r/jazzguitar•
sub-ox

How to improve as a jazz guitarist?

I’ve been feeling frustrated with my practice and my ability as a jazz guitarist recently. I practice daily, and I try to stay focused during my practicing, keeping a log, working towards goals. I also show up to a local jam periodically to get outside my comfort zone. But I feel like I never really improve, that I’m always playing at about the same, not-very-great level. Can anyone recommend any ways that I could get more from my practice? Maybe books that you liked? Or goals to work toward? Anything like that would be a huge help. I know this is a pretty I’ll-formed question. I just feel like I’m not getting much from my practicing these days. By way of context, I’ve been playing guitar for many years. I took lessons for years as a teenager (I’m 50 now), and have done a few workshops here and there more recently. For most of my guitar-playing life I was a guitarist for various punk rock bands. I started working with jazz about five years ago. Thanks!

Posted May 26, 2022, 5:40 PM UTC

1024
frrgc•

Honestly, instead of just recommending things to practice without knowing anything about you, this looks like a prime example of when you should look up local musicians for consistent private lessons. Find who's playing you love in your community, go to their gig, and ask them about lessons

11
OffBrandNameBrand•

This is the way

2
TheDroidNextDoor•

##This Is The Way Leaderboard

1. u/Mando_Bot 501217 times.

2. u/Flat-Yogurtcloset293 475777 times.

3. u/GMEshares 70943 times.

..

135333. u/OffBrandNameBrand 2 times.


^(^beep ^boop ^I ^am ^a ^bot ^and ^this ^action ^was ^performed ^automatically.)

5
the-bends•

It's hard to give a great answer to this without hearing your playing or at least what you feel is lacking about your playing. There's a few things I can suggest working on that I know are beneficial:

​

  1. Record yourself improvising for two minutes. Play it back and make a list of the things you don't like that you do and a list of things you do like. Take one item off of each list, for the thing you don't like, either work on omitting it from your playing, or improving it to make it sound better to yourself, for the thing you do like, dig deeper on it and see if it can be expanded upon or used in more creative ways.
  2. Play along with recordings you like, and specifically try to imitate the time feel and texture of the players you like. This is sort of a poor man's transcription but a super helpful practice. Just try to do a song or two each time you practice.
  3. Go really deep on a tool you don't have. The players who are better and who stand out are the ones who put in the work most others are avoiding because it sounds like it's hard or too much work. You don't get to be the latter type and the complain about improving. Mastery of guitar is really an accumulation of mastery of many small things. Make one of your goals to master an idea. Do you know how to play all seven diatonic arpeggios in each modal position? Do you know all your modes of melodic minor and know how to employ them? You get the idea, and once you've gotten a big subject under your fingers then go deeper.
  4. Line writing. Take a standard, let's say Stella by Starlight for example, divide it into logical chord passages (E-7b5 and A7b9 would be one section, C-11 and F7 would be another section, etc.). Compose 5 or 10 lines on each section, utilizing different concepts you are practicing (maybe it's approach notes, or multiple harmonic ideas on a single chord). Once you have multiple sections start connecting them and see how different ideas sound flowing into one another. The ones you end up liking the most learn in all keys and play around with variation and permutation. I will sometimes even buy musicians omnibooks and extract one of their lines over a chord section, then alter it to work over different changes.
  5. Time Feel. This is honestly the most important one and usually what makes the biggest difference in overall sound. Dig around on youtube for timing exercises and use them religiously. Use a looping station or something so you can get feedback on your playing immediately and constantly be analyzing your time feel. If you want to go a step further then get a book on jazz articulation for horn players, and learn how to apply those ideas to guitar.

​

I hope something in here helps you.

11

Good stuff, this post should be permanently shown at the top of this sub

5
the-bends•

You're too kind! I feel like I'd have to get a little more granular for that sort of thing. I have been thinking about writing a post on line composition to trot out some educational ideas I have, maybe I should get around to it...

3
sub-oxOP•

This is all super helpful. Many thanks.

I’m going to go upstairs and try to play along with a couple tunes I’ve been working on right now.

2
Silversky615•

As a not so advanced player, been playing and listening to the music for 5 years (Played guitar a lot longer), what’s helping me right now is transcribing every day for 2 hours or more. Even just an hour a day would be enough to figure out a nice line that you like and find ways to make it your own.

Can’t really tell you how to get to the next level since I’m not there myself

2
morchalrorgon•

Patterns for Jazz by Jerry Coker, Forward Motion by Hal Galper

2
Tschicc•

Great welcome, note that ; so the feeling of "not getting better" is a constant to all of us, every musician is "almost there, always". Given your bio, and assuming that you are a "visual" player and recommend that you need to get away from the visual-perspective, understand what is happening under your fingers and why it sounds as it sounds, what the notes are doing to the music. Four-Part-Harmony is great for that but maybe it'd be overblowing for you.

Learn songs from the top of your head.

Play only roots & sing the melody; sing the roots play the melody.

Play the roots and the melody.

Play the roots with the thirds and sevenths.

Learn the sound of those notes. Learn what the notes are doing with the song; functional harmony.

2
sub-oxOP•

It’s definitely the case that I’m a “visual” player, and that’s one of my main frustrations, not being successful at moving past that.

I’ve worked hard to learn functional harmony, and I actually feel like I’ve made some progress there. The hard part is translating that to action once the beat starts and I’m actually trying to play. I feel like, in the heat of the moment, I almost always revert to muscle memory and the visual patterns I’ve built, for better or worse, over years of habitual playing.

1
Tschicc•

heat of the moment, I almost always revert to muscle memory and the visual patterns I’ve built, for better or worse, over years of habitual playing.

...and this is what makes you feel stuck. Learn the notes on the fretboard, do what I described above it'll help for a long ride, it'll make everything feel natural. Just don't be afraid anymore and enjoy every note you are playing. No more crossword puzzles. No more brain twisting.

1
the_bird_lives•

Play with other (better if possible) musicians and get some lessons! Recording either is helpful as well.

1
sub-oxOP•

Yeah. Starting to play out with other musicians has definitely helped. Tho it’s also drawn my attention to my limitations.

1
the_bird_lives•

What do you mean limitations?

1
sub-oxOP•

Playing alongside musicians with more skill, or at least more experience, is super instructive, and I think it has helped my playing a lot. But it’s humbling, as well. It give ms rise to that feeling: wow, there’s no way I’ll have time to learn what I want to know.

1
JazzRider•

I’m not hearing anything about transcribing in your practice. This is the quickest way to improvement.

1
sub-oxOP•

True. It’s not a big part of what I’m doing. My main stumbling block in terms of transcription is choosing solos to work on. But I know there are recommendations out there for novice transcribers. I’ll look for some.

2
[deleted]•

I recommend the book Jazz Improvsation for Guitar: A Melodic Approach by Garrison Fewell. He teaches, to my ears, very tasteful and musical phrases and how to analyze them. And how to compose your own solo over a couple standards. With a very Wes-esque approach to triads. Check it out!

1
vagabond251•
1
sub-oxOP•

Thanks. I looked over those and based on them, started my own transcription of Chet bakers solo from a recording of Summertime.

Any recommendations on software to use for writing your transcriptions? I’m just used pencil and paper at this point.

2
vagabond251•

I'm glad it got you inspired (if I'm reading right)! When I was doing these I used Sibelius 4-6. My Dad uses the latest version of Cubase I think for his arrangements.

I think I did a number of these on paper just because it was a little quicker for me starting out but I eventually switched to digital so I wouldn't lose my sheet music!

1
Ok_Raspberry8535•

Playing along to horn player solos on YouTube is helping me get better recently. I’ve been stuck for years

1
Woodnstrings•

I really like the list from bends, especially number one, record yourself and see where you want/need practice. Not knowing your level, I would suggest improvising with gypsy jazz for awhile. The song structures are less complex "Please don't talk about me when I'm gone" and "All of me (why not take all of me)" so you can get some confidence working on songs that have changes that are more readily felt/heard, and lay a foundation for more complex stuff later.

1