Well, I just cancelled my Alienware R10 order and opted for a Legion Tower 7i Gen 7 Desktop

Advice/Other

I have been a very loyal Alienware customer. I currently own 2 Alienware laptops which run flawlessly and owned two older ones. One was given to my 10 year old nephew who adores the 10 year old m11x R1 which still runs perfectly and one was sold 2 years ago to a college student who loves the thing. I also own a 2 year old R10 with a 3700X and a 5700 XT GPU that my other son games on that has given me no problems but I had to tweak the heck out of the components to keep the temps tame in that cooling nightmare of a case, even with an AIO liquid cooled CPU.

So when I was looking for a new Desktop to replace my 1 year old Alienware laptop which will go to my kid who starts college in September, I naturally looked to Alienware.

I saw some decent deals on R10s but I was very worried about getting a 5900X with a 3080 in that case if I barely was able to tame a 3700X and a 5700 XT in the same case. I'm doing a lot of video editing now with my fledgling YouTube channel which is growing fast, so I wanted something with more cores and threads and some GPU horsepower and more memory than my current Alienware laptop has.

I posted on the Alienware forums about my thoughts and I was steered away from the R10s for that component makeup, the R13s and R14s were very pricey too. So one of the members there pointed me to the Legion towers.

Boy am I glad he did. I was able to get a great deal on a Legion Tower 7i Gen 7 Gaming desktop with the following specs:

  • i7 12700K with thee same thread count but faster clocks as the 5900X
  • DDR5 4800MHz RAM which is a huge upgrade over the R10s DDR4 3200MHz ram.
  • A 3080 Nvidia GPU
  • 1 TB PCIe SSD Gen 4 which will outperform the Gen 3 SSDs in the R10s
  • MUCH better cooling vs the R10s

The cost for the Lenovo Tower, including sales tax was $2358.43. Only $130.00 USD more than the Alienware R10, which I believe that is a reasonable upcharge for the DDR RAM, the slightly more powerful CPU and the much better cooling. I did loose my 2TB storage HDD in the shuffle, but I can easily add that into the case for a very cheap price.

Now here is the kicker, I also scored 10% cash back with Rakuten! So the 2199.00 Device cost me only 1980.00! (Sub 2k for this beast? Here is my money... Take it!)

Overall, I'm excited to give Lenovo a whirl. Hopefully the Tech Support will be as helpful as Alienware's was for the few times I had to engage them over the years.

Posted May 26, 2022, 2:18 AM UTC

55
Heliosvector•

What steers you towards built towers like this and not just building yourself? Not judging. Just curious as I personally never see the value.

2
PandasLOL•

I imagine, time, effort, and ease of support.

1
Ryankujoestar•

How much would it cost if OP were to build one individually?

1
binro01OP•

With the cash back from Rakuten I’m basically getting the same spec device for 400.00 less then building.

Yea I don’t get to choose my components, but the price and time savings + the added fact that I don’t have to troubleshoot and repair my device over the next 2 years is huge to me. My time is way to valuable to me. I have built many a desktop. I’m just at a point in my life now where I just don’t want to deal with the hassle.

I just want to tell the person on the other end of the line the issue, my suspected root cause and leave it at that and have them complete the job.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

You can also chat in real time on our beautiful Discord Server with wonderful community and Lenovo staff, make sure you check it out!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

How do you like the Lenovo tower? I'd love to hear impressions! Does 12th intel really make a difference and the DDR5?

I'm trying to decide between these two desktops as well but the price difference is about $360 CAD so it's not a easy decision for me. FYI, USD $130 USD should be around $170 CAD so the difference is more than doubled! Also, Rakuten deal for me is only 3% at Lenovo today. It was 6% yesterday.

At the moment, I'm leaning more towards R10 for cost savings. I can really use $360 for other items I need to buy. I'm little concerned about the cooling problem but didn't they say the liquid cooling helps out in this regard?

1
binro01OP•

So I wound up returning the Lenovo. Here is why.

  • All the pics on the site showed a 240mm AIO cooler. I made the incorrect assumption that a 12700K would surely be a system deemed to have such a cooler. Wrong. It was air cooled by a tower cooler incapable of cooling the chip under load. (It immediately hit 100C and thermal throttled).
    • I said, well lets undervolt this with XTU.XTU would not run with Lenovo's OS install because they prevent this by using an XTU STK. Had to do a clean install of windows to get XTU working. Got a stable undervolt to use the CPU at stock but there was no chance of overclocking the K chip. Money lost because I can't use the chip to its full potential with this cooler due to the need to undervolt it to keep it reasonably cool. (Under 90C.. Still not great...)
    • I figured I could fix the cooler problem with a good Noctua cooler since I didn't want to potentially deal with getting an AIO working properly with the Lenovo Motherboard to manage fan speeds/etc, but the backplate was glued to the back. I didn't want to deal with potentially breaking that motherboard when removing the backplate.
  • The DDR5 RAM could not run at the rated speed of 4800MHz. Because the BIOS did not allow the use of its XMP profiles. I updated the BIOS to the most recent on Lenovo's website. Still nothing.. Memory running at the base speed of 4400MHz. Called Lenovo tech support to see if I'm missing anything. They were so inept. I had to explain for 30 minutes the issue. I even had to walk them through the why. Finally talked to someone at a higher level, and then and only then they fessed up that the BIOS needs an update to allow the faster profiles to run. There was no ETA for said BIOS update. So basically they lied on their website about the speed the memory will run at.. Well technically not lying. It can run at that speed. JUST NOT NOW with the way the BIOS is.

I wound up building my own. 12700K w/ 3080, 32GB of DDR4 RAM. (There is really no difference between the 2 right now, in 2-3 years that might change), I have a 360mm AIO cooler on the CPU, with 3 Corsair fans. In a great airflow mesh case from Corsair. I also have a much better 1TB SSD in there running at proper Gen4 speeds. The one Lenovo put in there was pure garbage. The cost to build was about 370.00 less than the Lenovo.

1
binro01OP•

The R10 is a cooling nightmare. I would steer far far away from it. Also, you will never be able to upgrade the GPU to an over the counter GPU. the case is just too small.

Also the 12Gen CPUs are amazing. Finally Intel got back into the game with AMD and are competing also in price as well as performance.

I would recommend building your own now. Prices have come back to normal on the GPUs, but if you had get a prebuilt, take a look at Digital Storm's prebuilt Lynx options. For 1700.00 (Best Config) it is a pretty good system. You can easily add some more memory and sell the 3070 and upgrade to a 3080 at a very reasonable price, and be at a very similar price point as the Lenovo.

If you can, the best option is building your own, but I can understand why people will not go down that route.

1

Thanks for sharing your experience and tips. I would have loved to build my own rig if it was 15 years ago but now I have no time to do extra research. I've spent too much time already researching gaming laptops and desktops last week so it was time for me to make a final decision and ended up going with the Legion tower today.

Despite the issues that you have pointed out, I'm just glad to be able to enjoy some 4K/60fps gaming on my projector and really excited about trying out VR racing and flying games! It was fun playing with PS4 and PS5 until now but it doesn't really have many games at the moment. I guess I will only use it for Sony's exclusives moving forward.

Btw, I received additional 8% off from Lenovo because I told the online agent that my wife is in grad school. I was ready to go through the verification process but the agent made it so easy for me to take that discount. Plus 3% Rokuten cash back is nice. I'm going to put all that savings towards a VR headset!

1
binro01OP•

Awesome! The Lenovo is a decent machine. It just really needs a better cooler for the CPU. Think about a Noctua cooler so you can take advantage of that 12700K. The only issue you might come up against is changing out the backplate for the Noctua's.

I was kind of in the same boat as you with the build option. I was intimidated about the new boards with the new headers for all those fans and lighting, but it actually was quite easy. Just had to get out my glasses and use the Magnify app on the iPhone to help out my 52 year old eyes out. Only took me about 4 total hours to build out and be installed and running smoothly.

1

Hahaha. I know what you mean by taking phone pictures to see some fine prints. I was starting to have similar issues with my eyes (getting old!) so I was shopping for 17 inch QHD screen laptops last week. Then I realized I can add little more money and get much more powerful gaming desktop and just use the high resolution projector and monitors I already have. I can still maintain mobile status at home by adding PC tower stand with casters on it.

Anyways, thanks again for your kind replies and help. So glad to be back on pc gaming community!

1