Banned for reporting 3 comments

I just got banned for 14 days due to report abuse. I reported 3 comments that were all low effort and avoiding the topic of discussion. Apparently I'm just not allowed to report comments that simply say "Lol".

Posted May 27, 2022, 5:46 AM UTC

337
ausmomo•

Rule 3, Low Effort, is a very subjective rule. If I were you I'd not bother reporting based on Rule 3.

What you think is low effort might be acceptable to others.

Save your reporting for clear breaches eg abuse.

3
StoicBoffin•

Yes, absolutely. One poster's harmless bit of banter is another mod's low-effort shitpost.

8
InvisibleHeatOP•

Why even have it as a rule if you're not allowed to report comments that you think breach it?

3
ausmomo•

You're absolutely allowed to. My point is it's the *hardest* report to get right. Get it wrong too many times, and you'll be pinged for report abuse.

2
InvisibleHeatOP•

I reported 3 comments, one of which was removed. I got banned for that.

Sounds to me like you're straight up not allowed to report on that rule.

3
InvisibleHeatOP•

Whoever is downvoting every comment an Auspol mod makes, please stop.

2

Appreciate the sentiment. I trust that it isn't you.

Since you've brought this to the public forum and have given consent, I will provide full transparency here:

People are entitled to due process in the real world, and it is something the we do believe in being fair with here - now, you will have received ModMail response a couple of hours ago now to that effect, that I elevated on the fly and perhaps out the cart before the horse, and that I had reversed your ban, and seek to review, with a possible apology in it for you. Have you not received this ModMail?

It is true that I did not first seek confirmation, this time, as this pattern, this phenomenon is something which seems to be an affect of arguing with u/InvisibleHeat - and has been confirmed correctly to be so in the past, by admins when put to them for review, despite you claiming at the time that you were not report abusing.

Now, you have also said in response to chats with us that you thought X and Y comments should be reported as low effort commentary, last time. Thus acknowledging your alignment with those specific actions.

It gets a bit Boy Who Cried Wolf. But it should still be reviewed properly, hence the current status of the ban reversal.

However it is fair to say that we really should be mroe certain than 'quite', because that still leaves room for human error.

FWIW I agreed with what you were saying, but that's besides the point of the allegations of misusing reports in an attempt to get the other persons comments removed - which was the allegation I acted on in administering a ban in line with the normal length increase.

I am aware of standing bans you have received outside of this sub, and allegations which have been made. I don't care for them. Whilst that may add to the picture, in theory, I don't think they should be relevant and we will continue not to consider them in anything we do.

Reports can't be unsubmitted, false or true ones. Accurate ones I am actually thankful for. Perhaps this time, after many instances of abuse of this exact specific nature, you were indeed treated unfairly by a hasty decision on the fly which ought to be corrected.

I don't however believe that it was the commentary that you're saying it was. I do generally have good judgement, I think.

What I am going to do is look for the comments which have collected reports, and punctuated by comments removed by user and thus obfuscation their involvement in. If I don't find any, you will most certainly be vindicated. If I do, they will be referred to the admins for further examination - and I will ask them quite specifically whether they can look into the possibility that you might be getting framed. To be fair, that is a possibility.

At the end of the day, if you then come up clean you will most certainly get my most humble apology, and it will be separate, and it will be public record.

We do not intend at all to be unfair. Does that sound reasonable?

2
InvisibleHeatOP•

People are entitled to due process in the real world, and it is something the we do believe in being fair with here - now, you will have received ModMail response a couple of hours ago now to that effect, that I elevated on the fly and perhaps out the cart before the horse, and that I had reversed your ban, and seek to review, with a possible apology in it for you. Have you not received this ModMail?

I have received the mod mail saying that it's been temporarily reversed.

It is true that I did not first seek confirmation, this time, as this pattern, this phenomenon is something which seems to be an affect of arguing with u/InvisibleHeat - and has been confirmed correctly to be so in the past, by admins when put to them for review, despite you claiming at the time that you were not report abusing.

I still don't believe that I was, but have since greatly reduced the amount of reporting I do anyway.

Reports can't be unsubmitted, false or true ones. Accurate ones I am actually thankful for. Perhaps this time, after many instances of abuse of this exact specific nature, you were indeed treated unfairly by a hasty decision on the fly which ought to be corrected.

I appreciate this.

What I am going to do is look for the comments which have collected reports, and punctuated by comments removed by user and thus obfuscation their involvement in. If I don't find any, you will most certainly be vindicated. If I do, they will be referred to the admins for further examination - and I will ask them quite specifically whether they can look into the possibility that you might be getting framed. To be fair, that is a possibility.

I don't think they'd need to make comments, just be stalking my comments and reporting comments that I reply to. I'm not saying it's likely that this is happening but I think it's possible it's happened in the past, and I worry that if I'm put on a "report any more comments and you'll be permabanned" situation, someone could easily do this once and result in me being banned.

At the end of the day, if you then come up clean you will most certainly get my most humble apology, and it will be separate, and it will be public record.

We do not intend at all to be unfair. Does that sound reasonable?

Sounds reasonable. Cheers.

2
InvisibleHeatOP•

I've just noticed 1 of the comments I reported got removed, which makes it even weirder.

1

This is a misrepresentation of the comments you were banned for, and doesn't mention that this is the third of fourth strike for this same exact issue.

I am currently at work, will follow you up ASAP.

1
InvisibleHeatOP•

These are the 3 comments I reported:

Lol...

Well more insightful than your comment, which (obviously) is not saying much.....

The level of ignorance....

And yes, this is the 3rd time I've been temp banned for reporting a couple of comments. Not sure how that's relevant to the fact that these comments are all low effort and avoiding the topic.

2

This is a misrepresentation of the comments you were banned for.

I was under the impression that only site admins were capable of user level attribution?

2
Xakire•

The admins have previously confirmed this user having report abused.

We can put two and two together. If it is common for in exchanges between this user and others for all comments of the person Invisible is arguing with to suddenly be reported, even when they are fine, then especially given his track record, we are able to make a pretty educated guess while we refer it to the admins.

3
InvisibleHeatOP•

So essentially if someone was to report every comment that I replied to I could be banned for it?

I reported 3 comments that were all low effort and avoiding the topic. Hardly "all comments of the person Invisible is arguing with to suddenly be reported".

What's the point of having a report function if I get banned for using it in good faith?

1
endersai•

I was under the impression that only site admins were capable of user level attribution?

It really depends.

When two people argue, and we get reports on one of the person's comments, and those reports occur just before the other person posts, it's not especially hard to pick up the breadcrumb trail.

2
InvisibleHeatOP•

So someone could very easily just report every comment I reply to and get me banned. Cool.

2

You are correct. u/InvisibleHeat seeing as you have made a public thread, which is perfectly fine, do you mind if I elaborate on this and where it relates to a past history?

1
InvisibleHeatOP•

Sure, go ahead. I'm not sure how you're going to justify banning someone for reporting 3 low effort comments though, especially since 1 was upheld.

1