r/Alienware•
binro01

Thinking about a new R10 for video editing.

Purchasing

Looking at the following specs for an R10.
AMD® Ryzen™ 9 5900

NVIDIA® GeForce RTX™ 3080, 10 GB GDDR6X

32 GB, 2 x 16 GB, DDR4, 3200 MHz, XMP

1TB M.2 PCIe NVMe SSD (Boot) + 2TB 7200RPM SATA 6Gb/s (Storage)

Dark Side of the Moon chassis with High-Performance CPU Liquid Cooling and 1000W Power Supply

I can get it for $2,086.36 USD + sales tax ($142.74) Which is pretty much the same cost for me to build... (Slightly better CPU with the 5900X on build, but with video editing I will never OC my CPU.. To much danger in crashing and losing a ton of work) I also get zero percent financing with Dell vs, purchasing components and me building...

It feels like a reasonable deal. And I believe it will handle my video editing quite well. (4k YouTube videos with not much in the way of special effects)

I also do some AAA gaming. But not like hours a day.. Maybe a couple hours a week if that. It will primarily be for editing.

I'm kinda done being my own tech support thus why I'm looking at a pre built with warranty support.

I have an R10 that my son games on constantly. 3700X/5700 XT setup which gave us no issues whatsoever over the last 2 years, so I'm comfortable with Alienware desktops.

I do understand the hassles of upgrading RAM, but I feel confidant that I can always find a second set of 2x16 modules on ebay when the time comes if ever. (I don't see myself ever doing 8k video or heavy SFX/multitasking so, no real "need" for 64GB)

The only thing I worry about is heat in the R10. Any thoughts on this build in this chassis?

Posted May 25, 2022, 3:20 AM UTC

127
YOLOFireGuy•

Be sure to get liquid cooling and you should be good to go

3
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

Yea. I did spec it with liquid cooling. I have the liquid cooling on my other R10 and would not build one without it.

2
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

Does the price point look reasonable?

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Tdw75•

I have this machine - with a 5900x, 64 gigs of quad channel ram, and a 2tb m.2 drive...I've replaced all the fans inside with quieter ones, because this machine is very poorly designed. It's very noisy... And it's airflow absolutely sucks.

I have buyers regret all the time, because to actually get something with airflow, will be a new motherboard, power supply, case and cooling that will cost around $800.

Do yourself a favor, and just get a different brand of non-proprietary parts.

I see your other comments about - that it's fine.

No!!! It way underperforms for the parts inside because of heat issues."But I can return it" ... Just do more research and get something from a company that actually has a reasonable case and standard parts inside instead.

3
mau5atron•
2
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

I seen that video before. I agree with him on some points and on others. Well let’s just say. He has a huge bias against anything other than custom builds.

I understand. I have built many a PC. But I just have way too much going on for me to build one and be tech support if things go sideways.

2
mau5atron•

It’s not a bias. Just pointing out the fact that Dell fucks over consumers with cheap materials. I can’t stop you from buying an R10. But I’m also letting you know you won’t be getting your moneys worth.

2
PookiasX17R1•

It’s not bias but half of what he says doesn’t matter because he specced it with the air cooler. Buy an R10 in a reasonable configuration and with a liquid cooler and you’ll be just fine. Ffs endless gamers nexus shitposting

2
MogRulesArea51mR1/Alienware 17R4/M15R5 Ryzen•

Give it a few weeks and they will go back to whatever sub they came from.

1
nickierv•

But you shouldn't be able to order dumb/stupid/otherwise bad configurations. They have it for the PSU, why not for the rest?

1
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

I actually found a video with the exact chassis (R10 with Liquid Cooling CPU), exact same CPU and GPU, even the same exact SSD. The Max temp the GPU got in over 2 months of testing the system was 70.7C during gaming and the max CPU temp was 75C. Idled at 37-40C. That's not too bad at all, for stock.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sGKB9t-pYSI

If I find that it gets too hot, I'll just send the thing back. What's making my choice even easier is the 10% cash back on Rakuten right now for dell, which puts this rig at $1877.72 (or a little over 2k with taxes)

Can I build for that price? Yea... But do I want to? I think I will see how this works, and if its way too hot, and I'm not getting the value out of the components I'm paying for, I will just send it on back and build. No skin off my back and potentially a huge time savings for me and peace of mind with a decent warrantee.

1
nickierv•

I have seen the 'but the warranty' argument of things before. DIY parts come with a 3 year warranty at minimum. Whats that going to be another $250? More?

Any bets that there are some non standard power settings to keep the thermals under control.

2
Raztax•

Everyone has their own reasons for buying or building. You mentioned 0% financing which would be a nice bonus, but warranty is definitely not a reason to go with a prebuilt.

In general you will get significantly more warranty building than you will with Dell unless of course you pay extra which seems silly to me.

1
Raztax•

He has a huge bias against anything other than custom builds.

It's not bias when you have the test results to back up your claims. Dell is not the only OEM that they shit on.

2
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

They crap on every OEM. The site is a PC builders site. This is what they do. If they didn't they would lose half their niche audience and subscriptions. Its called preaching to the choir. I know the game. I have a substantial YouTube community. You go against their inclinations, and desires, what you get is a decline in views, revenue and subscribers. Its ok. I understand. Its a business. But do NOT expect a clean review.

I have built my own, I also own a prebuilt R10 from 2 years ago. I did some tweaking with software (Clock Tuner For Ryzen, Adrenaline, fan curve changes, etc., as well as repasting adding a push pull fan setup on the AIP) and the thing runs as good as thermally and performance wise as any custom build and I have the numbers to back it up. Just like a custom build you can't just pull things out of a box and be done with it. I know many prebuilt users are geared to that. But I'm not.

Believe me, I was thinking of building again. But I'm now 52, I have a very intense job as a Principal Software engineer in a very large SAAS company. I also have a growing YouTube Channel and I vacation ALOT. I just don't have the time or energy to deal with building and being tech support for a PC that I use primarily for video editing 4k videos.

1
Raztax•

They crap on every OEM.

They definitely have positive videos as well.

I am not against prebuilt machines at all, there are definitely good ones out there. It's just that Dell is my second to last choice (Acer is even worse imo) for several reasons.

1
mau5atron•

I have a 3080 Ti founders in my full tower case and that gets toasty unless I adjust the power limit and set a max temp limit. I can’t imagine you’ll be getting the performance you’re paying for with everything crammed and screaming for fresh air in that R10.

2
PookiasX17R1•

Here’s what I would do. There is a configuration on Dells website that shows one for about 28% off and comes preconfigured with 256 GB SSD, 6700 XT, and 8 GB of RAM. You can spec this one up with a 3080 and a better Ryzen CPU and it will be cheaper than the others because of the applied discount. Buy your own storage and RAM and upgrade it yourself, don’t overpay.

Rakuten is doing 10% cash back right now. Install that on your web browser and activate it before checkout. DPA5 gives you 5% off on a Dell Preferred account, and then use a spare email to sign up for emails and get a 10% off coupon, or Capital One Spring Rewards sign up will get you a 12% off coupon. You’ll be paying next to nothing for a 3080 build.

1
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

I hear you on the RAM and the storage. I just don't want to deal with finding good compatible RAM for the MoBo. I know there are "issues" with that. I can probably save a good 200.00 by doing that. Also, switching out the SSD myself will require either an external housing to clone, or a full OS rebuild and driver install., which is time that I really do not want to spend. I will be spending enough time to get the thermals right, and the CPU clock stable at a good temp with CTR 2.1 and a good GPU clock/thermal profile, and removing bloatware etc.

Every hour I'm messing around with my tools vs using them costs me about $75.00 per hour. So the extra 200.00 is OK with me, for the timesaving I get to immediately start getting the thing right and performing the best I can without having to pull out and getting parts in and wires routed, and OS's moved/cloned/rebuilt.

Using that build the only thing I cant add in is the 2TB HHD. I can only add in the 1TB HHD to pair up with the 1TB SSD. That being said, this configuration starting point gets to 2312.79, 2263.79 w/o the HDD, before the 10% Dell Email coupon. Which bring it down to 2081.51. The additional 5% off for DPA, We are now at $1935.54. $145.00 bucks cheaper, but no HDD. Not bad! Thanks for the tip. I'll just throw in my own secondary HDD, and save around $100.00...

I tried the capital one spring coupon for 12% off and Dell says the coupon expired.

1
binro01OPAurora R10 AMD•

So after some deep thoughts about this rig, with the potential cooling issues I will encounter and have to come up with solutions for, the Alienware R10 will not serve the purpose of being "Hands off" like I want a pre-built to be. So I decided to cancel the order before it hit production.

I love my Alienware devices. I own 1 desktop and 2 laptops right now. I just gave away a 10+ year old m11x R1 to my 10 year old nephew who is in love with the little device which still runs flawlessly.

I also owned other Alienware laptops that I have used for years and then sold to college students going away to school for great resale prices. So I naturally move to Alienware devices.

I was just extremely worried about that "mini" 3080 in that case with only 2 fans for airflow.

I had to undervolt my 5700 XT with a small overclock to keep performance at a little above stock at tame temps on that card, leaving some performance on the table.

I decided to go with a Lenovo Legion Tower 7i Gen 7 tower, with a i7-12700 CPU and a 3080. The cool thing is I now have the same thread count, with faster clocks on the CPU, I also have now 32GB of DDR5 4800MHz RAM vs DDR4 3200MHz RAM, which will help me a lot scrubbing through 4k video.

My cooling is also so much more superior with a twin fan AIO Liquid cooler for the CPU, and 4 case fans in a mesh well ventilated case.

The device was only 100.00 more than the Alienware, which I think is a reasonable upcharge for the DDR5 RAM and the CPU performance boost I will get. (I also got 10% cash back via Rakuten on the Lenovo site). I just hope to have as much "luck" and good experiences with Lenovo as I have had with Alienware.

1