r/Anki•
onthelambda

Looking for opinions/suggestions on changing anki's default settings

Question

Somewhat embarrassingly, despite extremely heavy anki use, I really haven't tweaked the default settings that much. I'm more or less using all of the defaults, except for my initial steps, which are, somewhat unscientifically, "1m 20m 90m 3h" for new cards and "20m 90m 3h" for lapsed cards.

I've been doing some research and of course, opinions seem to vary pretty heavily. I realize there is no perfect configuration, but I think I can certainly get to a better place. I've searched here, of course, and opinions vary...so I figured I'd post my thoughts and people can opine here as well :P

For context, this is all language learning related.

Some things I was considering, but really I welcome any suggestions or thoughts. I am almost certainly in ease hell, though thus far I've just been sort of powering through. But I figure there's no time like the present to rationalize my use of anki a bit :) I'm not tied to any of the below, it just seemed reasonable based on a little research, but I have tried to avoid obsessing too much since there really isn't a "perfect" answers. I just want reasonable settings that will reduce long term anki use without destroying retention

  • I was thinking of using the settings recommend by this post https://tatsumoto.neocities.org/blog/setting-up-anki.html with this plugin https://ankiweb.net/shared/info/819023663 to normalize my existing cards
  • I was thinking of using the straight rewards plugin on top of that
  • I was thinking of setting "new interval" to 30% for word decks and 60% for sentence decks
  • probably the one I'm least sure about, I was thinking of setting my initial steps to something like "1m 20m 90m 3h 4d" and then set the graduating interval to "8d", or some general idea like that. I've seen this advocated by a lot of people, and the idea makes sense, but others sort of say it doesn't matter.
  • Related to the above but more important for me would be the lapse interval (these days my new cards is dwarfed by my existing reviewed cards)...setting new interval to something >0 I think covers this, but it seems like there'd be an argument for doing the same "1m 20m 90m 3h 4d" here, though perhaps with a low minimum interval (or just a minimum interval of 4d) and let new interval do its thing?

Again, not married to any of the above, just stuff that seemed reasonable, but I'm very open to other approaches. I've also seen the auto-ease plugin, which seems interesting, but I like the above because it is pretty conceptually easy and plays nice with anki's core algorithm. Auto-ease seems like a more drastic departure, which doesn't mean it's bad of course, it could be much better...but this is just why, given moderate but not heavy research, the above appealed to me. I welcome thoughts!

I'm especially interested for any thoughts on the question of initial steps and graduating interval, both for new cards and, in particular, for lapses

Posted May 21, 2022, 2:32 PM UTC

14
guppy114•

get the true retention addon and adjust to your retention rates accordingly

2
egeniolanguages•

Doesn’t sound bad. Are you doing lots of reviews in the day? If not, move to 1m 20m 12h 1d 4d or the like. My graduation is now 6d but this depends on the language and personal results.

1
Evelf•

I was in the same situation a few weeks ago, having using Anki for language learning intensively for a long time without thinking too much about most of the settings. Recently I've read a lot of articles and did some changes, I'm satisfied with my current settings but I may tweak them a little more in the future.

I use AnkiDroid for reviews and AnkiDesktop to edit/manage the card. I sync both way every day. Because of AnkiDroid's limitation, I have to stay on the V2 scheduler. I thought about having different settings for my Vocabulary and my Sentences decks, but I decided it was simpler to use the same values for most settings (but two different option group, because the number of new cards and max number of review per day are different).

  • My New Cards "steps" in minutes: 10 960 3840 9360
  • The meaning:
    • First step is just 10 minutes
    • Then: 24h minus 8h, 72h minus 8h, 156h (= 6.5 days)

The minus 8h is a trick for a problem I had but you may not (I'll explain bellow). The last value should be a round number of day minus 8h too, but I don't want to change it now as it works as it is.

Note : When I was experimenting, I changed those values a lot, it seemed to "disturb" AnkiDroid regarding the cards in learning phase (Some of them almost graduated went back to step 2 or things like that). Not a real problem, but it's annoying, and I'm not totally sure I understood how that kind of changes are managed by the scheduler algorithm.

The logic for those values:

  • I want to see the new cards at least twice the first day, but I don't think hard-coding more mandatory steps for the first review is a good idea. There's some words or sentences easier than others, I don't need to see them more than twice, hitting "easy" would get them out of the learning phase right away and I don't want that. For more difficult card, I can hit "again" multiple times the first day without any consequences.
  • 1 days, 3 days, ~6.5 days was just an experiment and it seems to work well for me.
  • The minus 8h comes from the fact that I like new+learning+reviews to be mixed for a given deck. I noticed that with multiple of 24h the learning cards came at the end. It may depend on the time of the review the day before.. Honestly I don't know, but it seems to work for me with this trick :D
  • graduating interval: 13 days (it roughly follow the progression of the learning phase)
  • easy interval: 15 days (for the last step I like to see different values between "good" and "easy")

Lapses settings:

  • Steps in minutes: 10 2400 8160 (10 minutes, 2 days minus 8h, 6 days minus 8h)
  • new interval: 50%
  • minimum interval: 11 days (follows the progression of the re-learning phase)
  • leech: 6 lapses, tag only

You may want to look at statistics to get an idea of what's going on:

I keep un eye on the number of cards I currently have in (re)learning phase. No matter how many time you hit "again", they don't get tagged as leech. I had a few words I couldn't learn, so I saw them every day for a few days, then I checked in the desktop browser and suspended them for now. You can sort by the total number of reviews in the desktop browser if you add the column, then filter only the card in learning.

I didn't try RefoldEase, I'm patiently waiting for my cards to heal with StraightReward. Because I didn't review for a few months at some point, some of my cards with the lowest ease have a very long interval, so it's balanced, but I may change my mind at some point and reset the ease factor with an addon.

There's some advice I don't like in the article you linked:

  • avoiding "Hard" and "Easy" buttons: I use them once in a while, I think with StraightReward activated it's ok to do so to get some nuance on the easiness of a card.
  • the initial value of 131% ease + increasing the interval modifier: it solves the "ease hell" problem, but it does so by removing the possibility for a card to be noted as "difficult", I prefer a more subtle approach.

I wish Anki would have a built-in algorithm for "healing" cards once you fixed them. There's a lot of plugins and articles, and a lot brain power spend in solving a problem that shouldn't exist :/

1
onthelambdaOP•

Thank you very much for taking the time, I really appreciate it!

1