran Affairs, 30% of military women are raped while serving, 71% are sexually assaulted, and 90% are sexually harassed." Brave doesn't say it all. Why are there no videos made by burner accounts about this?

2
capitandorko•

Yes, this group is very good at getting videos to the front page here: http://welcomehomeblog.com/

More on it here: http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/t6pqc/man_absolutely_floored_by_the_return_of_his/c4kbrnr

That whole thread is a actually a pretty good sleuth read.

3
[deleted]•

Damn it, reddit. For a community that vies itself on skepticism and rationality, you sure are quick to jump on the nearest conspiritorial bandwagon.

You can't look at 2 or 3 three submissions and proclaim the evil-american-military-propoganda-machine is out to get you. Even if you could produce more than three, you would have to compare it to other coming home videos. Furthermore, you would need to compare it to the life of reddit common accounts--not everyone is a 24/7 reddit neckbeard.

From a few seconds of searching..

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/nol5o/little_girl_tells_santa_she_wants_dad_home_from/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/mkx7j/dog_completely_ecstatic_to_see_owner_return_from/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/t4g9c/loyal_dog_returns_back_to_owner_after_deployment/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/l5q8m/us_army_dad_home_from_iraq_surprises_children_at/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/a3n1i/soldier_finds_an_abandoned_puppy_in_iraq_lives/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/nshzw/the_best_christmas_present_ever_girl_tells_santa/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/nqvg2/girl_tells_santa_she_wants_dad_home_from_iraq/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/6uwoc/home_from_iraq_sleep_is_now_the_enemy_for_veterans/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/nqb3c/girl_tells_santa_she_wants_dad_home_from_iraq/

http://www.reddit.com/r/videos/comments/nlgsa/father_comes_home_from_iraq_and_surprises_his/

..it's fucking obvious this "theory" is confirmation bias. Not all accounts are new. Not everyone who submits these videos delete their account. There is absolutely no evidence to suggest there is some massive conspiracy behind people submitting videos to reddit.

for my sanity, I'm going to think Trapped_in_Reddit doesn't really think this. I'm going to say he made this account so he could, in time, raep the karma. r/KarmaConspiracy guies. If you're going to believe nonsense, maybe you can believe my claims?

45
pseudolobster•

This is a very widespread occurrence. It happens very, very often. Reddit is generally very anti-war, but sometimes we see unusual amounts of support for the troops in a way that feels manipulated or gamed, like hundreds of votes within a five minute period then the voting stops altogether, etc.

It really does seem like there's a whitewashing / astroturfing PR campaign by the US military here. Americans only make up 60% of the users, but have you ever, even once, seen a user from another country glorifying their own military? There should really be 40% as many pro-military posts for non-US redditors.

There have been many discussions about this, and many redditors agree something weird is going on with all these chest thumping flag waving insanely pro-military pro-war submissions that seem to pop up like clockwork.

Here's another discussion about this: http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/ukpfl/is_reddit_being_manipulated_by_the_us_army/

26
[deleted]•

Few points. If you're going only off the most popular submissions, the observation is going to be skewed towards the Americans. There are so many spots and it's not going to be proportionally given to every country. If 5% of reddit is Indian, 5% of the spots aren't going to be given to them. There aren't enough Indians to breakthrough reddit's algorithm to be noticed, unless it's within their specific subreddit, and I'm sure we don't have any knowledge of these potential posts. It would create a confirmation bias.

Secondly, Americans are generally more adorned to their military. This is compounded with the first point. Not only are Americans more able to push their military, but it would seem they're more likely to comment, submit articles, and upvote.

Third, you have to consider the number of Americans who are at war. With point one and two, this would only further skew the results.

I've read that TOR post, and there isn't any evidence. There is speculation from news articles and an observation of these occurances, but people are still operating on selective evidence.

8
kbox•

In subreddits about specific countries, where the userbase is made up by nearly all non-US redditors, you still don't find these posts.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kaiise•

it's one of the reasons i left reddit

1
TakeFourSeconds•

how has it been going for you?

5
HelloMcFly•

Personally I don't find troops returning to their dogs to be pro-military. Reddit likes animals (a lot), and that is first and foremost an animal video.

Also, Americans in general are much more supportive of troops (regardless of the conflict) ever since what we as a society did to the vets of Vietnam.

0
FilterOutBullshit3•

I don't see how these videos aren't anti-war. Isn't it anti-war to post videos that campaign for recalling the troops from foreign territories? If I were forced to point to a country that could be strategically posting these videos for psi-ops purposes, I would think Russia or Iran.

-2
seabass101dg•

Reddit wishes it was important enought to warrant the attention of the government. Reddit isn't as special as it thinks it is.

10
kbox•

It's the 52nd most visited website in America, according to Alexa, and the videos sub is subscribed to by 1.5 million people.

10
zHellas•

I think that if you want to use pro-military propaganda, you'd focus on the top 51 most visited websites.

-1
rogercaptain•

Reddit is plenty important enough to be the target of a viral marketing campaign. It's not about being special, it's about being able to reach a large internet audience. And I don't think a viral marketing campaign by the military would be very controversial; the military advertises in all sorts of ways, and I don't think people would think this is crossing the line for being too deceptive.

I'm not saying that any pro-military post on Reddit is necessarily posted by the military. But Reddit not being important enough is a silly reason to dismiss the possibility.

4
pseudolobster•

And I don't think a viral marketing campaign by the military would be very controversial; the military advertises in all sorts of ways, and I don't think people would think this is crossing the line for being too deceptive

Honestly this scares me. I agree with you. I don't think anyone would be too opposed to this, and that's what scares me.

You see movies about East Germany and you laugh at the Stasi's propaganda campaigns, thinking today's informed populace couldn't fall for that, but educate from an early age the military is a vitally important public service that does honourable things, and you get people eating it up with a spoon thinking this is the best way to advance as a country - by domination.

5
[deleted]•

The UK pledged something like 3billion last year to it's online crimes unit.

Intelligence gathering about large communities such as reddit will be happening.

The 'hivemind', will have been structured and developed. Although not by government, more by marketing companies.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

A lot of videos get submitted to reddit, a lot of people are in the military, and a lot of people are on reddit. It's only weird or mysterious if you focus on a few instances while completely ignore everything else.

People want to believe in this conspiracy, and if that means selectively picking your evidence, then they're going to do that. I would like to think it's a joke, but people are obviously having faith in this assertion.

2
UpGoaTedThis•

Last post that'll be made from this account, just watch.

38
dmagee33•

First post was on a video where the OP is deleted, and syri4u clearly knows more about the video than the average person should.

1
eric22vhs•

It sounds conspiracy-theory as hell because it's the military; but in reality, it's no different than what just about every company on the planet does.

18
government_shill•

Difference being the military doing that would be thoroughly illegal.

0
eric22vhs•

Really? How so?

0
government_shill•

Annual appropriations bills (most recently the 2012 Consolidated Appropriations Act) bar the military from engaging in covert domestic propaganda. Other legislation such as the Smith-Mundt (sp?) Act also restrict the government's domestic public communications.

4
marmz111•

Has anyone actually stopped and thought about it for a second from the military POV?

These guys are told to keep everything military related away from social media, and also if I was a returning soldier, I wouldn't want to use my actual Reddit account in case it is found out by command and they drill my ass.

I think this has more to do with procedures they have in place in regards to social media and privacy than anything else.

Still doesn't explain why they leave no comments, and delete their accounts however... just trying to give a reasonable explanation for it.

Edit: BTW the user who submitted this post has posted other videos and comments.

17
well_golly•

Yes, and they are disguising their identities by using throwaway accounts ... and then showing their names, their ranks, their uniforms (branch of service and various patches), and the outside of their homes in their videos.

The throwaways are clearly not being used to "pull one over on the uptight military establishment" and circumvent some military policy against posting personal stuff on social media.

37
prattle•

They are showing their names, their ranks, and their uniforms, but not revealing any of their other various opinions and comings and goings. If you create an account that is not tied to you in any way so that you can say whatever you want, is it not just as logical that if you had an account that was obviously tied to you, it would be best to say as little as possible?

I've never had a desire to post something as revealing as this, but if I did, it seems like the obvious way to do it would be to have an account dedicated for the purpose.

5
[deleted]•

Active Duty Air Force here. The military is embracing social media, the only real information frowned upon is OPSEC violations including travel itineraries, specific locations of training or mission events, and time frames -- or certain unprofessional acts in uniform and even further, embracing political parties or candidates in uniform.

No one on active duty is going to get in trouble for posting these videos. There is an entire TV show dedicated to shit like this.

edit: Also, reddit isn't blocked on gov computers. I browse regularly from work.

17
lolmonger•

Still doesn't explain why they leave no comments, and delete their accounts however... just trying to give a reasonable explanation for it.

It does.

The military, at least the American military, does not want any uniformed or active duty personnel giving out their personal take on wartime service, wartime duties, etc. etc.

The military has spokespeople for that, and they do not want any personal projection or biases to in any way compromise the Armed Forces.

The most known consequence of that policy is that political endorsement while active (especially wearing a uniform) is totally not okay.

These accounts posting and then deleting are likely service members or people connected to service members getting cold feet.

12
well_golly•

The service member in this and almost every other video of this nature is very clearly identifiable.

10
lolmonger•

Sure, but not that they posted the video.

It's totally fine for your spouse to do whatever they want, and as far as the Air Force knows, that's what happened.

1
Jerkfish•

The military has spokespeople for that, and they do not want any personal projection or biases to in any way compromise the Armed Forces.

If the poster honestly wanted to follow that rule they wouldn't be posting the video in the first place.

4
lolmonger•

Probably why they went for the halfway compromise of posting and deleting.

2
0311•

Those policies would not apply to this video. The military doesn't give a shit if you post a video of your homecoming online.

4
lolmonger•

Probably not, but considering all the bullshit they do give a shit about, it wouldn't surprise me if the original uploader was just being cautious.

2
BahamutSalad•

The military has spokespeople for that

That doesn't mean they can't do this as an advertising campaign. If anything the people running such a campaign would qualify as said spokespeople.

2
ForUrsula•

That also doesnt explain why the accounts try to pretend they are real though. If they were an actual redditor, they would know the theory, and know the top comment on their post is going to be saying their video is a PR stunt. If it were a redditor they would know that a 1 day old account looks just as bad as a 5 day old account, so why bother? Just to continue that line of discussion.

3
omnilynx•

I'm an actual redditor and I never heard of the theory before today.

4
ForUrsula•

Its been mentioned in the comments on every single post of this nature for a while now.

4
motivation150•
17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
motivation150•

Glad I'm not the only one!

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
aletoledo•

Seriously. I hold a lot of conspiracy theories, but I felt this type of theory could be dismissed as simple minded nationalism. The more and more this happens though, the evidence starts to pile up that it is indeed marketing.

5
skakruk•

What? This was solved the first day some user posted his observation. It's undeniable, I don't even know how reddit is still debating over this, it already is fucking clear. Propaganda.

I'm conflicted, should I upvote this for being so adorable, or should I downvote it to discourage propagandistic use of reddit?

-3
Prathik•

I dont think its propaganda, I think its a dude or a bunch of dudes promoting their website, the welcomehomeblog thing.

2
aletoledo•

I downvote them all for the propaganda, but I never realized the debate was over on this. I saw the original topic, but I guess I didn't read all the same comments that you did. I think I recall one person saying that we shouldn't attribute to malice what can be explained by stupidity. America is a country of sheep after all, so one of those sheep might just be looking to stand out from the flock.

Personally I looked at someones submission history that posted one of these videos and it seemed like he had a regular history, with only one other patriotic marketing submission out of at least a dozen. Sure maybe the marketing is so complete that they're developing fact covers for their reddit accounts, but that seems to stretch my belief that it's worth that much to market in this format. Though "viral" campaigns are what the new generation of marketers is after.

For example look at the submission history of the OP. He has other videos, are those just a cover story?

-1
facelessace•

Next question: could a dog be trained to do that?

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
angrybane•

She had to have bacon in her hair and smeared all over her face

1
[deleted]•

If the alternative is anti-war people countering with lots of "He did not return, the family goes nuts" videos, then I would rather have this.

3†
nonhiphipster•

Very interesting, and worth noting. Although it probably is nothing more than a very pro-military redditor making many accounts in order to get his message across of 'support the troops,' etc.

Personally, I don't have anything against that. Plus, if you hate this video, I don't really want to know you in the first place.

3
Jonas223XC•

People should not look at videos like this and think "I should be supporting our government more", as that theory suggests that we should. What you should take away from videos like this is "I should be supporting our troops more." There's a huge difference

3
howisthisnottaken•

Guns don't kill people, people kill people. The government doesn't go to war soldiers go to war. No soldiers, no war. Say what you want about a draft but America would wage less war if they had less volunteers.

Supporting the troops = supporting the government. Anyone who would pretend it's not lies to themselves in hopes they'll believe it.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
howisthisnottaken•

What I said:

America would wage less war if they had less volunteers.

What you said:

Are you kidding me? No soldiers=no war?

The two have nothing to do with each other.

In the Early 1930s Smedley Butler, who had pretty strong knowledge of war stated: War is a racket

I spent 33 years and four months in active military service and during that period I spent most of my time as a high class muscle man for Big Business, for Wall Street and the bankers. In short, I was a racketeer, a gangster for capitalism. I helped make Mexico and especially Tampico safe for American oil interests in 1914. I helped make Haiti and Cuba a decent place for the National City Bank boys to collect revenues in. I helped in the raping of half a dozen Central American republics for the benefit of Wall Street. I helped purify Nicaragua for the International Banking House of Brown Brothers in 1902-1912. I brought light to the Dominican Republic for the American sugar interests in 1916. I helped make Honduras right for the American fruit companies in 1903. In China in 1927 I helped see to it that Standard Oil went on its way unmolested. Looking back on it, I might have given Al Capone a few hints. The best he could do was to operate his racket in three districts. I operated on three continents.

What did he suggest?

  1. Making war unprofitable. Butler suggests that the owners of capital should be "conscripted" before other citizens are: "It can be smashed effectively only by taking the profit out of war. The only way to smash this racket is to conscript capital and industry and labour before the nation's manhood can be conscripted. … Let the officers and the directors and the high-powered executives of our armament factories and our steel companies and our munitions makers and our ship-builders and our airplane builders and the manufacturers of all other things that provide profit in war time as well as the bankers and the speculators, be conscripted — to get $30 a month, the same wage as the lads in the trenches get"
  1. Acts of war to be decided by those who fight it. He also suggests a limited plebiscite to determine if the war is to be fought. Eligible to vote would be those who risk death on the front lines.
  1. Limitation of militaries to self-defence. For the United States, Butler recommends that the navy be limited, by law, to within 200 miles of the coastline, and the army restricted to the territorial limits of the country, ensuring that war, if fought, can never be one of aggression.

I fully support the entirety of these ideas. The idea that people join and don't know what the military has historically been doing cannot be used as an excuse. The U.S. military hasn't been defending shit in the past 50 years other than corporate interests. Frankly other than the deviations into the World Wars they haven't been interested in doing what's right for a long time prior to that according to Smedley Butler.

I don't support the regular military any more than I do the mercenaries of (Xe, Academi, Blackwater etc). They have been bought for a price and that's a choice they made. Sure the regular military mercenaries make less than the better paid mercenaries but they are all mercenaries.

Troops are Americans who have volunteered their lives in order to get a steady pay, a place to sleep, reliable meals,

If you think your life is worth so little, then fine but that's a choice. I didn't ask anyone to go. I didn't sign any contracts with them. The military contracts are between the government and the soldier. Those are the only two parties to that contract. Since I have nothing to do with it I bear no responsibility. Since I bear no responsibility I shed no tears.

Being an arsonist is likely scary but we don't call them heroes. If you want to wage "preemptive war" don't pretend that you bear no responsibility for the outcomes.

Preemptive war is a lot like arson, someone has to strike that match. The only honor is in putting out the fire which falls to different hands.

-2
prattle•

I don't think it is that odd that people use throw away accounts for certain postings. It helps maintain anonymity. If your pictures were attached to Trapped_in_Reddit account in some way, would you still want to use it the way you do?

3
sapo916•

0 comment karma does it for me. These accounts getting front page posts with all of them having 0 comment karma. OKKAYY

3
[deleted]•

do you realise that sublestern hasn't been online for 22 days? do you think he was killed for asking questions?

3
lasershurt•

Soldiers, so far this year, are committing suicide at a rate of about 1 a day. If this is propaganda, it's not "join the army!" propaganda, it's "Please feel better and don't kill yourself" propaganda.

At least that's my guess.

2
MisterFanBlades•

More soldiers need to do this. They WILLINGLY invaded a country, rape everyone in sight and murder the witnesses.

Why the downvotes? Man, Reddit has become ARMY-WORSHIP central. get a fucking clue

-10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
MisterFanBlades•

Oh? So the murders signed up to do something other than murder innocents... I get it. Was it because the victims happen to be brown?

-3
walking_away_•

I had a few soldiers recruit at my school, and I ended up hitting it off with one of them and had a few nice talks. He said the military always ups their recruitment and advertisements. In my opinion, it is a military use of the internet to either get more recruits or to bring up the citizens view of the military, and morale in general.

IMHO, it is not a wrong thing to do. Most celebs who decide to do an IAMA also talk of whatever they are doing currently and try to get people to check those things out.

I am not completely bothered by it. Even if the video was a fake, I would still cry... I mean chop onions.

2
brazilliandanny•

Here's [another one on the front page of r/pics](http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/ut3m4/my_buddy_took_this_photo_of_our_last_48_hour/)

Although the posters account is 9 months old 90% of his posts and comments are related to the military

Don't get me wrong we all post about our jobs and interests, I just find it difficult to believe that a legitimate redditor would have at least a few other comments on unrelated matter.

2
rh3ss•

You should take of your tinfoil hat. This does not benefit the military at all.

Also note, that this is a personal video (identifies the people's faces). Many people may want to share this video, but they don't want it to affect their other comments.

For example, if they made a comment that some may view offensive, someone can just go through their history and then complain with the military.

I would never post any video of me, with my account, identifying my employer -- more so if I was in the military. I would share from an anonymized account though.

2
ordinaryrendition•

Are you kidding me? Look up any US military thread and count the number of "thank you for your service" comments you see. This absolutely glorifies the US military, and by extension, their goals.

12
deprivedchild•

The 'Thank you for your service' part doesn't have anything within it's context to say whether someone is pro or anti-war. By your logic, whenever we say Merry Christmas, we glorify Santa and giving gifts to everyone.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
awiservoice•

No way. To me, this video is about the unforgetting love of a dog...not about the military. I support our troops. I don't support our wars. To think a video like this is "glorifying" our wars in the middle east is an absolute stretch.

1
ordinaryrendition•

The video is great, but it's not the content of the video that's off issue. It's that we suspect they are being used for manipulation purposes. I generally hate conspiracy theories, but I'm also becoming suspicious that this isn't happening by mere chance anymore.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
throweraccount•

I don't get it, why would it be a positive thing that Amanda was taken away from her loved ones only to be returned and her loved ones go nuts because the chance that she comes back unharmed came true and she didn't get maimed and or die.

These videos always give me a fucking military people did this shit vibe.

2
Crossfox17•

I didn't once think about the military when watching this video. All I could think about was how amazing a dog's devotion and attachment to a human can be. But yea, I have noticed a certain trend.

2
Magruber•

I'm really not into conspiracy theories but I'm inclined to agree that it is a little suspicious.

2
GanasbinTagap•

We'll just wait for this account to get deleted.

edit: Okay notice the username is syri4u, almost like a reference to Syria, and the only comment he posted was about an incident in Syria, pretty detailed description too.

So... if this account is one of those rogue accounts that posts patriotic vids, why Syria? Perhaps a supporter of the Free Syria army trying to get American attention on whats going on in Syria? But wait, the city he mentioned isn't one that is being destroyed by the Syrian army. Or is it?

2
SuburbanLegend•

Even if this is some sort of strategy by the military, I don't mind. They are nice videos and I enjoy them. Whoever it is posting them, they are never deceptive in the title and they earn upvotes by being good content.

I just think that if someone is posting legitimate content that people want to see, they are not gaming reddit; they are using the site for its intended purpose.

2
stesch•
2
WeirdIdeasCO•

Has the OP replied to anyone? This is creepy.

2
wortwechsel•

From Anti-Flag's Anatomy Of Your Enemy:

Ninth step: Design propaganda to show that your soldiers
have feelings, hopes, families, and loved ones.
Make it clear that your soldiers are doing a duty;
they do not want or like to kill.
2
BottomContributor•

Oh who cares? Reddit is full of people saying they hate the military/police state but as soon as a military person or police officer posts on reddit, they will lick their anus relentlessly. I bet my comment will get downvoted to hell.

2

God can you imagine what awful mind altering drugs they gave that poor canine to make him act that way!

I wish I was a dog.

2
luna547•

It's fairly shocking how accurate this has turned out. At least this account made a pathetic attempt to appear like they're an actual user by posting a bit of garbage before this video.

1
gyunjgf•

A lot of people (I've heard most people too) don't read the comments, they just click on the links. And these people certainly don't check the submitter's history time they joined. So if the military really is manipulating reddit to spread pro-military messages, it's probably working.

1
zoobiezoob•

Even if it is I don't see anything wrong with it

1
mobiuszeroone•

I remember someone who claimed to be part of a merketing team who used Reddit, specifically on accounts that were months old, to promote new films. He claimed that they had even watched parts of The Dark Knight Rises to look for memes that could be made such a screenshot with scumbag batman written on it or whatever. The idea being that it could catch on and get people talking about the film more.

It seems pretty conceivable.

1
nosex_justdeath•

So glad this is the top comment, I thought the exact same thing.

1
burgess_meredith_jr•

The fact that the posters of these videos never respond to our "conspiracy" charges, speaks volumes as far as I'm concerned. If he was legit, why wouldn't he just say something? Anything. "Fuck you guys." or "I just thought it was a cool video."

Also, just in general, who posts a link and doesn't respond to a single comment?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
JulieAndrews•

I don't understand how videos like this can be considered propaganda, though. Don't they just illustrate, in emotional terms, and from the perspective of the family, how much it sucks to go away to war? My reaction is "yep, there's another reason you'd be crazy to join the military and we're stupid for playing World-Police." I can't imagine that's a sentiment the military wants to promote.

1
spyfer•

Holy fuck dude, it's been 21 days since sublestern's last comment/post. And it was on the post where he posted his theory. Guys, what if he was shut down by the people who are doing this?

1
Oorion•

it'd be great if we could filter all the stuff off the front page from people who joined reddit after we did.

1
[deleted]•

dude this is totally true I can't believe that as a Spaniard I have been tricked by the US gov

1
pseudolobster•

You may want to add this ToR link to your post: http://www.reddit.com/r/TheoryOfReddit/comments/ukpfl/is_reddit_being_manipulated_by_the_us_army/

Before I clicked comments I spent ten minutes searching for this because I noticed the account age, and this really is a thing.

1
musicaficta•

And does it sound like the dog's yelps don't match the video at all? Maybe it's just me, but the entire time I was watching this it looked like the dog was just jumping on her and licking her, as a normal dog does when its owner comes home from being gone for any period of time. Without the yelps, it's just a dog averagely excited to see its owner.

I don't have a ton of audio editing experience, but from the bit that I do know, I wanna say that those dog yelps were totally added in.

EDIT: :59 the dog's mouth is shut, yet barking.

1
Magnets•

It's fairly clear that the theory has now been shown to be correct.

1
open_ur_mind•

I don't doubt you, however. I wouldn't be surprised if it was the military planting videos and completely missing their intended message. The only thing I take away from videos like these are that war is bad, and causes "suffering" to those who love you. I quoted suffering because it's more of an emotional suffering, such as the case of this dog. I think humans have the same emotion as the dog, but the dog just sucks at hiding it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
gremluk•

Ok. so there is a conspiracy here that strategically reminds people that the US military is full of good human beings that aren't pure evil. isn't that true? I appreciate all the research everyone is doing on this because I like to see all conspiracies exposed but i don't feel this is something to get so worked up about. At no point does any of these videos make me think the US military is a wonderful entity doing the force of good

1
anaclagon•

I thought I would share this article I read awhile ago-- Link

1
MarinesOP•

Another conspiracy: Maybe sublestern is the one posting all the videos and then he made this comment so it would look like he uncovered a government conspiracy...

1
[deleted]•

Hey guys! Join the Army... because after 2 years of heart-crushing separation that will probably end several relationships and may leave new friends dead in a foreign land... your pet will remember you!

1
[deleted]•

iirc the military has actually setup a "communications" division that acts like the military PR in occupying countries. like these people would go into forums to inform others of what US is actually trying to accomplish and dispel possible myths about the occupation (like they are taking over forever, etc.)

the key difference here was that these ppl needed to clearly identify themselves as working for the US and use only factual information. it was more of a learn their culture, help dispel myths and false conclusions, and extend goodwill and show them that US actually cares.

ofc this was for occupying countries and most likely anti-us countries but i can see a similar tactic being used within america as well. of course why they would hide their origins from us i do not know.

in the end reddit is a media and the US government has shown in the past that it tries its best to control the media and spread propaganda.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
artificeseal•

Remember... Reddit upvoted this.

1
[deleted]•

From: https://www.fbo.gov/index?_cview=0&id=6ef12558b44258382452fcf02942396a&mode=form&s=opportunity&tab=core

DARPA is soliciting innovative research proposals in the area of social media in strategic communication. Proposed research should investigate innovative approaches that enable revolutionary advances in science, devices, or systems. Specifically excluded is research that primarily results in evolutionary improvements to the existing state of practice. See the full DARPA-BAA-11-64 document attached.

1
Threedawg•

Wait, but he also posted a lot of other shit.

I don't think this is the same situation, as the other accounts only posted the one military post.

However he did post 3 other videos in 5 days, meaning I think it is just a Karma whoring account more than anything else.

0
luna547•

Nah, anyone can post three videos and a comment to make themselves look legit. The fact that virtually every single 'dog greeting soldier' video comes from accounts like this makes it harder to explain away.

7
Threedawg•

Actually, I have only seen one "dog" greeting soldier once before, that was forever ago and a friend posted it.

Usually they are pictures or human reactions, not dogs.

0
cyberslick188•

You know what he meant :P

-1
skakruk•

Oh God, comments like this make me lose faith in humanity. No offense but, are you stupid? Do you know how easy it is to click submit any video?

-2
sexbobomb91•

This is exactly what I was thinking.

0
andrew12361•

2 of his uploaded videos come from youtube accounts just as new and with names similar to his reddid name. Very4strange and Multi4funny.

0
[deleted]•

Came here to say the same thing; these "one of america's heroes returns from saving every life on the planet and everyone loves him because freedom" posts are annoying, and they're usually drummed up by accounts that are less than a week old. I was surprised to see this one had other subs.

Also note that the OP from the sub you linked to deleted his account. GEE, I WONDER WHY.

0
REEDnSTUFF•

Haha, i instantly checked his account to see if he actually posts.

0
agrey•

is there a subreddit dedicated to tracking down these posts and following up on the conspiracy?

/r/militarykarmaconspiracy or something?

0
Mtownsprts•

Damn reddit, you creepy.

0
ThatsPopetastic•

People like you make me hate reddit more and more every day. You are just like that guy who posted all of that BS about the nuclear "incident". You guys are just as gullible and naive and crazy as the "birthers".

0
ballstatemarine•

Some people are always just looking for something to get worked up over. We call them idiots.

2
winteriscoming2•

If the military is doing this they are fools. Someday it will be rooted out and they will have egg on their face. Instead, they should appoint an official social media liaison. This liaison could still post the positive videos and build a relationship with the community. They could also arrange AMAAs (clearly there would be security restrictions) with interesting members of the armed forces or have open recruiters who are willing to answer questions about a career in the armed forces.

For an example of a great community liaison see r/GameDeals and Tony the friendly Amazon Rep. He is open about his affiliation and even has flair revealing it, but he offers a lot to the community in addition to the game deals. His lead has been followed by other online distribution companies and their representatives are also building good reputations.

Large organizations are generally too afraid of tainting their polished image by truly engaging social media, but they are missing out on a huge opportunity.

-1
Futhermucker•

Right, because this video totally encourages me to join the US Military

-1
NinjaSkillz810•

No, it's not supposed to make you wanna join. It's supposed to put the military in a good light. "Look at this soldier coming home to a lovely family, a great home, and a beautiful loving dog."

Not the part where many don't have the proper care once they return home. (PTSD, amputees, depression, etc.)

Then there's this:This year, more US troops have died this year from suicide than combat.

Edit: I got that article from mybillionthaccount's comment in this thread.

2
BallsackTBaghard•

Shieeeeeeet, nigga.

-1
UpDown•

I'm going to downvote this for that reason. Even if its not true, fuck this user anyways because they are no good intentions regardless of how you think about it.

-1
[deleted]•

Oh, totally.

Anything anti-establishment or war is heavily censored on Reddit. I posted a video of an ex-big pharma rep talking about how the whole industry is a sham, and it gets swept right under the rug. Posted a video about Obama's murdered ex-gay lovers mother coming out about her sons death and the police's refusal to investigate it, another one swept right under the rug.

However, if the video has anything to do with glamorizing murderers or shallow materialism, put it right on top!

-1
[deleted]•

hey, thanks for using your top karmawhore status for good. i have more respect for you now.

-2
imnotabus•

I'm so glad this is the top comment.

-2
[deleted]•

let me adjust my tinfoil hat, and yes it seems like the whole conspiracy theory is actually a reality.

-2
saltyjohnson•

So?

-3
saltyjohnson•

Perhaps I should elaborate. It's unlikely that the military has thousands of people to upvote things like this, so they're posting videos that real people actually like. So what if it's propaganda? Although I don't know what they're propagandizing... this video sure doesn't say to me "War Is Good", "Join The Military", "etc". But I'm only saying all this because I'm obviously caught under their evil brainwashing spell, so you should disregard everything I ever say because it's all actually the government.

1
Herpderpg•

how about you shut the fuck up and stop creating controversy over something that should be positive

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8
[deleted]•

Meh who gives a shit. Unless you're a weak-minded clown this video is nothing more than a heart-warming reunion, not some propaganda that has somehow turned me pro-war.

-9
[deleted]•

You're a propagandist's dream.

10
luna547•

Heart-warming reunion = propaganda. It's intended to make you sympathize more with soldiers and thereby perpetuates the cult of the uniform. It causes people to lavish soldiers with praise and uphold them as peerless examples of American exceptionalism. People end up talking about how much they appreciate military service, how the job is tough but necessary, and how such true blue American scenes like this can only happen because the military keeps us safe.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2011/mar/17/us-spy-operation-social-networks

5
RustyRobot•

Cat's reaction to soldier returning from Afghanistan.

522
Helter-Skeletor•

"...sup."

BZZZZzzzzzzzzzzooooonnngggggggg

Edit: Who knew my most popular comment so far would be imitating one of those door bazoingy-things.

312
owennerd123•
61
Helter-Skeletor•

Oh sweet lord, I was NOT expecting it to actually make the sound, and my speakers were on full...brb, need to find my pants.

30
[deleted]•

[deleted]

30
Maseycakes•

nothing like being walked in on while playing with that thing.

1
TheWarHam•

if you hit it a bunch of times really fast, it sounds like a truck driving away

6
ChunkArcade•

I fucking love reddit.

2
Shindig_7•

I had more fun on that website than I should have

2
SimonSays_•

It's 1:55 am and I can't stop laughing at it! I'm literally in tears it's hilarious!

1
[deleted]•

Click like crazy, Its a car! :D

0
mrhotsauce•

I rarely actually laugh out loud on the internet, but that got me.

20
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Flyinhighinthesky•

That Onomatopia was perfect, upvote!

-9
Pwoshi•

Nice try, but it's spelled Onomatopoeia ;)

4
Flyinhighinthesky•

Close enough for Govt. work.

1
CalmItDown•

It's really a utopia of noms

0
[deleted]•

Nah wasn't there that video where the cat wouldn't leave the soldiers side when he came back? I remember it being posted on here ages ago

14
option_i•

I want to see that!

5
imabigsofty•
5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
Natsuu•

Sure, but the cat missed his pets.

16
mahade•

Exactly. Petting a cat right above the tail is like giving them catnip. You're practically masturbating your cat.

2
Jeffooie•

Or this

10
missfrenchpress•

When I return from a week long trip, my cat is freaking out when I see him. Purring, rubbing on me, and meowing a lot. Not all cats are apathetic.

2
k43r•
1
iampaven•

Upvote for your bravery

1
Richard_Jae•

My cat is more like Audrey II.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
16miledetour•

nah that cat is just mad that someone ate his lasagna.

1
laller•

Oh gawd, I don't often laugh this much. So true, lol.

0
[deleted]•

Exactly. Let me see a pet cat that cares as much as this dog.

-4
x3tripleace3x•

the way a cat expresses it's love is very different than the way a dog does.

0
Foley1•

Dogs - Universally anti-war.

305
[deleted]•

Why are you being downvoted? Reddit is weird.

0
longhornmd•

Because Reddit is pro-cat, but dogs are easily better. Downvote me. I am not deleting this

176
[deleted]•

Couldnt agree more. I dont dislike cats but I'm a dog person 100%

64
bonesjones•

They are just plain awesome. You can't get a response like that from a cat, that doesn't include being teared to shreds.

30
jawbreakErica•

So brave

9

1
[deleted]•

I love you

7
[deleted]•

They both have their pros and cons but essentially do the same thing, provide humans companionship.

1
GroovyBoomstick•

Hahaha, dude, in anything even vaguely dog-related, someone inevitably makes a comment along the lines of "dogs rule, cats suck". Trust me, you're not gonna get downvoted. Honestly, why are dog people so competitive? Just chill and like what you want to like.

Also, the whole "Reddit is pro-cat" thing is bullshit... why would cat people downvote a comment in the thread of a dog video, which literally has nothing to do with cats?

1
TheMinister2811•

Since you asked.

1
FilterOutBullshit3•

I don't get how people get the idea that Reddit is mostly pro-cat. While they are pro-cat, they're more pro-dog. r/aww is ground-zero for lovable pet worship. The current tally on the front-page right now is:

8 cat posts

12 dog posts

0
ignore_my_name•

Ya I don't know a single dog that's in favour of war.

19
Macb3th•

Oh yeah? Whatabout Dog Fort and Red Lobster?

18
[deleted]•

This was my first lol of the day, good on you

4
ignore_my_name•

I can't speak for them I don't know them personally. I'm saying any dog I've known and spoke to about war hasn't had one good thing to say about it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
xenoposeidon•

Roman wardogs?

1
Foley1•

Go, you can't stop it now...

1
imafunghi•

because dogs aren't antiwar perhaps? Perhaps they aren't smart enough to understand war, and are descendants of killing machines (wolves) and would kill other animals if they have to? because its cheesy? Just a few possibilities for you.

1
TomSwirly•

Redditors are pretty pro-military, and very pro-dog, so statements like this are very disturbing to them.

1
growinglotus•

Because plenty of military families who get excited at the return of a soldier are not anti-war.

-6
[deleted]•

Oh I see! Foley1 said "dogs" are anti war. You then turn that into "military family" and make a claim that "military families" are not anti-war. Makes sense.

Oh wait...no. I'm mistaken. You're acctually an idiot.

2
growinglotus•

sorry, meant to say "not necessarily."

You're actually pretty mean.

1
stallscribble•

Dogs don't understand the concept of war. They chase their tail and eat their own shit.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Directors_Cut•

I love it when they get so excited, that they don't know what to do with themselves, so they just run around flipping out...

178
Swissguru•

As someone that has lived with a dog for all his life, this video made me tear up.

That dog was so fucking happy it was almost exploding from it =)

70
shriek•

I remember one time my dog did the exact same thing, not really flipped out but I was away from my home for couple of weeks and when I came back it started crying and jumping. I love dogs so much.

28
pr1ntscreen•

almost exploding from it

Concidering the site that hosts this video, this is a viable expression

11
MicrowaveSpace•

This is the first post on reddit that has actually legitimately made me cry.

1
azrhei•

It is like the dog equivalent of how people act on the on The Price Is Right gameshow. ZOMGWTFOMGWHARGARBLLL!111!!!1111!!1

17
Heelincal•

Complete brain disconnect.

1
SlightlyAmbiguous•

Lol I know, like when he went to go run in the opposite direction, and then stopped and started flipping the fuck out again? Oh my god that was so cute.

8
The_Magnificent•

My mother's dog acts like that if my mom is gone for even 5 minutes.

At that time it gets more annoying than anything else. xD

2
princess_shami•

The dog seemed to be screaming "mommy!" over and over again.

1
IvoryCoats•

Dogs love the smell of fresh blood..

1
henry82•
87
Whodini•

"do you want your spouse, children and pets to miss you uncontrollably? Wondering if you'll ever come home? Join the army!"

Btw, I'm not saying this isn't true. As a matter of fact I think you are right. Account is only a few days old.

Just seems like an odd message to send out.

18
henry82•

I think they're trying to show soldiers personal side. Rather than being perceived as killers, they're people representing the country, with family to support.

1
Whodini•

Makes sense.

1
sirhelix•

Yeah, and the posting account is now deleted, too. What a poor attempt at viral marketing.

15
Accidentus•

Well it's currently on the front page of reddit so...

12
sirhelix•

I was referring to the one linked to by the parent,

2
Mildcorma•

Viral marketing for what?!

All this video shows is that dogs miss people when they're deployed, and it only serves to make me more against staying in those countries fighting a sustained war. It doesn't make me want to go enlist.

EDIT: Sorry, apparently my opinion doesn't resonate well with people.. let me make myself more clear.

The guy who owns this channel gives his profits to charities that support military men and women. When we click on the video to watch it, we're giving money to those charities indirectly. You don't hurt people by watching, there's nothing bad about what this guy is doing. He's supporting people that need support and at the same time enabling you to feel good about watching youtube videos.

Please tell me what's bad about this. Don't tell me that creating new accounts is bad, because he's doing it to support a charity. If this was for personal gain then fucking A man, go get the pitchforks! But there really is nothing to get so angry about here...

-13
sirhelix•

Regardless of what the video does for you, it is a concerted effort to publicize the human side of the US Army. The posters of these videos are all very new accounts, post one or two things and then stop. When the posters are called out for being spam, the accounts get deleted. Why is there US Army spam? As the parent I was replying to said, it's some HR dude who thinks this is a good advertising tactic. You know, to get "the youth".

edit: Check out this post, from one of the parent's links. This is textbook viral marketing, but not necessarily driven by the US Army. It's a guy with a Youtube channel of welcome home videos that links to the Welcome Home Blog, and both are ad-supported. Proceeds from the ad revenue apparently go towards Army charities. Verdict is out on the extent of involvement the US Army may have. Do they know and not care? Does the guy work for the Army? Does he receive kickbacks for good publicity? Who knows.

10
The_Time_Lord•

And Reddit users on average have a higher education than average. So they get "smarter" younger people and all they have to do is post comments. Seems genius if you're a guy in a board room.

1
Mildcorma•

Or maybe he just wants to make more money for causes that matter? The issue with you guys is most of you look past what is usually a simple thing.

This guy wants to make money for his charities, and given that the video is relevant and interesting he stands to make quite a bit for them. Good for him.

Why are people so fucking mad? We get to see happy videos and make money for charities -without actually spending a penny-. Who wins? We all win.

0
NullCharacter•

But... it's not even the Army... the woman in the video is an Airman.

Honestly, I'm disturbed by the paranoia displayed in the comments here. Reddit begs for original and new content, and then when they get it they do everything they can to discount it.

It's just a woman returning home from war and her dog's reaction. How can you derive some deep, national-level conspiracy from that?

Frankly: You're insane.

-3
[deleted]•

every single time I see a post about a "troop" returning home, I see how old the account is and it never stops amazing me. 4 days >_>

71
[deleted]•

Man, they were way too busy being patriotic to make a reddit account. They just got home, so they just made their account! Duh!

-4
dalco•

it makes me sad to see redditors making the same mistakes we did in vietnam. we should take care of our troops, not disown them. doesnt matter if you agree with war or not, which I dont.

-8
wankers_remorse•

nobody's saying that. I'm pretty sure most people that don't support the politics of any of the wars we're currently in still support the troops

1
LurkerLuke•

My dog acts like this if I return after 2 hours

48
DirtychrisT•

Haha. My beagle acts like that if I come home from the grocery store, except more howling.

16
IGottaSnake•

The noise a beagle can make is just unbelievable. I have a beagle mix, but it is my basset that really sounds like he is being murdered when he barks.

Beagles when dad comes home

Also, loudness 1:35 is when it gets all beagle-screams-at-you.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
My_Face_Is•

Mine too. I can't even imagine when I leave for college!

5
feeb75•

Beagle owner here too, and yeah they are pretty much like that all the time lol

2
JudgeEric•

Dogs aren't able to think in time like people do. When you leave your house they aren't able to think "Its alright he'll be back in a few hours". Makes you feel guilty about leaving them at all!

1
silverain13•

AWW. That was sweet. I loved how it took a second to recognize her and then boom that dogs universe just flipped.

39
Takuya-san•

The dog probably assumed she was dead since she never came home. Sad thing is that she could have been dead, and all over a war the US shouldn't have been in. Fuck the US military.

3
realigion•

Totally the military's choice what war they go into. Totally.

0
Takuya-san•

Well... it kind of is. The military advises the government on its decisions, and the government basically just agrees.

-1
vanguard199•

The propaganda machine is active again...(Edit: referencing...sublestern's theory on the military's use of reddit)

37
growinglotus•

It's like the dog is crying with happiness. Very sweet.

34
[deleted]•

I like how it took the dog a couple seconds to process she was back before flipping out.

20
SlightlyAmbiguous•

"IT'S YOU?! IS IT REALLY YOU?? OH MY GOD IT IS YOU!!!"

24
Magna_Sharta•

What's interesting is a dog has no concept of "I'll be home in X months" so once she had been gone long enough, it's possible the dog thought she was dead. Coming home like that must've been like the dog having it's owner come back to life. That beagle will probably start a religion based on the glorious resurrection of the alpha female, and go around the house/neighborhood baying the good news.

31
flignir•

I think you're basically right. Makes me wonder how complicated the dog's concept of "dead' is. Do you think he thought he recognized his owner but paused because he had some concept in mind that the dead don't come back? Do they miss their old owners so much that they can still smell them...and don't believe the real smell until something else reinforces it? Man, i wish they could talk.

Nonetheless, it's obvious he's ecstatic. He doesn't need to talk to convey that.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Diggens•

I always wondered if we accidentally messed up our dog mentally. We took care of my grandparents dog during the winter then he lived with them the rest of the time.

The first time he left, my dog was seemingly mourning. She would rub her nose raw trying to "bury" things in the corners of the house and was generally mopey. Then my grandparent's dog magically came back to life a few months later and my dog was so happy.

This repeated for several winters.

6
Frankenstooge•

It never ceases to amaze me how capable dogs can be in showing their feelings.

And they are always true. They are incapable of any form of deceit.

27
the_electric_gigolo•

I'm always afraid of liveleak videos that somebody gets shot, stabbed or blown into pieces... pleasant surprise.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

13
Thergal•

I don't think anyone here is getting fooled by how fucked up war actually is, we just like sweet movies. Don't worry.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Thergal•

I think most if not all Redditors can differentiate this manipulation, we like heartwarming things sure, but I'd say with ease that we aren't going to be fooled by the noble status that they are trying to impose, we are living in the age of information now. I'd say it could have worked 30 or so years ago, the wastness of the internet daily shows us the dark side of it. However people that get into the military probably do it knowing how shit it is, but they are just in a situation that forces them to do it. I.e no cash and things in those nature.

My point is that they aren't going to manipulate us in that way, because the majority of us know the dark side, and do not find it noble. But there are certain situations where it just dosen't matter what you think about it if you're forced because of your situation in life. That is another matter wich needs to be adressed.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
BadgerRed•

Watching videos like these doesn't make me want to join the military. I don't understand how watching the joy someone feels when their loved one returns home could make someone pro-war. If anything, it reminds me how my peaceful beliefs are correct. I want people to be home and be welcomed with open arms. Not returned in a body bag.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Mein_Tarnaccount•

Exactly. It's about associating war not with shot children and raped women, but with loving dogs and happy hugs. Creating warm feelings when watching videos of american soldiers.

Edit: And downvoting those who call you out on it.

-4
shortbuss•

if this is how a DOG reacts when a person RETURNS from war, just imagine the devastation of a CHILD when their PARENT DIES in war.

fuck war.

13
ForeignStranger•

I expected the dog to get aggresive because of title + liveleak... was not disappointed.

8
chupacabrando•

If only

3
lippindots•

This makes me less likely to join the Air Force! I want to be home with those I love!

NICE TRY, AIR FORCE PR REP.!

7

She's not in the Army. She's in the Air Force.

4
lippindots•

Right, just edited for mistake.

2

Thank you kindly.

1
SleepyEel•

My dog acts like this every time I get home from work. He's a bit of a drama queen.

7
joedude•

Brand spanking new account posting pro american military content, holy fuck this is perfectly fine for you guys?

7
MeMyMoo•

Yes, damn them for wanting us to be happy about our solders comming home!

-4
borisbelov•

this is why dogs are so much better than cats

6
Snuffz•

This is why - Wait why do all these turn into pointless wars.

Have whatever you want, personally, both ftw.

2
GroovyBoomstick•

Exactly, I don't get why this shit has to turn into proof that one animal is better than the other? Just chill out and enjoy your pet.

2
Takuya-san•

Personally, neither ftw. Don't get me wrong, I love dogs and cats a shit ton and wish I had one as a companion, but the amount of food and resources wasted on dogs and cats is just phenomenal. Imagine if the $48 billion dollars spent in America alone on pets were spent elsewhere... say... ending world hunger. Some estimates put ending world hunger at around $30 billion a year for 10 years in order to develop all hungry nations to a self-sustaining point. I'd much rather donate the money I would spend on a pet to World Vision and other charities, and that's exactly what I do each week.

So yeah, call me an asshole, but I look down on anyone who has more than one pet. Even one pet is a waste of resources technically, but it's good for mental health so I guess it's okay to be selfish in that respect.

Edit: Yep, downvote me when you know I'm right. I suppose you have to justify your needless waste of resources somehow. I'm not against feeding currently living animals, but buying pets increases demand for said pets, meaning more pets are bred and more resources wasted.

-2