Did I rule initiative wrong, or were my players greedy?
Hi all. Experienced DM that had to resolve yet another initiative issue. Feedback appreciated. Let's get to the nitty gritty :
- Scenario is that players are in the same room as the BBEG. PCs are all in various disguises, pretending to be servants around the dinner table. They succeed.
- Their plan is that an allied NPC casts hold person on BBEG, then they all attack.
- They wait (even if hold person fails) as they want the BBEG think it's the NPC that betrayed them and for the NPC to absorb the BBEGs initial attacks because the NPC has strong natural healing powers.
Initiative is rolled. I as the DM know the initiative order is in this order:
- Ranger PC
- BBEG
- Remaining PCs in various orders
- NPC to cast hold person
- Paladin PC
I narratively described how the NPC and BBEG are talking, discussing overthrowing the kingdom, but then the NPC begins to grab for their spellcasting focus and waving hands, i.e. they have shown aggressive action, but haven't taken it yet. The equivalent for reaching for your gun to shoot it. But since NPC rolled so shit I asked the Ranger PC what they're doing as they're first :
- Ranger : "Ok so is it done?
- DM : "No, NPC is lower in the initiative."
- Ranger : "I wait then."
- DM : "As in you ready your action or your lower yourself in the initiative order?"
- Ranger : "No I have 3 attacks as Gloomstalker. I want to attack."
- DM : "So make your attacks."
- Ranger (and other players) : "But the NPC didn't go yet. We wanted to wait."
- DM : "Well yeah, your split second reflexes are faster than the NPC who wants to make the first move."
- Players : "But is the BBEG before the NPC?"
- DM : "You don't know the initiative order yet, these are split second decisions."
- Several minute arguing where they want their turns but also want to wait where I literally said "You can't have your cake and eat it too. The NPC didn't roll highest on the initiative, this is what sometimes happens."
- Result was the Ranger (visibly irritated) readied their action to after the NPC casts. The BBEG then went, I RPed that they stand up from the table, ask what the fuck is going on and casts Mirror Image on themselves. The remaining party members then take their full turns to attack. Finally NPC starts their turn, Hold Person is counter-spelled by the BBEG.
- Ranger is visibly frustrated they lost their initial Gloomstalker burst.
So my logic is as follows :
- I ruled that nobody is surprised. The BBEG was actively looking at the NPC and is a high level sorcerer. They have their bodyguards literally next door, so this wasn't a "having dinner with my husband I trust above all." -> Is this ok?
- I do not reveal initiative order of NPCs before they actually go to initiative because it's all split second decisions and in theory happen almost at the same time. -> Is this ok?
- I told the Gloomstalker player due to the initiative order they can't have their burst and also not be suspicious. It would either be "Minimal damage dealt, but no damage taken", or "Burst damage dealt, possibly a lot of damage taken." -> Is this ok?
EDIT : Thank you so much all for the points. I'm reading through each and every one. I have already seen mention that maybe not including the PCs in initiative for the first round of combat (because they wanted to wait) was also the way to go RAW.
I do allow permanently lowering themselves in the initiative to the level of NPC at my table, so with this homebrew rule (which I offered at the time) would be a guarantee they have a full turn in 1st round of combat and would be better than just adding themselves on the 2nd round of initiative (since for those that would roll lower the BBEG would have gone twice already), but this was lost in the discussions and slight frustrations.
EDIT 2 : Thank you for all of the input, this blew up way more than I thought it will. I'll have a chat with my players (important to mention is we play together for many years and are grown up adults, actual friends, so resolving this will be super easy, barely an inconvenience. This post was more for me to gather valuable feedback, which I got way more valuable information than I thought I would get. Cheers.
Posted May 26, 2022, 1:12 PM UTC · edited