The Effectiveness of Gun Laws
I'm a supporter of the 2A, specifically the version that starts with, "A well-regulated militia..." And I appreciate Vaush's basic arguments, as far as they go.
From what I can remember, he supports background checks, waiting periods, and voluntary buybacks. But he has an overall skepticism about the effectiveness of gun control laws in America, because of the absurd number of firearms already in circulation, as well as the gun fetishization endemic to our culture.
But if he's going to talk about or debate this subject, he could do with brushing up on the relevant literature regarding gun regulations and safety laws. For someone who is usually sociologically rigorous in backing up his arguments, he seems to have a pretty big blind spot about the data we have about gun violence.
There are some studies that give some clarity to the issue, and there are specific policies they indicate would be helpful. Here are a few I found with a quick search (I'm sure the community could dig up some more if he wanted):
The Impact of State Firearm Laws on Homicide and Suicide Deaths in the USA, 1991–2016: a Panel Study
Universal background checks were associated with a 14.9% (95% CI, 5.2–23.6%) reduction in overall homicide rates, violent misdemeanor laws were associated with a 18.1% (95% CI, 8.1–27.1%) reduction in homicide, and “shall issue” laws were associated with a 9.0% (95% CI, 1.1–17.4%) increase in homicide. These laws were significantly associated only with firearm-related homicide rates, not non-firearm-related homicide rates. None of the other laws examined were consistently related to overall homicide or suicide rates.
What Do We Know About the Association Between Firearm Legislation and Firearm-Related Injuries?
Evidence from 130 studies in 10 countries suggests that in certain nations the simultaneous implementation of laws targeting multiple firearms restrictions is associated with reductions in firearm deaths. Laws restricting the purchase of (e.g., background checks) and access to (e.g., safer storage) firearms are also associated with lower rates of intimate partner homicides and firearm unintentional deaths in children, respectively.
Gun Violence: Prediction, Prevention, and Policy
Firearm prohibitions for high-risk groups — domestic violence offenders, persons convicted of violent misdemeanor crimes, and individuals with mental illness who have been adjudicated as being a threat to themselves or to others — have been shown to reduce violence. The licensing of handgun purchasers, background check requirements for all gun sales, and close oversight of retail gun sellers can reduce the diversion of guns to criminals.
Two policies-universal background checks and "may issue" laws that required a heightened showing of suitability for concealed carry-were associated with lower firearm homicide rates in large cities but were not associated with firearm homicide rates in suburban and rural areas. In contrast, laws that prohibited gun possession by people convicted of a violent misdemeanor were associated with lower firearm homicide rates in suburban and rural areas, but were not associated with firearm homicide rates in large cities. Permit requirements were associated with lower firearm homicide rates in both large cities and suburban and rural areas.
Edit: Apparently Vaush is planning a research stream for tomorrow. I'm sure he'll find a lot of good studies, and probably these exact ones. But if anyone reading this actually watches his streams live, feel free to pass these links along to make sure.
Posted May 27, 2022, 11:27 PM UTC · edited
I still find it weird to encounter on the current left, the same arguments I used to have with my gun-hoarding right-wing dad in the 90s.
this is absolutely a talking point i've heard from the right wing innumerable times.
It has an excluded middle fallacy in it. The US has lots of guns, yes. But the options are not limited to "we've rounded up every gun in the country" and "we do not regulate guns at all".
There's an entire spectrum in between those positions, and the differences in gun violence we see between our states and cities (based on the local and surrounded gun laws) is representative of the fact that moving across this spectrum also yields vastly different outcomes in the amount of gun violence and deaths we encounter.
Making guns just somewhat harder to obtain for people likely to do violence is possible, and effective, and that's been demonstrated. We've known this forever. We had a whole national discussion around it in 1993 with the Brady Bill and waiting periods.
Absolutely, and couple this with the public support for these 'middle ground' policies, and the anti-gun control discourse seems even more disconnected from reality.
A strong majority of gun owners, and even a strong majority of NRA members, support universal background checks.
Between emotion-based stuff like Vaush's take, and emotion-based stuff like banning "assault rifles" (an impossibility because that's not actually a category of weapon), it makes a rational discussion really difficult.
We have to engage with the reality of what's going on and what our political system allows for. The Brady Bill was struct down by courts on 10th amendment grounds. That means that any new legislation at the Federal level has to avoid taking on "powers not enumerated in the constitution" (especially with the current court, jesus fuck).
My first impulse would be to withhold some necessary state funding again until states pass legislation compatible with Federal guidelines (this worked and was deemed constitutional with the drinking age change to 21), but nobody is having this discussion at all because guns are like fucking hormone totems that make everyone irrational.
I think you mean "assault weapon" and not "assault rifle." I just looked it up on Wikipedia and it gave a definition. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assault_rifle
Yeah it's 'assault weapon' which is the somewhat vague term, while 'assault rifle' is a real class of firearm technically not available for civilian use. This is because AR-15s don't have selective fire, which means semi-auto plus fully automatic/burst fire.
But in reality, the anti gun control crowd are being super pedantic, because except in specific cases, fully automatic weapons wouldn't increase the body count of a mass shooting, and a well-trained shooter can fire a semi-auto rifle very quickly with extremely high accuracy. Full auto is used in the military for suppressive fire or like, clearing a trench or whatever.
For all practical purposes, the AR-15 and all other medium caliber semi-automatic rifles are equivalent to assault rifles.
And 'assault weapons' have been defined, at least in the now defunct Federal Assault Weapons Ban. The NRA just doesn't like the definition.
I think it's important to begin any discussion about gun control with an assurance that safe and responsible gun owners will always be able to keep their guns.
There simply is no political will for mass gun confiscation or mandatory buybacks, no practical way to ban semi-automatic firearms, etc. In America, these are just emotional talking points that are amplified with glee by the NRA.
Also, the Brady Bill wasn't struck down, only the part that mandated state officials conduct background checks on behalf of the federal government. The rest of the law stood, and then the NICS came online the next year making it kind of a moot question.
The system is inadequate, of course, and needs to be made more comprehensive. And you're right that it's a legal mine field even if we had a relatively even-handed Supreme Court. But if we had 60 votes in the Senate I'm sure we could get some well-crafted legislation through that would have a significant impact.