War and Peace: 2007 or 2016? Which version do you like?

Discussion

I started 2007 (because I'm low key in love with Clemence Poesy), but my teenager asked why I didn't watch "the one with the Riddler from Batman" instead? I had missed there was a newer version.

Is one better than the other, in your opinion?

Fun Friday topic. :)

Posted May 27, 2022, 8:44 PM UTC

28
BalsamicBasil•

"the one with the Riddler from Batman"

Lolll oh god that makes me feel old. I suppose actors become known for their blockbuster roles, eh Alan Rickman?

I absolutely loved the 2016 adaptation and have watched it twice. I've yet to read War and Peace, so idk how faithful it is to the book.

I haven't seen the 2007 adaptation, so I can't review it or compare. I understand the 2007 miniseries is in French and Italian (also maybe German?) with actors of various nationalities, while the 2016 adaptation is by the BBC, so it's entirely in English with British actors (with the exception of Paul Dano). If that makes a difference...I'm guessing not, if you're a big fan of Clemence Poesy.

Finally, I'll just add that I have heard really great things about the much older 1966 Soviet adaptation (which is of course in Russian), although I have never seen it myself. Vox even wrote an article about it. I'd be curious if any other people on this sub have seen it. I might check it out myself sometime soon because I see it's streaming on HBO Max.

4
freeneedle•

I love the 2016 version and have seen it multiple times

3
CourageMesAmies•

The version shown in the US and on the US dvd is severely cut from what was shown on UK tv.

2
freeneedle•

That’s too bad, I found it very well done. I’ve signed back up for Hulu several times just to watch it again

2
CourageMesAmies•

I found the dvd in a thrift store for $1. When I watched it, I remembered how it had been cut to bits. (When it aired on uk tv, I watched it on BBC iplayer using a vpn.)

2
blankcheesecake•

For context, I haven’t read the book or seen the 2007 version, but I quite liked the 2016 one! I would definitely rewatch it.

1
CourageMesAmies•

I love the old 1970s miniseries the best. The 2016 one is not really War and Peace, imo, but I still like it. The Pan European version is okay, I call it “War and Peace light.”

1
steampunkunicorn01•

The 2016 version is the second best version I have ever seen (the best being the Russian version) I haven't seen the 2007 version, so I can't say how it compares

1