Amelia - I can't help but love her

Spoiler

From PP to Greys S18E18 - I love Amelia.

These last couple seasons have been the worst. She hasn't communicated with her partner. BUT when she DOES communicate with a friend, she explains the rational behind her relationship decisions (She absolutely should communicate with her partner but we're all [especially on tv] imperfect people). Amelia takes her sobriety/mental health seriously and acknowledges what is best for her and does that. It may seem "selfish" but if you're not taking care of yourself, you can't properly take care of anyone else.

Posted May 20, 2022, 5:18 AM UTC

2010
macademicnut•

I used to like her but I feel like the show tried too hard to get us “on her side” if that makes sense? Like, sometimes she does stuff that’s wrong, but the show pretends it’s right. I also think her storylines are too repetitive- I mean this is literally the fourth time she’s having kid drama with a romantic partner

12

I actually agree with this!! This is also my exact reason why I can’t go on board with Amelia.

4
Triple_777•

The only reason the show needed to get us "on her side" was because they screwed up her writing early on. She was incredible on PP and a fan favorite.

0
EpicGlitter•

Amelia's my favorite character, I like her unironically, past present future. (spoilers for last night, 18x18) >!what I disliked most about last night was seeing her so sad (apparently heartbroken? but not sure?) again.!<

!in her relationship with Kai I thought she did communicate with her partner though? she said in The Makings of You (I think that was 18x12) that Scout is her #1 priority, and being a mom is something she loves most about herself. if 18x18 was truly a break-up, Kai seemed to be the one making a relationship decision (ending it), not Amelia. so yea if this post is addressing last night I don't quite understand - I don't remember Amelia doing anything last night that was flawed or bad communication etc?!<

7
maricopa888•

Totally agree. I didn't like the writing here at all. We've barely seen Kai, and the implication is that they were beginning a solid thing. Then, instead of the 2 of them talking about kids like any normal couple, Kai takes the nuclear route and blows it up.

4
_edenadele_OP•

Last night it was more how Amelia talked about Kia to Teddy that I loved. It was her talking to a friend about how she truly felt & it was so wonderfully put. You are right, Amelia has communicated pretty well with Kia and if this is the end, they made that decision not Amelia.

4
EpicGlitter•

I loved the scene I think you're talking about, where Teddy's kind of stressing about Leo, and Amelia talks to her about Kai, being ok with ambiguity and uncertainty, fully loving someone you can't always define, etc. but if that's the right scene, I think it was two weeks ago, ep 18x17?

2
_edenadele_OP•

Oh probably. I always watch the week before right before the new episode airs so it's fresh in my mind.

2
maricopa888•

As always, I have mixed emotions on her. I do think Caterina's acting last night was some of the best I've seen on the show. It's hard to explain, because it's just how I reacted.

But on her sobriety, I've never been a fan of how she handles that. She has a way of indirectly involving others in it, or subtly manipulating them as if her success relies on them. No, this is why support groups exist.

I've always had a love hate relationship with her! There are things I absolutely love and then....the rest.

2
WoollyMonster•

She's one of my favorites. Her and Jo. I guess I like the ones that others tend to hate.

2